Former Green County investigator Colonel Coral Sims recounts the complexities of the Justin Gaines case. Initial information and interviews pointed towards Dylan Glass's involvement due to a confession made before news of Justin's disappearance broke. This suspicion was further fueled by a later confession from Dylan's estranged mother, Tammy Blue, which corroborated details about the night of the incident.
Dylan Glass confessed to hurting someone before Justin Gaines was reported missing.
Tammy Blue's confession corroborated Dylan's involvement, despite their estrangement.
Tammy described witnessing events at Andy Pickens's house and hearing a gunshot.