cover of episode  Amorim for Ten Hag & Who Deserved The Ballon d’Or? | Fan Debate

Amorim for Ten Hag & Who Deserved The Ballon d’Or? | Fan Debate

2024/10/30
logo of podcast The Overlap

The Overlap

People
A
Adam McKola
C
Charlene Smith
F
Flav
G
Gareth Roberts
J
Jamie Carragher
L
Laurie Whitwell
L
Luke Robinson
P
Paul Scholes
R
Rory Jennings
S
Steven Mcinerney
Topics
Jamie Carragher: 曼联的进攻乏力是球队的主要问题,需要更多进球。 Paul Scholes: 曼联联赛排名低迷,解雇滕哈格是正确的决定,球队表现起伏太大,尤其水晶宫4-0惨败那场,就应该换帅。 Laurie Whitwell: 曼联考虑解雇滕哈格已有一段时间,水晶宫比赛后就已决定换帅,但足总杯决赛改变了局面。曼联应该反思在赛季初坚持滕哈格并花费巨资引援的决定,因为最终结果并不理想。阿莫林可能是曼联球迷期待的人选,他拥有不错的执教履历,并且年轻有潜力。 Adam McKola: 曼联需要时间来纠正格雷泽家族多年来犯下的错误,但对球队新老板的耐心正在逐渐消磨。解雇滕哈格是正确的决定,托特纳姆热刺的比赛是压垮骆驼的最后一根稻草。曼联需要一位既有能力又有性格魅力的主教练,能够与球迷建立联系。对伊尼奥斯能否做出正确的管理决策并不完全有信心,他们夏天就应该换掉滕哈格。 Gareth Roberts: 无论曼联引进谁,他们都不是瓜迪奥拉,这将是一个巨大的挑战。曼联主教练的压力巨大,需要一位特殊的人才能胜任。埃梅里不太可能执教曼联,因为他更喜欢在阿斯顿维拉拥有完全的控制权。 Steven Mcinerney: 如果瓜迪奥拉离开曼城,阿莫林可能是接替者,但目前瓜迪奥拉的未来仍不明朗。阿莫林的战术风格(三后卫阵型)可能与曼联的传统打法有所冲突。如果曼城真的想要阿莫林,他不太可能选择曼联。 Charlene Smith: 阿森纳应该赢下与利物浦的比赛,球队上半场表现出色。阿森纳在比赛中存在下半场表现下滑的问题,但裁判的判罚也存在争议。阿森纳可以通过防守反击和灵活的球员安排赢得联赛冠军,但前提是避免伤病和保持纪律。 Rory Jennings: 切尔西本赛季的目标不是赢得联赛冠军,而是争取一个令人满意的积分排名和前四的位置。马雷斯卡对切尔西的改造非常成功,他打造了一支年轻而充满活力的球队。切尔西的前场球员储备丰富,但后防线实力较弱。里斯·詹姆斯缺乏足够的领导力,不适合担任队长。恩佐·费尔南德斯也不适合担任队长,科尔·帕尔默更合适。 Flav: 热刺球迷对波斯特科格鲁的执教工作普遍满意,球队本赛季取得了显著进步。热刺本赛季能否进入前四,取决于他们在欧联杯中的表现。波斯特科格鲁能否赢得奖杯,将成为他本赛季的关键考核指标。波斯特科格鲁对热刺的态度与之前的教练不同,他展现出赢得奖杯的决心。 Luke Robinson: 阿斯顿维拉有能力赢得奖杯,球队本赛季表现稳定,潜力巨大。 Steven Mcinerney: 罗德里赢得金球奖实至名归,他是曼城过去几年取得成功的关键球员。罗德里赢得金球奖是对其职业生涯的肯定,他为曼城和西班牙国家队做出了巨大贡献。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why was Erik ten Hag sacked by Manchester United?

Erik ten Hag was sacked due to poor league performance, with Manchester United sitting 14th after nine games, and a series of disappointing results, including a 7-0 loss to Liverpool and a 4-0 defeat to Crystal Palace. The club felt it was time for a change after failing to see improvement despite significant investment in the squad.

Who is being considered as the next Manchester United manager?

Ruben Amorim, the current manager of Sporting Lisbon, is being considered for the Manchester United job. He has a strong track record in Portugal, winning two titles and competing in the Champions League, which makes him an exciting prospect for the club.

Why did Manchester United delay sacking Erik ten Hag after the FA Cup final?

Manchester United delayed sacking Erik ten Hag after the FA Cup final because the victory over Manchester City created a swell of positive sentiment around him. The club hoped that with better recruitment and structure, he could turn things around, but the poor start to the season forced their hand.

What are the concerns about Ruben Amorim potentially managing Manchester United?

Concerns about Ruben Amorim include his lack of experience in the Premier League and whether he can handle the immense pressure and scrutiny that comes with managing Manchester United. There are also questions about whether he can adapt his tactical approach, such as his preference for a 3-4-3 formation, to the club's traditional style.

Why did Rodri win the Ballon d'Or?

Rodri won the Ballon d'Or due to his exceptional performances for Manchester City and Spain, including winning the Premier League, UEFA Champions League, and the Euros. He is seen as a complete midfielder who contributes both defensively and offensively, scoring crucial goals and being a key playmaker.

What is the debate around Rodri winning the Ballon d'Or?

The debate around Rodri winning the Ballon d'Or centers on whether the award should celebrate beauty and artistry in football, often associated with attacking players, or effectiveness and consistency, which Rodri exemplifies. Some argue that players like Vinicius Junior or Cole Palmer, who are more flashy and creative, should have won instead.

What are the expectations for Arsenal under Mikel Arteta this season?

Expectations for Arsenal under Mikel Arteta are high, with fans believing the team can win the Premier League. The team has shown a balance of defensive solidity and attacking prowess, but there are concerns about their ability to consistently perform in big games and whether they can overcome injuries and suspensions.

Why is Cole Palmer considered one of the best footballers in the world?

Cole Palmer is considered one of the best footballers in the world due to his exceptional technical skills, creativity, and ability to influence games with goals and assists. His performances have reinvigorated Chelsea's attack, and he is seen as a player who can elevate the team to new heights.

What are the challenges facing Chelsea's defense this season?

Chelsea's defense is struggling with inconsistency and a lack of leadership, particularly from captain Rhys James, who has been plagued by injuries. The team has depth in attack but is vulnerable at the back, which has cost them points in key matches.

What is the outlook for Aston Villa under Unai Emery?

Aston Villa is thriving under Unai Emery, with the team performing consistently in the Premier League and competing in the Champions League. Emery has complete control over the team, and there is optimism that Villa can challenge for trophies and continue to improve under his leadership.

Shownotes Transcript

Welcome back to The Overlap’s Fan Debate, brought to you by Sky Bet. 

 

Jamie Carragher is joined by Paul Scholes alongside some of the biggest fan channels across England. We are also joined by Manchester United correspondent for The Athletic, Laurie Whitwell.

 

We kick things off by looking at the big news from the week - Manchester United sacking Erik ten Hag. Would Emery go to United? Is Amorim the right man for the job?

 

Plus, will Pep stay at Manchester City? Can Arsenal win the league with the set up they have? Will Aston Villa win a trophy this year? Who should have the Chelsea captaincy? 

 

Finally, was Rodri the right player to win the Ballon d'Or?

 

00:00 - Promo

00:41 - Introduction 

01:01 - Paul Scholes on Manchester United and Erik ten Hag being sacked

03:04 - Laurie Whitwell on Manchester United’s situation 

06:51 - Manchester United fan Adam McKola

12:03 - Liverpool fan Gareth Roberts

13:57 - Would Emery go to United?

14:58 - Manchester City fan Steven Mcinerney 

22:44 - Super 6 winner Lee Andrews

24:41 - Arsenal fan Charlene Smith

40:41 - Chelsea fan Rory Jennings 

48:26 - Tottenham fan Flav

52:12 - Aston Villa fan Luke Robinson

54:16 - Rodri winning the Ballon d’Or

  Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy) for more information.