cover of episode The Flop House: Megalopolis, with Roman Mars

The Flop House: Megalopolis, with Roman Mars

2024/12/10
logo of podcast 99% Invisible

99% Invisible

People
D
Dan McCoy
E
Elliot Kalin
R
Roman Mars
S
Stuart Wellington
Topics
Roman Mars: 本期节目探讨了弗朗西斯·福特·科波拉的电影《巨石城》,这部电影试图展现对城市乌托邦的愿景,但其叙事混乱,执行不力。Roman Mars认为,尽管电影存在诸多不足,但其对城市规划和乌托邦的探讨以及对罗伯特·摩西的隐喻值得关注。 Dan McCoy: Dan McCoy, Stuart Wellington和Elliot Kalin对电影进行了详细的剧情分析,指出电影中存在许多逻辑不通和缺乏解释的场景,例如Adam Driver的角色拥有停止时间的能力,但这一能力并未在剧情中得到充分利用。他们认为,电影中人物关系的变化缺乏解释,许多场景显得突兀和混乱。 Stuart Wellington: Stuart Wellington认为,电影中对富人和大众的刻画存在矛盾,对大众的刻画过于简单化,缺乏对普通民众观点的展现。他认为,电影试图表达对平等和正义的追求,但却最终呈现出一种法西斯主义的倾向。 Elliot Kalin: Elliot Kalin认为,《巨石城》深受罗伯特·摩西的城市建设理念的影响,但这种影响以一种奇怪且无效的方式呈现。他将电影解读为对弗朗西斯·福特·科波拉自身创作历程的隐喻,认为电影中缺乏连贯的主题和明确的前提。 Roman Mars: Roman Mars认为,《巨石城》是一部糟糕的电影,其核心观点是危险且有害的。他批评了电影中对天才人物的盲目崇拜以及对大众的轻蔑态度。他认为,电影中对政治和社会问题的探讨缺乏逻辑和深度,其核心观点是危险且有害的。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did Roman Mars join The Flop House to discuss Megalopolis?

Roman Mars joined The Flop House to talk about Megalopolis as it intersects with urban utopia and city-building ideas, aligning with his work on 99% Invisible. He also saw it as an opportunity to explore the film's connection to Robert Moses and The Power Broker.

What is the central theme of Megalopolis?

Megalopolis explores the idea of urban utopia and the tension between populism and the need for a genius to reshape society. It questions whether the current societal structure is the only one available and explores the concept of utopia through the lens of city planning.

Who are the main characters in Megalopolis?

The main characters include Caesar Catalina (Adam Driver), a city planner loosely based on Robert Moses; Mayor Frank Cicero (Giancarlo Esposito), the mayor of New Rome; Julia Cicero (Natalie Emanuel), the mayor's daughter; and Crassus (John Voight), the owner of the largest bank.

What unique abilities does Caesar Catalina possess in Megalopolis?

Caesar Catalina has the ability to stop time and is the inventor of Megalon, a magical super substance. These abilities are not fully explained or utilized in a meaningful way within the plot.

How does the film portray the relationship between Caesar Catalina and Mayor Cicero?

The film portrays a tense relationship between Caesar Catalina and Mayor Cicero, with Cicero opposing Catalina's grand vision for the city. However, the movie ultimately sides with Catalina, portraying him as the genius who should be allowed to reshape the city without opposition.

What is the significance of the Soviet satellite crashing into the city in Megalopolis?

The Soviet satellite crash opens up more land for building, symbolizing the necessary destruction required to create a new utopia. It also reflects the film's themes of great men using destruction to achieve their vision, often at the expense of the people.

What is the most memorable line from John Voight's character in Megalopolis?

John Voight's character, Crassus, delivers the memorable line, 'What do you think of this boner I got?' before revealing a crossbow hidden under a blanket. This line is particularly striking for its unexpected placement in a serious-minded film.

How does the film conclude, and what does it say about the future of New Rome?

The film concludes with Caesar Catalina and Julia Cicero getting married and planning to build a utopia. The city is left in chaos, but Catalina's vision for a new, organic city is presented as the solution. The final scene shows time stopping for everyone except their baby, symbolizing the continuation of their vision into the next generation.

What are the criticisms of Megalopolis's portrayal of society and populism?

Critics argue that Megalopolis has contempt for both the rich and the common people, portraying the masses as easily swayed and in need of a genius to guide them. The film's themes lean toward a fascist ideology, where the genius is always right and the people are merely pawns in the vision of a utopia.

What is the final judgment of Megalopolis by The Flop House hosts?

The Flop House hosts classify Megalopolis as a 'good bad' movie, appreciating its ambitious vision and personal touch despite its flaws. They acknowledge that while it is a mess, it is an experience worth having for those interested in its unique ideas and chaotic execution.

Chapters
The Flop House podcast, joined by Roman Mars, reviews Francis Ford Coppola's *Megalopolis*. The discussion starts with introductions and background on the film's premise, focusing on its unique blend of urban planning, utopian visions, and peculiar execution.
  • Roman Mars's connection to the Flop House podcast
  • Introduction of Megalopolis and its connection to Robert Moses and urban planning
  • Discussion of the movie's challenging nature and the hosts' decision to see it in theaters

Shownotes Transcript

Roman Mars and the Flop House team dive into Francis Ford Coppola's intriguing and controversial film, Megalopolis, exploring its chaotic narrative, ambitious ideas, and perplexing execution.

Listen to The Flop House) wherever you get your podcasts!

The Flop House: Megalopolis, with Roman Mars)

Subscribe to SiriusXM Podcasts+ on Apple Podcasts to listen to ad-free new episodes and get exclusive access to bonus content.