cover of episode Matt RESPONDS To Ben's Unhinged Rant

Matt RESPONDS To Ben's Unhinged Rant

2024/11/16
logo of podcast The Matt Walsh Show

The Matt Walsh Show

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
M
Matt
无足够信息构建一句话概述
Topics
Matt: 我制作了一个关于最被高估电影的视频,Ben Shapiro 对此进行了猛烈的抨击。我坚持我的观点,认为我的排名是正确的,并且不需要辩解。我主要回应Ben Shapiro对《黑暗骑士》的批评,因为我对其他电影的评价是显而易见的。我并非为了针对Ben Shapiro而制作这个视频。我的批评并非针对小丑这个角色的缺失,而是针对小丑这个角色本身的设定以及希斯·莱杰的表演。我认为安东·奇格尔(《老无所依》)比小丑更胜一筹。我对《黑暗骑士》中医院爆炸场景的逻辑性表示质疑,并指出双面人的角色设定和剧情存在缺陷。我认为90年代的《蝙蝠侠动画系列》比诺兰版本的《黑暗骑士》更好。最后,我批评《黑暗骑士》的片长过长。 Ben Shapiro: (根据Matt的描述,Ben Shapiro对Matt的电影排名提出了批评,并对《黑暗骑士》进行了辩护,认为小丑这个角色至关重要,并且影片的整体质量很高。他还对Matt的论点提出了反驳,并使用了具有攻击性的语言。)

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did Ben Shapiro attack Matt?

Ben Shapiro attacked Matt because of a video where Matt listed the top five most overrated movies, which included The Dark Knight, a film Ben is very fond of.

What were the movies on Matt's list of most overrated films?

Matt's list included Shawshank Redemption, Toy Story, The Dark Knight, the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe, and all of the Star Wars films, especially the originals.

Why did Matt criticize The Dark Knight?

Matt criticized The Dark Knight for its reliance on Heath Ledger's performance rather than the script, its unrealistic elements like the Joker's hospital explosion, and its overly long runtime filled with speeches.

Who does Matt consider the greatest villain in cinema history?

Matt believes Anton Chigurh from No Country for Old Men is the greatest villain in cinema history, arguing he is more menacing and interesting than the Joker.

What does Matt think about the character of Two-Face in The Dark Knight?

Matt finds Two-Face's character arc in The Dark Knight unrealistic and less developed compared to the Batman animated series from the 90s.

Why does Matt think The Dark Knight is overrated?

Matt thinks The Dark Knight is overrated because it relies too much on Heath Ledger's performance, has unrealistic plot elements, and is overly long with too many speeches.

What is Matt's opinion on Christopher Nolan's filmmaking in The Dark Knight?

Matt criticizes Christopher Nolan for focusing too much on delivering philosophical messages through speeches rather than developing characters and maintaining realism.

What does Matt suggest as an alternative to the chaos of modern Christmas?

Matt recommends the Advent Pray 25 Challenge by Hallow, which focuses on daily guided prayer sessions, authentic Advent music, and content designed to help grow in faith during the Advent season.

Chapters
Matt Walsh responds to Ben Shapiro's critique of his list of overrated movies, focusing on The Dark Knight.
  • Matt defends his stance on The Dark Knight being overrated.
  • He argues that Heath Ledger's performance elevates the Joker character, which is otherwise hokey and corny.
  • Matt compares The Dark Knight unfavorably to The Godfather, suggesting that without Ledger's performance, the film would not be as highly regarded.

Shownotes Transcript

I made a video rating the top 5 most overrated movies, and Ben attacked me for it. Let's see what he has to say.

 

Today’s Sponsor:

 

Hallow - Go to https://Hallow.com/Walsh) to join the Advent program.