cover of episode Christmas Movie Knight

Christmas Movie Knight

2024/12/24
logo of podcast Gone Medieval

Gone Medieval

People
D
Dr. Eleanor Janega
M
Matt Lewis
Topics
Matt Lewis: 本播客节目《Gone Medieval》旨在探讨中世纪历史上最有趣的神秘事件、令人震惊的细节以及最新的突破性研究成果,涵盖从维京人到诺曼人、从国王到教皇再到十字军东征等各个方面,深入探讨叛乱、阴谋和谋杀等事件,以揭示我们如何走到今天以及我们真正的过去。 他还提到他和Eleanor Janega制作了一部关于如何在中世纪严冬生存的新影片,现已发布,内容包括在威尔士的Cosmestan中世纪村庄取景、在德文郡用苹果酒敬酒等。 Dr. Eleanor Janega: 推荐观看Netflix剧集《最后的王国》,因为它展现了英格兰盎格鲁-撒克逊时期的暴力和政治斗争,并与真实历史人物有所关联,例如Uhtred of Bamburgh。虽然并非完全准确,但它在展现盎格鲁-撒克逊时期的政治和维京人的入侵方面做得相当不错,并能作为学习的跳板。 她还推荐观看Netflix剧集《十日谈》,因为它基于14世纪意大利的真实书籍,展现了黑死病肆虐时期人们的生活百态,既有幽默,也有粗俗,反映了即使在可怕的环境中,生活仍在继续的现实。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

What is 'The Last Kingdom' about?

'The Last Kingdom' is a TV series based on Bernard Cornwell's books, set in Anglo-Saxon England during the time of King Alfred and the Viking invasions. It offers a gritty, authentic portrayal of the period with political intrigue, battles, and the story of Uhtred, a real historical figure.

Why is 'The Decameron' a good choice for a medieval film?

'The Decameron' is based on a 14th-century book written by Boccaccio, reflecting life during the Black Death. It balances humor, romance, and the horrors of the plague, showing how people continued to live and enjoy life even in devastating circumstances.

What makes 'Army of Darkness' an absurd medieval film?

'Army of Darkness' is a 1992 film starring Bruce Campbell, where a chainsaw-handed man from the modern era is transported to the 14th century. It combines slapstick comedy, horror, and medieval settings, featuring a shotgun-wielding protagonist fighting demonic forces in a ridiculous medieval world.

Why is 'The Physician' problematic?

'The Physician' inaccurately portrays medieval medicine and the role of the church, suggesting the church opposed medical practices. It also incorrectly places the Black Death in the 11th century and misrepresents historical figures like Avicenna. The film is riddled with historical inaccuracies and anachronisms.

What is the appeal of 'The 13th Warrior'?

'The 13th Warrior' stars Antonio Banderas as Ibn Fadlan, a poet who joins a group of Vikings to fight a supernatural threat. It combines historical elements, Norse mythology, and a compelling outsider narrative, making it a visually stunning and engaging film.

Why is 'The Great Wall' considered problematic?

'The Great Wall' features Matt Damon as a Western warrior defending China from monsters, which critics argue perpetuates the trope of a white savior. While the film's visuals and martial arts choreography are impressive, the story's focus on a Western protagonist overshadows the rich Chinese history and culture.

What is unique about 'Outlander'?

'Outlander' blends medieval Viking settings with sci-fi elements, featuring an alien monster that terrorizes a Viking community. It explores themes of community, acceptance, and the supernatural, offering a fresh take on medieval storytelling with strong visuals and a compelling narrative.

Why is 'Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves' a classic?

'Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves' is a 1991 film starring Kevin Costner and Alan Rickman as the Sheriff of Nottingham. It combines action, humor, and a classic Robin Hood story, with Rickman's performance as the villain being particularly memorable and entertaining.

What makes 'Robin Hood (2018)' a bad film?

'Robin Hood (2018)' is criticized for its messy storytelling, anachronistic costumes, and confusing mix of historical seriousness with modern action sequences. The film attempts to blend a moralistic tale with cart chases and molten metal scenes, resulting in a disjointed and unconvincing narrative.

What is the appeal of Disney's 'Robin Hood'?

Disney's 'Robin Hood' (1973) is a beloved animated film featuring anthropomorphic animals in a swashbuckling adventure. It captures the fun and spirit of the Robin Hood legend with memorable characters, catchy songs, and a lighthearted approach to the medieval setting.

Shownotes Transcript

It’s Christmas. The holly and ivy are adorning the fireplace, hopefully the shopping is (mostly) done and the King of Misrule is on his way…Who are we to disobey him? 

Matt Lewis and Dr. Eleanor Janega have hung their medieval stockings and are having a blast discussing the best 'medieval' films delivered to our homes via the very modern magic of TV. They choose the most accurate, the most absurd and the most bell-ringingly fun depictions of the middle ages, including the gritty authenticity of 'The Last Kingdom', the hilarious 'Army of Darkness,' the problematic 'The Physician,' the martial spectacle of 'The Great Wall,' and the intriguing 'Outlander.' Plus a hefty dose of Robin Hood and his Merry Men in their many, many film adaptations. There will be tights...

Gone Medieval is presented by Dr. Eleanor Janega and Matt Lewis. Edited by Amy Haddow. The senior producer is Anne-Marie Luff.

All music used is courtesy of Epidemic Sounds and All3 Media Music.

Gone Medieval is a History Hit podcast.

Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe). 

You can take part in our listener survey here)**: **https://uk.surveymonkey.com/r/6FFT7MK)