Case 305: Marshall Street
Casefile True Crime
Deep Dive
Why did Josefina Rivera initially agree to go with Gary Heidnik?
Josefina accepted a ride from Gary because it was a slow night for her sex work, and he offered a decent price. She didn't see any red flags in his appearance or behavior.
What was Gary Heidnik's plan for the women he abducted?
Gary intended to hold up to 10 women captive in his basement, impregnate each one, and raise the children together under one roof to create a 'big happy family.'
How did Josefina Rivera attempt to escape from Gary Heidnik's basement?
Josefina managed to pick at the superglue on the muffler clamp shackle, freeing her ankle. She then tried to crawl through a small basement window but was chained too short to fully escape.
What was the hierarchy system Gary Heidnik implemented among his captives?
Gary allowed Josefina, Sandra, and Lisa, who were the most compliant and had been there the longest, to sleep on a regular mattress. Debra, due to her rebellious behavior, was mostly kept in the hole, and Jackie, as the newest captive, was also confined there.
How did Josefina Rivera ultimately escape and alert the authorities?
Josefina convinced Gary to let her visit her family, promising to return. She then went to a payphone and called 911, detailing her captivity and the existence of the other women in Gary's basement.
What was the outcome of Gary Heidnik's trial?
Gary was found guilty on all counts, including first-degree murder for the deaths of Sandra Lindsay and Deborah Dudley, and was sentenced to death.
How did Gary Heidnik's crimes impact the death penalty in Pennsylvania?
Gary's execution in 1999 marked the last time the death penalty was carried out in Pennsylvania. No other inmate has been executed since then.
What challenges did the survivors face after being freed from Gary Heidnik's captivity?
The survivors faced severe physical and psychological trauma, including PTSD, anxiety, and difficulty reintegrating into society. Some, like Jackie Askins, struggled with basic functions like walking and relied on medication to manage their conditions.
- Josefina was held captive in Heidnik's basement with five other women.
- Heidnik subjected the women to unspeakable crimes, including sexual violence and torture.
- The basement was soundproofed and contained a hole dug in the floor, intended as a grave.
Shownotes Transcript