Join hosts Katie and Whitney for a different kind of true crime podcast. You can start with season 1
Love is grand, or so they say. When it works out, it can be one of the greatest things in the human
Join Katie and Whitney for the conclusion of the twisting tale of Dr. Martin MacNeill. See descripti
The MacNeill family was, to all appearances, perfect. There was beautiful and kindhearted mom Miche
Join Katie and Whitney for part 2 of this bizarre story of manipulation and murder. Sources:Book: I&
December 10, 2001. Leesburg, Virginia. Neighbors find the body of Dr. Robert Schwartz, a brilliant
Join Katie and Whitney for the conclusion of this bizarre story, the first in our "Just Bananas" cat
Albuquerque, New Mexico. September 11, 1999. Employees at a local bank call police in a panic. The
Join us as we conclude the story of Matt Baker, a Baptist preacher with some seriously scary inner d
To his congregants at Crossroads First Baptist, Matt Baker was their charming, relatable young pasto
December 2001. The tiny town of Early, Iowa. Police respond to a 911 call from an eleven year old b
Join us for part 2 of the Tracey Richter story. The cold case investigation heats up as Special Agen
Join us as we tie up some loose ends: a spot of bother for Prosecutor Rick Guida, a shocking legal d
For our first Halloween special episode, we tackle one of the creepiest, most confounding, most fasc
Bill Bradfield is in prison at last, convicted of conspiracy to commit murder in the deaths of Susan
In this episode, the investigators close in on Bill Bradfield, and he is finally arrested for conspi
In this episode, the investigation into Susan Reinert's murder and the disappearance of her two
In this episode, we learn about the early days of what would become the most extensive police invest
In this episode, Bill Bradfield shares more details about his private "hit man lessons" with Dr. Smi
In this episode, we learn a LOT more about the supposed "hit man lessons" going on between Bill and
We learn what police found in "Prince of Darkness" Dr. Jay C. Smith's car and basement after his
