Chasing Chasing Amy: A Documentary Review

Chasing Chasing Amy, directed by Sav Rodgers, is not merely a nostalgic celebration of Kevin Smith's 1997 cult classic, but a multifaceted exploration of its complicated legacy and Rodgers' own personal journey as a trans man. While initially conceived as a love letter to a film that profoundly impacted Rodgers' understanding of his own queerness, the documentary evolves into a nuanced and unflinching examination of the film's flaws, its place in the 90s indie film landscape, and the enduring impact of Harvey Weinstein's shadow.

Key Themes:

The Complicated Legacy of Chasing Amy: Rodgers grapples with the problematic elements of a film made by a straight white man attempting to depict a lesbian relationship. Critics argue that the film reinforces harmful stereotypes and perpetuates the male gaze. “Here’s a refresher on the film’s plot: Ben Affleck’s comic book writer meets and falls in love with another comic book writer, Alyssa, played by Joey Lauren Adams. Alyssa, however, is a lesbian, which understandably complicates their budding friendship and any potential relationship.” (Film Stories)
Personal Transformation: Interwoven with the analysis of Chasing Amy, Rodgers chronicles his personal journey of self-discovery and acceptance as a trans man. Inspired by the film's portrayal of queerness, Rodgers confronts his own identity, his relationship with his partner Riley, and the evolving meaning of the film in his life. “The fact that Kevin Smith appears regularly in it may make the film appear to be a puff piece, something he might use to promote a film's anniversary but Rodgers' innocent “oh my god I love your movie” changes as he learns not only more about himself but about the film.” (Filmhounds Magazine)
The Shadow of Harvey Weinstein: The documentary acknowledges the dark undercurrent of Weinstein's presence in the 90s indie film scene. Interviews with Joey Lauren Adams reveal the toxic atmosphere of misogyny and abuse that permeated the industry, particularly for women. Adams poignantly states, “We all knew who he was,” referring to Weinstein. She goes on to highlight the tragic irony: Chasing Amy premiered at Sundance the same year Weinstein assaulted Rose McGowan. (Film Stories)

Kevin Smith's Reflections: The documentary features candid interviews with Smith, who acknowledges the film's shortcomings and expresses regret for the pain caused by his portrayal of lesbian relationships. He reflects on the criticism from the LGBTQ+ community and provides context for the film's creation. "This could be heavy, and feel like someone turning on the film, but Rodgers puts in his own life; coming to terms with his gender identity, his ongoing relationship with his partner Riley, her experiences as a lesbian. Eventually the film takes a back foot to a very sweet love story about someone becoming who they are, inspired by a film that was entirely what it wanted to be and the woman he loves holding steadfast in her support." (Filmhounds Magazine)
Joey Lauren Adams' Perspective: Adams' interview is particularly revealing, offering a stark and emotional account of the pervasive misogyny she faced and the impact of Weinstein on her career. “A one-on-one interview with Joey Lauren Adams herself is devastating, not just in what she talks about – Weinstein essentially sabotaging her career because he didn't fancy her, but the atmosphere of the time.” (Filmhounds Magazine)
The Power of Representation: Chasing Chasing Amy underscores the importance of representation and the impact that even flawed portrayals can have on individuals struggling with their identity. Rodgers' story serves as a testament to the power of seeing oneself reflected in media, however imperfectly. "We need more stories like this that are told by LGBTQ+ individuals, because this documentary serves as a reminder of the impact that films/shows/media can have on members of communities in need of representation." (Loud and Clear)

Movie Review: Chasing Chasing Amy 09:02 Share

Tell Me Something Now

Shownotes Transcript

Movie Review: Chasing Chasing Amy