cover of episode Is the School Meals Scheme worth it?

Is the School Meals Scheme worth it?

2025/1/13
logo of podcast The Hard Shoulder Highlights

The Hard Shoulder Highlights
People
T
Trina Golden
W
Wendy Grace
Topics
Ciarán Cudahy: 我在社交媒体上发起了一个关于学校免费午餐计划的讨论，收到了很多反馈，褒贬不一。有人认为食物质量差，包装过多，食材廉价；也有人认为该计划非常有益，为孩子们提供了一日三餐的保障。 为了进一步了解情况，我采访了两位嘉宾：Trina Golden 和 Wendy Grace。 Trina Golden: 在我们学校，免费午餐计划实施效果良好。大部分学生持续食用，食物质量尚可，我们学校有专门的设备和人员负责食物的加热和分发，家长可以通过应用程序选择菜单，并能灵活调整孩子的饮食。我们学校的剩饭剩菜由教职工食用，有效减少了浪费。虽然该计划存在一些问题，例如食品质量参差不齐，但总体来说，它对我们的学校来说是一个积极的体验。 我认为，确保每个孩子每天至少有一顿热饭热菜非常重要。我理解人们对食品质量和问责制的担忧，但我们学校的经验是积极的。 如果让我重新开始，我会更关注问责制和监管，因为不同供应商之间存在很大的差异。学校应该有权选择供应商，并且供应商应该对食品质量负责。 Wendy Grace: 我认为，免费午餐计划缺乏监管，许多学校提供的食物含有过多的超加工食品和添加剂，不利于儿童健康。政府应该制定更严格的标准，并对供应商进行监管，确保食品的营养和安全。 我注意到，一些供应商提供的食物质量很高，但缺乏统一标准，导致食品质量参差不齐。政府应该制定更严格的标准和监管机制，并提高透明度，让家长能够了解食物的成分和营养价值。 此外，超加工食品中的添加剂会影响儿童的味觉，让他们更喜欢加工食品，不利于他们的长期健康。政府应该避免在学校午餐中使用超加工食品。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

How many children and schools are currently benefiting from the Free School Meals Programme?

The Free School Meals Programme currently feeds approximately 350,000 children across over 2,000 schools in Ireland.

What are some common concerns raised about the Free School Meals Programme?

Common concerns include poor food quality, excessive plastic packaging, cheap ingredients, and the use of ultra-processed foods. Some parents and teachers also report significant food waste.

What has been Trina Golden's experience with the Free School Meals Programme in her school?

Trina Golden, a school principal, describes the programme as overwhelmingly positive. She highlights good food variety, minimal waste, and a system where parents can manage meal preferences via an app. Around 70% of students consistently eat the meals, while the remaining 30% can opt out if the food doesn't suit their needs.

How is food kept warm in schools under the Free School Meals Programme?

In Trina Golden's school, food is delivered in the morning and heated in ovens by an operator. It is then served hot to classrooms in insulated boxes that keep the food warm until it is ready to be eaten.

What is Wendy Grace's main criticism of the Free School Meals Programme?

Wendy Grace criticizes the lack of oversight and accountability in the programme, particularly regarding the use of ultra-processed foods and additives. She argues that government-funded meals should adhere to stricter nutritional standards and avoid ingredients that could negatively impact children's health and eating habits.

What is the cost per meal under the Free School Meals Programme?

The cost per meal is €3.20 per child. Wendy Grace suggests that this budget could be used to prepare healthier, more nutritious meals if managed effectively.

What are some suggestions for improving the Free School Meals Programme?

Suggestions include implementing stricter nutritional standards, reducing ultra-processed ingredients, improving transparency about meal ingredients, and introducing a grading system for food quality. There is also a call for better oversight to ensure consistency across providers.

Chapters
The school meals program, initiated in 2019, has expanded significantly, serving approximately 350,000 children in over 2,000 schools. However, feedback on the program's effectiveness has been varied, with some praising its positive impact while others express concerns about food quality and waste.
  • The program initially started in 30 schools and has expanded to over 2000 schools.
  • About 70% of children consistently eat the meals provided.
  • Leftover meals are consumed by staff.
  • Concerns exist regarding food quality, accountability, and waste

Shownotes Transcript

The School Meals Scheme continues to be rolled out across the country – this means 3,200 schools and 550,000 children will soon be eligible for the programme.

But, is it worth the time and resources?

To discuss, Kieran is joined by Trina Golden, Principal of Owenabue Educate Together National School in Carrigaline, Cork, as well as Broadcaster Wendy Grace…