cover of episode News Watch: Syria, Sex Workers, 'Sickfluencers', and Gregg Wallace is sorry-not-sorry

News Watch: Syria, Sex Workers, 'Sickfluencers', and Gregg Wallace is sorry-not-sorry

2024/12/5
logo of podcast Media Storm

Media Storm

People
H
Helena Wadia
Topics
Helena Wadia: 格雷格·华莱士面临多项性行为不当指控,媒体报道对其行为的描述含糊不清,未能准确定义其严重性。媒体对格雷格·华莱士性行为不当指控的描述过于轻描淡写,未能将其定性为性侵犯。《每日电讯报》对格雷格·华莱士性行为不当指控的报道,其用词模糊,削弱了其揭露真相的力度。《每日电讯报》的报道关注点不在受害者身上,反而侧重于格雷格·华莱士的成功和公众形象。《每日电讯报》发表了一篇为格雷格·华莱士辩护的文章,这与之前报道中揭露的性行为不当指控相矛盾。格雷格·华莱士事件的核心问题是权力和保护,而非玩笑是否得体。性骚扰和性侵犯的核心是权力,施暴者利用权力让受害者感到不舒服和羞辱。格雷格·华莱士在Instagram上回应指控时,将批评者定义为“特定年龄的中产阶级女性”,此举具有性别歧视色彩。格雷格·华莱士将批评者定义为“特定年龄的中产阶级女性”,并试图以此获得新的受众支持,此举令人费解。 Mathilda Mallinson: 对格雷格·华莱士事件的讨论补充和回应,可能包括对媒体报道的批判性分析,以及对受害者经历的关注和支持。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did Greg Wallace's response to allegations of misconduct spark controversy?

Greg Wallace's response, where he referred to complainants as 'middle-class women of a certain age,' was seen as dismissive and stereotyping, undermining the seriousness of the allegations against him.

What were the key allegations against Greg Wallace?

Allegations included inappropriate sexual comments, showing topless pictures of himself, asking for massages, and allegedly groping and pressing against women. These spanned across five different programs and involved at least 13 people.

How did the Telegraph's coverage of Greg Wallace's allegations differ from its follow-up article?

The Telegraph initially reported on the allegations in a way that seemed to undermine the seriousness of the claims by labeling them as 'banter laced with occasional sexual innuendo.' The next day, it published an article defending Wallace, calling him a 'top bloke,' which contradicted the initial reporting.

Why did the rebels in Syria launch an offensive against government forces?

The rebels, including the group Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, launched an offensive due to the ongoing repression by Bashar al-Assad's regime, which has been brutal since the start of the civil war in 2011. The rebels saw an opportunity as Assad's key allies, Russia and Iran, were weakened by other conflicts.

How does Western media coverage of the Syrian conflict differ from the perspective of Syrians on the ground?

Western media often frames the conflict in terms of instability and danger, dismissing rebels as terrorists or Islamists without exploring the human reasons behind the uprising. Syrians, however, see the conflict as an uprising against a brutal dictatorship, with many civilians supporting the rebels' actions.

What is the significance of the new law in Belgium for sex workers?

The new law in Belgium grants sex workers the same rights as other workers, including maternity leave, pensions, and sick days. It also mandates brothels to have emergency panic buttons and meet hygiene criteria, allowing sex workers to refuse clients or services without fear of being fired.

Why did The Times' article on 'Sickfluencers' draw criticism?

The Times' article criticized influencers with illnesses or disabilities for providing tips on how to claim benefits, framing it as 'gaming the system.' Critics pointed out the hypocrisy of not similarly criticizing wealthy individuals or financial experts for providing tax-saving advice.

What are the concerns of sex workers in the UK regarding the Labour government's proposed changes?

Sex workers in the UK are concerned that the Labour government may introduce laws criminalizing clients or redefining prostitution as sexual exploitation, which they argue would push sex work further underground and increase risks of violence and arrest.

Chapters
This chapter analyzes the allegations of sexual misconduct against Greg Wallace, the media's response, and his subsequent non-apology and apology. It discusses the power dynamics involved and the media's role in shaping the narrative.
  • Multiple allegations of sexual misconduct against Greg Wallace.
  • The Telegraph's conflicting coverage, initially highlighting allegations, then publishing a defense.
  • Wallace's initial dismissive response targeting 'middle-class women of a certain age'.
  • His later apology, deemed insufficient by many.

Shownotes Transcript

Join Mathilda and Helena on their weekly news debriefs! We pick apart the most unhinged headlines and try to make sense of the mainstream media - helping you consume the news critically.

This week, Gregg Wallace turned his back on his target audience ("middle-class women of a certain age") while issuing a statement that will surely go down in history as a top PR nightmare. It's all off the back of multiple serious allegations against him - both uncovered AND undermined by The Telegraph. Next, we step outside of the Western worldview to look at events in Syria, as Aleppo has been captured by the armed rebel group Hayat Tahrir al-Sham from government forces. Plus - under a world-first law, sex workers in Belgium will be giving the same rights as any other worker, and is The Times being hypocritical with its article about 'Sickfluencers'?

The episode is hosted and produced by Mathilda Mallinson (@mathildamall)) and Helena Wadia (@helenawadia)).

The music is by Samfire (@soundofsamfire)).

Follow us @mediastormpod)

Support us on Patreon!)

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices)