Everton is in a precarious position in the Premier League, and Dyche was seen as a manager who could guarantee their survival despite the team's poor form and lack of goals. Sacking him mid-season, especially without a clear replacement, risks destabilizing the team and increasing the likelihood of relegation.
New owners often seek to implement their own vision, which includes appointing a new manager. However, sacking Dyche mid-season could disrupt the team's stability, especially given his track record of keeping Everton in the Premier League despite challenges like points deductions and financial constraints.
While Moyes has a strong connection to Everton, concerns include whether he would take the job without guarantees of new signings in the January transfer window and if he is willing to manage a team in a relegation battle. His success at West Ham suggests he could steady the ship, but Everton's current situation is risky.
Potter brings a clear style of play focused on playing through the lines and flexibility in formations. His ability to adapt during games and develop young players could provide West Ham with a fresh direction, though the pressure of managing a club with high expectations will be a challenge.
Data suggests the 'new manager bounce' is largely a myth, with about 50% of teams showing improvement after a managerial change. Factors like fixture difficulty and player motivation play a role, but overall, the impact of a new manager is inconsistent and not guaranteed.
Why is it a big gamble for Everton to sack Sean Dyche now? Would David Moyes be a good appointment for the Toffees? Does a ‘new manager bounce’ really exist?
Gary, Alan and Micah also discuss Graham Potter’s appointment at West Ham after Julen Lopetegui was sacked earlier this week.
Sign up to The Rest Is Football newsletter at therestisfootball.com
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices)