Key Insights
Why did the investigation of Katelyn Markham's disappearance initially slow down?
The investigation slowed down because there were no strong leads or physical evidence, and the search for Katelyn turned up nothing. As time passed, fewer tips came in, and the case went cold.
Why did the discovery of Katelyn's remains in 2013 not solve the case immediately?
The discovery of Katelyn's remains only confirmed that she had been murdered, but it did not provide information on the cause of death, how it happened, or who was responsible. The forensic evidence was limited and did not point to a specific suspect.
Why did John Carter become a suspect in Katelyn's murder?
John Carter became a suspect because of inconsistencies in his story, his behavior, and new information from Katelyn's friends and family. They revealed that Katelyn was unhappy in the relationship and had doubts about her engagement to John.
Why did the investigators believe John Carter's actions on the night of Katelyn's disappearance were suspicious?
John Carter's actions were suspicious because he left the party and returned home, but his phone records showed his phone went dark around the same time Katelyn's did. Additionally, a neighbor heard a heated argument and a thud at around the time Katelyn disappeared.
Why did the investigators decide to charge John Carter with murder?
The investigators decided to charge John Carter with murder after finding new evidence, including poems and writings that suggested he was grappling with the truth of what he had done to Katelyn. They also found evidence consistent with the forensic findings on Katelyn's body.
Why did the prosecutors offer John Carter a plea deal instead of going to trial?
The prosecutors offered a plea deal to ensure that John Carter would admit to his role in Katelyn's death, providing some finality to the process and giving her family the acknowledgment they deserved. They may have also considered the strength of their evidence and the uncertainty of a trial outcome.
Chapters
- Katelyn Markham desapareció en agosto de 2011.
- John Carter, el prometido de Katelyn, fue la última persona que la vio.
- La policía llevó a cabo la búsqueda de personas desaparecidas más grande en la historia de Fairfield, pero no encontró a Katelyn ni ninguna pista sobre su paradero.
Shownotes Transcript