cover of episode 181. What’s So Great About Meritocracy?

181. What’s So Great About Meritocracy?

2024/2/4
logo of podcast No Stupid Questions

No Stupid Questions

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
A
Angela Duckworth
M
Mike Mann
P
Patrick Gilmartin
Topics
Patrick Gilmartin:质疑精英体制的公平性,并探讨完美精英体制是否存在以及是否值得追求。 Angela Duckworth:认为精英体制可能导致社会不平等加剧,精英体制的潜在危害在于它会加剧社会不平等,使富者更富,穷者更穷;并提出天赋普遍存在,但机会并不均等,这是社会不平等的根源;还提到即使是基因等先天因素也带有偶然性,不能完全归功于个人努力;以及我们常常将成功错误地归因于个人努力,而忽略了机遇和运气。最后,她还总结到生活本身充满了偶然性,精英体制只是这种偶然性的一种体现。 Mike Mann:认为精英竞争(例如NBA)看起来很公平,但早期机会的不平等会影响最终结果;精英体制的挑战在于,尽管我们希望最优秀的人脱颖而出,但起初机会的不平等会阻碍真正公平的竞争;成功既包含努力,也包含运气,两者并非相互排斥;以及偶然的机遇(例如慈善拍卖)可能对人生产生深远的影响。

Deep Dive

Chapters
The episode begins with a discussion on the concept of meritocracy, questioning whether it is a fair system and if it can be considered a trap as described in Daniel Markovits' book 'The Meritocracy Trap'.

Shownotes Transcript

Do you really deserve the credit for your accomplishments? Should college admissions be determined by lottery? And how did Mike’s contribution to a charity auction change his life?