cover of episode Matinee Monday: The Island

Matinee Monday: The Island

2024/11/11
logo of podcast How Did This Get Made?

How Did This Get Made?

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
J
Jason Mantzoukas
J
June Diane Raphael
P
Paul Scheer
Topics
@Paul Scheer : 本片对克隆人的设定存在两种模式:一种是预先购买克隆人作为器官移植的保险;另一种是事后购买,用于应对突发疾病。这两种模式在电影中都有体现,例如Ewan McGregor的角色因为患病而需要克隆人,而Scarlett Johansson的角色则是因为事故受伤。 此外,Paul还对电影中克隆人从高空坠落却毫发无伤的情节表示质疑,认为这与现实逻辑不符。他认为,如果电影中能够说明克隆人拥有更强的体质和反应能力,则可以更好地解释他们为何能够在电影中幸存下来。 在电影结尾,Paul还对克隆人离开克隆基地后的命运表示担忧,认为他们可能会面临危险。 @Jason Mantzoukas : 《岛屿》与以往克隆人题材电影的不同之处在于,本片从克隆人的视角出发,展现了克隆人意识的觉醒和自我认知的发展。这与以往电影中关注非克隆人视角的模式有所不同。 Jason还对电影中克隆人被植入虚假记忆以维持服从性的情节进行了分析,认为克隆人的记忆被操纵,他们所有的记忆都与“岛屿”和“抽奖”的概念联系在一起。 此外,Jason还对电影中大量的追逐戏份表示不满,认为这些戏份缺乏必要的镜头停顿,使得电影节奏过快。 @June Diane Raphael : June认为电影中克隆人的生活环境类似于高档水疗中心,这与克隆人作为器官来源的设定形成反差。她还对电影中克隆人被用作代孕母亲的情节进行了分析,认为克隆人可能也存在与宿主相同的生育问题。 June还对电影中缺乏解释的情节表示不满,认为电影前半部分缺乏解释,直到Steve Buscemi出现才给出关键信息。 此外,June还对电影中“岛屿”的概念具有误导性表示不满,认为实际上“岛屿”是克隆人被囚禁的基地,这与观众的预期不符。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did the clones in 'The Island' have limited knowledge and understanding of the real world?

The clones were raised in a controlled, sanitized environment with implanted memories of an island paradise, lacking exposure to real-world complexities and societal norms.

What moral and ethical questions does 'The Island' raise about cloning and organ harvesting?

The film explores the ethical implications of using clones as organ donors, questioning the rights and consciousness of clones and the morality of creating sentient beings for exploitation.

How does 'The Island' blend action and philosophical themes?

While featuring Michael Bay's signature action sequences, the movie also delves into deep questions about identity, humanity, and the moral consequences of technological advancements in cloning.

Why does the film 'The Island' face criticism for its length and pacing?

The movie is criticized for its lengthy runtime and excessive action sequences, which some viewers find detract from the core narrative and philosophical exploration.

What is the significance of the 'island' in 'The Island'?

The island is a fabricated memory implanted in the clones to maintain their contentment, symbolizing a false utopia that masks their true purpose as organ donors.

How does 'The Island' handle the concept of clones developing consciousness?

The film portrays clones gradually developing awareness and questioning their existence, leading to a narrative focused on their struggle for freedom and identity.

What role does Steve Buscemi's character play in 'The Island'?

Steve Buscemi's character provides crucial exposition, revealing the truth about the clones' existence and aiding their escape, despite his own eccentricities.

Why is the clone club in 'The Island' significant?

The clone club represents a superficial attempt to humanize the clones by allowing them social interaction, yet it underscores their lack of true freedom and individuality.

How does 'The Island' address the physical and psychological resilience of clones?

The film suggests clones are physically fit but psychologically naive, surviving numerous death-defying scenarios due to their conditioning, yet vulnerable to societal complexities.

What is the significance of the jet motorcycle chase in 'The Island'?

The jet motorcycle chase is emblematic of Michael Bay's action-oriented style, showcasing high-stakes, visually spectacular sequences that are a hallmark of his films.

Chapters
The discussion delves into the moral and ethical implications of cloning, questioning whether clones are conscious beings with souls and the implications of using them as organ donors.
  • Clones are grown as insurance policies for rich people to use as organ donors.
  • The clones have no memory of their hosts and are conditioned to believe in an island paradise.
  • The film raises questions about the consciousness and rights of clones.

Shownotes Transcript

The gang is back, or is it their clones, to discuss Michael Bay's bombastic movie, The Island. Paul, June, and Jason dig into Ewan McGregor and Scarlett Johansson running nonstop, clone clubs, jet motorcycles, and getting ratcheted out. Listen to The Island, or your clone may need to do it for you. (Originally Released 08/26/2021)

Tix on sale for Philly live show on Nov 16th and holiday virtual live show on Dec 12th! Go to hdtgm.com for ticket info, merch, and for more on bad movies.
Order Paul’s book about his childhood: Joyful Recollections of Trauma
For extra content on Matinee Monday movies, visit Paul's YouTube page: youtube.com/paulscheer
Talk bad movies on the HDTGM Discord: discord.gg/hdtgm
Paul’s Discord: discord.gg/paulscheer
Follow Paul’s movie recs on Letterboxd: letterboxd.com/paulscheer/
Check out new HDTGM movie merch over at teepublic.com/stores/hdtgm
Paul and Rob Huebel stream live on Twitch every Thursday 8-10pm EST: www.twitch.tv/friendzone
Like good movies too? Subscribe to Unspooled with Paul and Amy Nicholson: listen.earwolf.com/unspooled
Subscribe to The Deep Dive with Jessica St. Clair and June Diane Raphael: www.thedeepdiveacademy.com/podcast
Where to find Paul, June, & Jason:
@PaulScheer on Instagram & Twitter
@Junediane on IG and @MsJuneDiane on Twitter
Jason is not on social media

Get access to all the podcasts you love, music channels and radio shows with the SiriusXM App! Get 3 months free using the link: siriusxm.com/hdtgm.