Sean Dyche signaled that he felt he had taken Everton as far as he could, citing weariness from the club's financial struggles, points deductions, and organizational chaos. The Friedkin Group, Everton's new owners, acted quickly to replace him with David Moyes, who has a strong emotional connection to the club and a proven track record of stabilizing teams in difficult situations.
Moyes inherits a club vastly different from the one he left in 2013. Everton has been financially strained, with key players sold and a fan base ground down by years of instability. The Premier League is more competitive, and the squad lacks attacking flair and adaptability. Moyes must stabilize the team, avoid relegation, and rebuild trust with fans while navigating limited resources.
The contract reflects Moyes' leverage in negotiations and the Friedkin Group's belief in his ability to stabilize Everton. It provides him with time to keep the club in the Premier League, transition into the new stadium, and potentially rebuild the squad. However, if results don't improve, the owners may need to make another managerial change, similar to previous situations under Farhad Moshiri.
The current squad lacks the quality and depth of Moyes' previous Everton teams. Financial constraints have forced the sale of key players, leaving the team with limited attacking options and a reliance on direct, one-dimensional football. Moyes will need to work with a squad that lacks pace and creativity, making recruitment a critical focus.
The Friedkin Group, Everton's new owners, have prioritized stability and pragmatism in their early decisions. They opted for Moyes due to his familiarity with the club and his ability to navigate a relegation battle. Their approach mirrors their strategy at Roma, where they appointed Claudio Ranieri in a similar crisis situation. However, their long-term vision for Everton remains unclear.
Everton urgently needs to address their lack of attacking threat. The squad lacks pace, creativity, and goal-scoring options, with players like Jack Harrison contributing zero goals and assists. Moyes will likely focus on bringing in dynamic attackers and improving the team's ability to break down defenses, even with limited financial resources.
Moyes' first spell at Everton was marked by stability, consistent performances, and a strong connection with fans. This time, he faces a club in turmoil, with financial constraints, a disillusioned fan base, and a squad lacking quality. While his experience and pragmatism are assets, the challenges are far greater, and expectations are tempered by the need for survival rather than long-term success.
While some fans are nostalgic for Moyes' successful first spell, others are skeptical due to his departure for Manchester United and his attempts to sign Everton players while at United. However, most fans see him as a safe pair of hands who can stabilize the club and reconnect with the fan base, especially during a relegation battle.
After sacking manager Sean Dyche on Thursday, by Saturday Everton have confirmed their decision to bring back David Moyes to replace him.
So is Moyes the right choice to rebuild Everton and keep them in the Premier League?
Ayo Akinwolere is joined by The Athletic's Everton correspondent Patrick Boyland and The Athletic FC newsletter lead writer Phil Hay to discuss and analyse the decision to remove Dyche and bring back Moyes.
The Athletic's Greg O'Keeffe, having seen Moyes' first reign firsthand, also drops in to give his views on the return of the Scot as well as Italian Football correspondent James Horncastle looking at the role of new owners The Friedkin Group.
Host: Ayo Akinwolere
With: Patrick Boyland, Phil Hay, Greg O'Keeffe and James Horncastle
Executive Producer: Adey Moorhead
Producer: Guy Clarke
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices)