Manchester City's struggles stem from a combination of injuries to key players like Rodri, Kevin De Bruyne, and Phil Foden, as well as a rotating defense plagued by fitness issues. The midfield lacks physicality and strength, leading to vulnerabilities in counterattacks. Additionally, wingers are not scoring, and Erling Haaland has been rusty, resulting in a lethal combination of conceding goals easily and not scoring enough.
Manchester City's high defensive line is easily exploited due to their inability to win midfield battles, especially without Rodri. The team has committed more errors leading to shots this season than in four of the last five seasons. The midfield, including players like Gundogan and Bernardo Silva, lacks the physical dominance and ball retention that Rodri provides, leaving the defense exposed.
Ruben Amorim has brought a proactive approach to in-game management, making impactful substitutions that have improved United's performances. He has shown an ability to adapt tactically, such as using a back five to solidify the midfield. However, the team is still in a transitional phase, and Amorim has emphasized the need for time to fully implement his system and recruit suitable players.
For Manchester United, expectations are tempered, with a focus on building towards Amorim's system rather than immediate success. A top-five finish or a deep Europa League run would be considered a success. For Manchester City, the goal is to stabilize and secure a top-four finish, with a rebuild expected in the summer. Both clubs are in transitional phases, and immediate results are secondary to long-term progress.
The Manchester derby is significant as both clubs are looking for a turning point in their seasons. For Manchester City, a win could boost morale but won't solve underlying issues like injuries and lack of physicality in midfield. For Manchester United, a victory could serve as a catalyst for momentum under Amorim. However, the game holds less importance in the broader title race compared to previous years.
Pep Guardiola has maintained a consistent approach, emphasizing the need to stay level-headed and focus on daily solutions. Despite the team's poor form, he has not lost the dressing room, and the players remain committed. Guardiola has acknowledged the team's limitations and continues to experiment tactically, though injuries have restricted his ability to fully implement changes.
Manchester City writer Sam Lee, Manchester writer Mark Citchley and tactics writer Thom Harris join Michael Bailey for a Manchester derby roundtable.
With Pep Guardiola's side picking up just one win in their last 10 games, the panel dissect why it's still going wrong and look at whether Sunday's game presents an opportunity to bounce back.
Manchester United have lost their last two Premier League games - but after coming from behind to win in Plzeň - are Ruben Amorim's side showing signs of moving in the right direction?
Plus, we look at the fixtures elsewhere with drop ins from the club podcasts across The Athletic FC.
Host: Michael Bailey
With: Sam Lee, Mark Citchley, Thom Harris
Executive Producer: Adey Moorhead
Producer: Jay Beale
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices)