cover of episode The Power Of Political Advertising

The Power Of Political Advertising

2024/8/28
logo of podcast The NPR Politics Podcast

The NPR Politics Podcast

Chapters

Following Vice President Kamala Harris' entry into the 2024 presidential race, her campaign has launched a series of ads focusing on her biography and middle-class upbringing. These ads aim to familiarize voters with her background and policy stances.
  • Harris's campaign ads emphasize her middle-class upbringing and work experience.
  • The ads highlight her relatability and connection to everyday Americans.
  • This strategy aims to solidify her image among voters unfamiliar with her background.

Shownotes Transcript

This message comes from NPR sponsor Ford Mustang Mach-E. With the bold style and performance of a Mustang, this all-electric SUV offers seamless technology, so you never have to choose between what you want and what you need. More at Ford.com slash Mustang Mach-E.

Hi, this is Tony in St. Paul, Minnesota. I am at the Minnesota State Fair where I have already tried deep fried ranch dressing, a buffalo chicken cheese curd taco, and a focaccia ice cream sandwich. This podcast was recorded at 1:19 p.m. on Wednesday, August 28th, 2024. Things may have changed by the time you are listening to this, but I am going to be trying more new food at the Great Minnesota Get Together.

Okay, here's the show. A focaccia ice cream sandwich? I have been to the Minnesota State Fair and I have to say it is one of the best, if not the best state fair in the country. I would love to make it out there.

Hey there, it's the NPR Politics Podcast. I'm Deepa Shivaram. I cover the White House. I'm Stephen Fowler. I cover the campaign. And I'm Domenico Montanaro, senior political editor and correspondent. And today on the show, how campaigns are trying to portray their opponents. When the presidential race was between Joe Biden and Donald Trump, the playbook

for each side was straightforward. But now that Kamala Harris is the Democratic nominee, both her campaign and Trump's are racing to form visions of Harris in voters' minds. And Domenico, this has been playing out in all kinds of ways, right? But I want to focus on the ads that each campaign is putting out. And let's start with Harris. How is she portraying herself in her own ads?

Well, first of all, it's been a blitz of ads. I mean, across the seven swing states, the three blue wall states of Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania, and then the four Sunbelt states in the East, Georgia, and North Carolina, and out West, Arizona, and Nevada, of course.

You know, just in the past month, the top five ads, we've seen $100 million spent and they're all about Kamala Harris. And you know, Harris's campaign, obviously trying to put her in the best light. People know her name, but they're not totally familiar with her biography and all of her policy stances. And they're putting out very gauzy biographical ads, including this one, which is the most run ad

In the last month, more than 46,000 airings in the seven states. She grew up in a middle-class home. She was the daughter of a working mom, and she worked at McDonald's while she got her degree.

Kamala Harris knows what it's like to be middle class. It definitely tracks with, you know, Kamala Harris's stump speech talking about being from the middle class. She talks about McDonald's all the time, so much so that former President Bill Clinton even joked about it in his address at the DNC last week. That is one way that she's being portrayed, right? On the other side of things, though, I mean, how is Donald Trump portraying Kamala Harris? Very well.

Very differently, as you can imagine, right? I mean, and they're very focused on trying to paint her as a San Francisco liberal. And in this case, this ad that's being run by MAGA Inc., Super PAC, that's supporting Trump, and it's an outside group, calling her a dangerous San Francisco liberal, goes after her in a pretty inflammatory way about her prosecutorial record, in particular about an MS-13 gang member who was in the country illegally and committed a triple murder.

A bit of a fact check. This is about a man named Edwin Ramos. Harris's office did not prosecute him in an earlier case because of a lack of evidence. He'd been pulled over because of illegally tinted windows, no front license plate, and

The passenger in the car jumped out of the vehicle when the cops stopped him and tossed a gun into the gutter. You know, he turned out that this gun was tied to a murder. The passenger was charged. But Harris said it would have been tougher to convict Ramos because it wasn't his gun necessarily. And, you know, he was then convicted by Harris's office of the triple murder. He's now serving three life sentences.

but nuance in facts you know don't always matter in politics this is really about perception especially somebody who's not as well known in views on as well formed about harris it's so interesting about this prosecutor that to me too because you know i covered comal harris's campaign and

in 2019 when she was first running for president. And the prosecutor identity was a liability for her amongst other Democrats, right? Like the left or wings of the party called her a cop, were really unhappy with her prosecutor record. And now it's like really being rallied around as this selling point of like, you have the prosecutor versus Donald Trump who's been convicted of felonies. And that's the contrast that the Harris campaign is trying to put up. But at the same

time, it's still kind of a liability, right? I mean, the fact that she called herself a progressive prosecutor puts that in the Trump campaign to sort of hit

Harris on her own criminal justice record. Stephen, how is the Trump campaign using this, planning to use this? What have you been seeing so far? Like many things in politics in recent years, this is a bit of a Rorschach test. I mean, to a lot of conservatives and Republicans, this idea of a progressive prosecutor is a really effective tool to turn out their own voters and

and say, look, this is what happens when Democrats are in charge of law and order. Bad things happen. You know, here in Georgia, there was an effort by state lawmakers to create this prosecutorial oversight commission to rein in rogue DAs that they say aren't

following the law and aren't prosecuting people. And we're seeing that at the national level, too, here with Harris. The fact that she was the top law enforcement official in California and has this record as a prosecutor is being used by Republicans as a cudgel to say that, look, she's soft on crime. Crime is spiking in urban centers where there are Democrats in charge.

And that record as a prosecutor is being used as a shorthand for saying they're not tough on crime. Republicans are tough on crime. And if you elect a Democrat, crime is coming to a city slash suburb slash small town near you.

And Domenico, I mean, I feel like this is where it gets really interesting for Harris, right? Because her last three or so years as vice president, you know, she had a lot of issues on her plate that didn't work for her. I mean, being the point person dealing with the root causes of migration, taking on voting rights.

Until the Dobbs decision came down, she didn't have a singular issue she was able to successfully take the lead on. Does that put her in a position now where highlighting her past career as a prosecutor kind of makes more sense than highlighting her time as vice president?

Well, she's lucky because as vice president, she can pick and choose what she wants to take credit for. I thought it was really interesting that in her acceptance speech, when she said that she organized 50 countries to unify, to fight against Russia, to support Ukraine, I just thought, wasn't Joe Biden president? And there's all these other things that obviously she doesn't want to necessarily take the blame for on things like immigration, for example.

I think that her prosecutorial record, what's interesting about this is that it's key for her to frame her prosecutorial record in a way that's to her advantage, which is what she came out doing very quickly and I think it's been an advantage for her.

not to have to go through a primary because she doesn't have to pivot to the middle. She's starting there. And it does like some of that, you know, picking and choosing that she's able to do. Stephen, it leaves a little bit of room, right, for for voters and for people to form a new opinion of her almost because she's able to kind of reframe her record in a way.

Exactly. So much of the last four years has been dominated by Joe Biden and Donald Trump. And voters have said, hey, we would like another option other than Joe Biden and Donald Trump. And now that the Democratic Party has done that,

Even though Kamala Harris is a sitting vice president and is a heartbeat away from being the president herself, even though it is the Biden-Harris administration, this sort of willingness by voters to seek change elsewhere has given her this blank slate where she can kind of be all things to all people and not really disappoint anyone yet. OK, we're going to take a quick break and more when we get back.

Support for NPR and the following message come from SimpliSafe Home Security. Feeling secure in your own home shouldn't be a luxury, it should be a given. That's why SimpliSafe is dedicated to providing protection and peace of mind to all families. With LiveGuard technology, SimpliSafe's 24-7 monitoring agents can act within 5 seconds of receiving your alarm.

Visit simplisafe.com slash NPR politics to save 50% on a new system with a free indoor security camera. There's no safe like SimpliSafe.

This message comes from NPR sponsor Ford, introducing the Mustang Mach-E Rally. Chief Engineer Donna Dixon shares why the Mustang Mach-E Rally takes EVs further into the performance space. The team has done a really good job of tuning in the vehicle to give you that confidence when you take it from pavement to dirt. The vehicle overall is more capable for that adventurous person to kind of take it where

where you might not have thought an electric vehicle could go. To learn more about the all-electric Mustang Mach-E Rally, go to Ford.com. This message comes from REI Co-op. From early morning runs to last-minute trips, make time to opt outside. When you're ready, REI has your gear, clothing, glasses, and advice. Visit REI.com slash opt outside.

And we're back. And the thing about ads is that they cost a lot of money. Domenico, who at this point has the spending advantage here? And where are the campaigns spending their money? Wow. I mean, there has been half a billion dollars spent between the Republicans and Democrats in the last month. We've already crossed the billion dollar threshold for the entirety of this election. And we're already heading toward almost two billion in

reservations for the rest of the fall campaign. I mean, this is just a whopping sum of money that they're spending. And, you know, you could say that they're flooding the airwaves and it might not make any difference. Well, clearly they feel like they need to do something to be able to move people a point or two at the very least. What we're seeing now is actually the Trump campaign is kind of stepping on the gas.

as well as outside groups that are supporting Trump, kind of coming to his aid here, the cavalry sort of rushing in to be able to help him as Harris has been starting to take the lead. And this is a really sharp turnaround from what we saw earlier in the campaign when Biden had a huge spending advantage, almost all to himself outside of Pennsylvania.

I think the thing also is that like as Harris takes the lead narrowly, right? So there's a lot of spending on their side, a lot of spending on Trump's side. One thing I want to focus on though is the advertising online, right? Digital ads are different than TV ads by design in terms of the audience they're reaching. How are the campaigns using the online ads maybe differently? Right.

Well, yeah. So this is where Harris has a huge advantage and a very different strategy than the Trump folks do. I mean, Harris is outspending Trump $72 million to $16 million online. It's like the Trump campaign and allies are basically ceding the internet to Kamala Harris. There's good reason for why Harris needs to use the internet and use online platforms to be able to reach people. It's because younger voters are

all online, whether it's TikTok, YouTube, whatever. Trump's folks are not necessarily in that cohort as much, and they need to reach more of the traditional Republican voters in these swing states. To the point about the messaging and the audience.

you know, there are completely different messages and sometimes completely different audiences that these ads are trying to reach. Sometimes, even though they're being put on the air in swing states, the ads aren't necessarily designed to reach voters. They're designed to get people talking about them and

media outlets to talk about them. And speaking of that, Deepa, the Harris campaign now has contrast ads that they're launching against Trump. What's that about? Yeah, I mean, the first one came out today because as we were talking about earlier, right, Harris has had to spend the last...

I've lost track of the weeks now, six weeks of this very brief campaign defining herself and putting out ads that tell her story. Now, though, they have to pivot, right? Less than 70 days to go. They're trying to do that contrast work. And as you can imagine, Project 2025 taking front and center in these ads.

Donald Trump's back and he's out for complete control. I will wield that power very aggressively. And he has a plan to get it. Detailed plans for exactly what our movement will do. It's called Project 2025.

A 922-page blueprint to make Donald Trump the most powerful president ever. And I think, you know, this focus on Project 2025, you will see the Harris campaign basically talk about this every single day from now until November. It's not going away. And it really has been a successful way to sort of peg Trump for Democratic voters and voters who are a little on the line about how they're feeling so far.

Yeah, Project 2025 is very unpopular with a lot of voters. You know, the Harris campaign is really going all in on Project 2025, this 900-page blueprint that was written by a lot of people with very close ties to Trump who could wind up in a future Trump administration. And, you know, with a lot of unpopular ideas, there is a Venn diagram between the Trump campaign and Project 2025 with a lot of policy overlap.

Some of the things Trump has disavowed, but that has not stopped the Harris campaign from trying to peg all of it to Trump. We're going to leave it there for today. I'm Deepa Shivaram. I cover the White House. I'm Stephen Fowler. I cover the campaign. And I'm Domenico Montanaro, senior political editor and correspondent. And thank you for listening to the NPR Politics Podcast.

Support for NPR and the following message come from Rosetta Stone, the perfect app to achieve your language learning goals no matter how busy your schedule gets. It's designed to maximize study time with immersive 10-minute lessons and audio practice for your commute. Plus, tailor your learning plan for specific objectives like travel. Get Rosetta Stone's lifetime membership for 50% off and unlimited access to 25 language courses. Learn more at rosettastone.com slash NPR.

This message is brought to you by NPR sponsor, Lisa, in collaboration with West Elm. Discover the new natural hybrid mattress, expertly crafted from natural latex and certified safe foams, designed with your health and the planet in mind. Visit leesa.com to learn more.