The Dead Sea Scrolls Mystery
37:08 Share

With an hour before boarding, there's only one place to go, the Chase Sapphire Lounge by the club. There, you can recharge before the big adventure or enjoy a locally inspired dish. You can recline in a comfy chair to catch up on your favorite show or order a craft cocktail at the bar.

Whatever you're in the mood for, find the detail that moves you with curated touches at the Chase Sapphire Lounge by the club. Chase, make more of what's yours. Learn more at chase.com slash sapphire reserve. Cards issued by JPMorgan Chase Bank and a member FDIC. Subject to credit approval.

This episode is brought to you by Opel, the first over-the-counter daily birth control pill available in the U.S. Opel is FDA approved, full prescription strength and estrogen free. Plus, there's no prescription needed. Finally, the days of needing a prescription for birth control are over. Opel is available online and at most major retailers. Take control of your health and reproductive journey with Opel. Birth control in your control. Use code birth control for 25% off your first month of Opel at opel.com.

Welcome to the Forbidden History Podcast. This program is presented solely for educational and entertainment purposes. It contains mature adult themes. Listener discretion is advised. The Dead Sea Scrolls were one of the most important archaeological finds of the time. They are also one of the world's greatest conspiracies. They were discovered in the caves of Qumran, near the Dead Sea. But what was written on them? What secrets about Jesus do they reveal?

Why did the Roman Catholic Church keep them out of the public domain for nearly 30 years? And why were they considered so controversial?

To modern Israel, the Dead Sea Scrolls are of immense significance and they're treated with enormous respect and reverence. They bridge a gap in knowledge about Jewish history. The most fascinating document that came out of Qumran was undoubtedly the Copper Scroll. The records that it kept were about treasure.

I have no doubt that there's really sexy, really heretical information in the Dead Sea Scrolls that we may never see. The scrolls were not published for 40, 50 years. When they were asked repeatedly, "When are you going to publish the scrolls?" They kept saying, "It's on a need-to-know basis." I mean, can you imagine any historical discovery where that would be tolerated today?

The Dead Sea Scrolls are made up of thousands of written fragments, remains of larger manuscripts damaged by natural causes or perhaps human interference. However, there are fewer than a dozen well-preserved, almost intact manuscripts that have survived. And using radiocarbon tests, scholars have dated them from about three centuries BC to around the first century AD.

They were all discovered in just 11 caves in Qumran, about a mile from the Dead Sea. Some big questions remain: Why were they kept secret by the Vatican? And what else is buried out here? One of the reasons for the great mystery about the Dead Sea Scrolls is the fact that after they were found,

They were kept secret for decades and it wasn't a very long time until they were released to scholars. In that atmosphere, particularly of biblical research where there's very little new material for people to look at, this became explosive. People were wondering what is in them. The texts have great historical, religious and linguistic significance because they are some of the oldest written works about the Jewish people ever found.

They are primarily written on parchment and papyrus, with one even on copper, some in Hebrew, some in Aramaic, and some in Greek. Some archaeologists have associated the scrolls with the ancient Jewish sect called the Essenes, although recent interpretations have challenged this, while scholars argue that priests in Jerusalem or other Jewish groups actually wrote the scrolls.

A number of authorities had control over them at different times. The Jordanians, the Israelis, the Vatican. And of course, in an environment when these weren't being released, there was suspicion that they weren't being released for a reason. The Vatican wasn't letting people know what was in them because there might be something there that didn't suit the Vatican.

People think the conspiracy around the Dead Sea Scrolls is because the Catholic Church didn't want us to find out some really juicy stuff about Jesus that would alter our perception of the Church. So what if they had the truth about the nature of Jesus and Mary Magdalene? All sorts of things that are just completely opposed to what's been taught ever since. Now that's a lot to fear.

Because of the poor condition of some of the scrolls, scholars have not been able to identify all of them. But here's what is known: Some 40% are made up of copies of texts from the Hebrew Scriptures, about another 30% are from the Second Temple Period, and the remainder, roughly 30%, are non-religious manuscripts that shed light on the rules and beliefs of a particular Jewish group, believed to be the Essenes.

But can cutting-edge science reveal any new information? This area of Qumran is remote, arid, and not lived in today. But it is a hotbed for archaeological digs searching for the scrolls. Historian and archaeologist Danny Herman has been involved in a number of them and has a particular interest in the Copper Scroll, a treasure map of sorts. Investigative reporter Jamie Thexton has joined Danny in his trip to Qumran.

The Copper Scroll is really a big mystery on so many levels. If this group was living in the middle of nowhere, how could it have so much wealth, the wealth that is described in the Copper Scroll? I personally believe that the Copper Scroll is a league of itself. It's not part of the Dead Sea Scrolls. It was created by the priests in Jerusalem and taken to be hidden with the Dead Sea Scrolls as the Romans were advancing.

And that would explain why the other scrolls are all on papyrus or parchment and this one was on copper, right? That they were actually different... That could also explain how could someone both mention such treasures and also afford such expensive material to write on or incise the letters on. And that's a copper sheet. It's way more expensive than the papyrus or parchment.

The Copper Scroll is so enticing because it details treasure, gold, silver, coins that would be worth billions today. Why would you go to all the trouble to make this really difficult Copper Scroll and then hide it if it never existed in the first place? It just makes no sense. In 1956, English archaeologist John Allegro was the first to transcribe the Copper Scroll.

and identified possible locations where temple treasures were hidden around Qumran. Danny was part of an archaeological team that went to one of the locations listed as a potential hiding place for some of the treasures. But the question remains whether this man-made tunnel is indeed the one mentioned in the scroll. So here we are in an area of the valley that becomes a canyon, but it's all natural. And yet,

On the left side of this canyon, in the 1960s, Allegro publishes the existence of a man-made tunnel. And the reason he got so interested in this tunnel is because he argued that it could be the tunnel mentioned in Section A of the Copper Scroll. And if it is indeed the one, it could be containing huge amounts of treasures, of silver, of temple tools. Who knows what could be hidden in there?

The Copper Scroll lists 60 hiding locations and containing maybe 100 or 200 tons of gold and silver. That by itself sounds like an hallucination, you know, who could have so much wealth? But let's remember up in Jerusalem the priests were collecting huge amounts of wealth from the temple tax and from donations of Jews from all around the world. So such quantities of wealth are possible.

But why would they be hidden and why would they be documented on a copper scroll? And why would that copper scroll be hidden with the Dead Sea Scrolls next to the Dead Sea? If we were to find at least one of the treasures, we could at least tell that copper scroll is a real documentation of real treasures.

I don't think it's a hoax because you've got the Romans bearing down on you. You know, they're coming for you. What are you going to do? Sit there and write a huge lengthy hoax on a copper scroll? Doesn't seem like a good idea. Probably better to run actually at that point. So these are people desperately writing this stuff down in the hope it will be found. I don't think it's a hoax. I think it's somewhere out there. Although archaeologists never found treasures in the first tunnel,

Danny takes Jamie and the team to a second location nearby that fits the description as a possible hiding place for treasure. It's just down the stream. Another tunnel similarly designed on the left side of the drive river bed going in a very sharp angle. Maybe this one will contain the treasures. Can we go in there? We climb in? We can, but it's a bit dangerous. You could be running out of air at a certain depth.

archaeologists cleared a massive amount of rock and debris which exposed this 130-foot-long tunnel. This is not an aqueduct or a system. It's just a man-made tunnel that goes to nowhere. Okay, but we were excited. Sure. Because the potential was huge. You know, such a tunnel could be hiding the treasures of the Copper Scroll, or at least some of it. That was the hope. And that's what kept you going. That's what kept you digging. That was, for me personally, a big motivation. Sure.

And finding nothing at the end, that was quite disappointing. Inevitably, when there is wealth of that magnitude hidden around somewhere, this gets the attention of archaeologists and of treasure hunters. And since the release of the copper scroll and the details, people have tried very hard to locate these places. Not with great success, but it hasn't stopped armies of them trying. It wasn't until 1991, a full 44 years after they were first discovered,

that photographs of the scrolls were made available to the public. In November of that year, the Biblical Archaeological Society and the Huntington Library promised to open all the microfilm files of every scroll photograph.

I don't think people immediately realized how important this discovery was. Bits went in different directions. The Hebrew University ended up with some and Syrian Archbishop ran off to New York with another bit of it. But I think as it became evident what this was, then the excitement rose hugely. The Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered in Qumran, about an hour and a half car ride from Jerusalem.

But the city itself is literally alive with historic treasures. Chader Beydoun is one of Jerusalem's most famous antique dealers. His shop is here in the Old City. It really is a treasure trove of artifacts that cover the last 6,000 years. Historic relics are big business in Jerusalem. It's not only relics that Chader is an expert on.

40 years after the discovery of the first scrolls, he says he actually met the Bedouin shepherd who found them. So Khada, tell me how the Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered. It was by accident when he lost one of his goats. He was looking to find it and it was in a cave, that cave. When he went down to see, to look after his goat, he found the jars around the cave.

And it was full of scrolls, each jar with one scroll. And then he finds it and he picks one or two of them at that time, just for curiosity. He didn't know what it is. And then he was walking in Bethlehem where he met a sandaler, a guy who fixes the sandals. And then he said, "I found this thing here, do you know what it is?"

money or whatever. Then he said to him, "Okay, you know how or what? We can swap it, just give you one sandal." So one of the most important discoveries of all time, he swapped for a pair of sandals. Yes, he swapped it with them and then he had no idea how much it was.

The story of what happens to the scrolls is really interesting because at first they're completely invalidated. The boys take them back to the village, the village elders take them to various places and in Bethlehem they're told, "No, these are fakes, they're worthless, they're probably stolen from some synagogue." But eventually, shortly thereafter, in 1947, someone who understands what they really are buys the first few of them in Jerusalem. And then before you know it,

There's advertisements in the Wall Street Journal for these scrolls and they've been trying to sell them to universities for large sums of money. So, I mean, how much would they be worth, the Dead Sea Scrolls, if someone was to find them today? In that time? I mean, in that time there was not much of money in the hands of the people. When you talk about in that time, one million, like you are saying now,

900 million. Wow. Worth a lot of money. And so could there be more scrolls hidden in caves around Qumran now? Certainly there is more because what I believe that there is the big possibility because of this 2000 year raining and the weather and there was earthquake and it cover one of these caves and

That's the possibility that still in one of these caves. It might come as some surprise, but the black market for the Dead Sea Scrolls is still alive and well and has been since 1947 when they first were kind of discovered and acknowledged as existing in the first place. And they trade because there's always going to be interest from wealthy patrons.

who want to get their hands on these. And it's also reflective of the fact that while we have an official Israeli organization that holds the known Dead Sea Scrolls, there are many others that are not part of that library. Even though there could be some fragments of the scrolls in private collections today, the vast majority can be found at the Dead Sea Scrolls Laboratory at the Israeli Antiquities Authority.

The preservation and research on the scrolls by the Israelis is led by the head of the Dead Sea Scrolls Project, Penina Shor, who has given Jamie Theakston special permission to see some real pieces of the actual Dead Sea Scrolls.

The big scroll is as important as, or might be as important as this minute fragment because it can be the missing link in the jigsaw puzzle. And therefore every single fragment is being treated. But hang on, so is there writing on these tiny fragments? Yes, yes, there's writing on these fragments but because it has been taped, the residues of the tape

enter or they penetrate the parchment or the papyrus and they cause their disintegration. The work being done is painstaking beyond belief. We say scrolls, but actually many of them are fragments no bigger than your fingernail. This is like putting together a jigsaw of the Mona Lisa that's the size of four football pitches.

But the reason it's being done is because the information in those scrolls about that crucial period of Judaism, as they're moving from temple Judaism through to the more synagogue-based version that we would recognize today, and the evolution in that time of sects and cults like Christianity, is fascinating to the history of Judaism, and there are no other sources for it. This is unique and therefore is very important to those who specialize in this area.

This show is sponsored by BetterHelp. Halloween is the spookiest time of year. A time where we get to have fun with what scares us.

Here at Forbidden History, we love delving into eerie and mysterious stories and exploring those weird and sometimes spine-chilling historical tales. But what about those fears that are not ghosts and goblins or creepy stories from the past? For many people, the idea of therapy could seem pretty frightening. But sometimes holding ourselves back and not facing those fears in the first place is the scariest part.

If you're feeling ready to talk them through or have been thinking about giving therapy a chance, BetterHelp is a great place to start. It's entirely online and designed to be flexible and convenient. Getting started isn't spooky at all. Just fill out a brief questionnaire to be matched with an experienced and licensed professional. Overcome your fears with BetterHelp.

Visit BetterHelp.com slash ForbiddenUS today to get 10% off your first month. That's BetterHelp, H-E-L-P dot com slash ForbiddenUS. What do the remains of the Dead Sea Scrolls reveal? How important are the writings that have been deciphered? And what else is still buried out in Qumran?

Fragments of the Dead Sea Scrolls have been unearthed from caves located around Qumran. These discoveries have found their way into private collections around the world, but a large number have been painstakingly restored at the Israeli Antiquities Authority. Today, the Jewish people hold the Dead Sea Scrolls as sacred.

and as they should, because they represent the earliest sort of full description of their religious origins. The preservation of the scrolls is clearly a massive task, with thousands of fragments still to be catalogued and archived. Although some of the processed scrolls are even on display in museums around the world for the public to see,

Some archaeologists believe there is still more to be found. A team of archaeologists in Qumran, known as Operation Scroll, excavated a 12th cave, known as Cave 53, early in 2017. Despite the cave having been looted, the experts confirm that it did once hold scrolls. One of the men in charge of the team is Dr. Oren Gutfeld,

Now I've spoken to several experts who say that the whole area around Qumran has been surveyed once, twice, three times and there's nothing more to be found. Do you agree? Well, that's not true. In the last five to seven years, more and more small pieces of fragments, of perchments, of squalls arrived to the market here in the old city of Jerusalem.

So you're telling me that fragments of scrolls are traded by dealers here in the old city? That's correct. That's correct.

Of course people are still looking for this treasure and why wouldn't they? There's a Jewish archaeologist by the name of Dr. Oren Goodfield who is doing a lot of work in this area and he's finding things in caves around Qumran that are suggesting that there were scrolls there. There's fragments of papyrus, there's shards of pottery. So it's really quite encouraging that we might be beginning to decipher this copper scroll after all these years.

Today, the State of Israel established a new survey program, Operation Scroll 2, sponsored by the government, with teams that now, this minute, are surveying on the cliffs and working in the caves. So I don't know, from that, they got the idea that there's nothing more to look over there. And look, my cave, Cave 53, is the proof that there's more over there. We have found a new scroll cave.

The Dead Sea Scrolls are considered reliable historic discoveries concerning the Jewish people. But how much do we actually learn about them from these scrolls? Dr. Noam Mizrahi is a celebrated academic who agreed to meet with Jamie Thixton and deliver the unvarnished truth. So, Noam, tell me what actually is contained in the manuscripts. What do they tell us? What is actually written down on the scrolls?

It's a bit of a bewildering collection of texts, to be honest. We can divide the scrolls into three or four major groups of texts. One group of texts, which is about 25% of the material, so about, let's say, 250 scrolls.

is what we call biblical scrolls. The earliest copies of books that we know as parts of the Hebrew Bible. Right, but the kind of stuff that we knew anyway. Stuff we've read. Absolutely. However, it's very important for me to emphasize that almost none of these copies is identical

to the text of the Bible as we know it. Sometimes the differences are very slight, they're matters of spelling, of orthography, of language. Sometimes, however, these are major differences. The text, it's like that you read a different edition of the same text. So should we be updating the Bible? Should we be updating the Old Testament with these discoveries? Well, we should definitely know that even the Old Testament had a history. So before the Dead Sea Scrolls,

The oldest version of the New Testament we had was from about the 400s, but the oldest version of the Old Testament was actually a lot more recent, it was only 1,000 years old. So this meant we now had a 2,000-year-old version of the Old Testament, everything except the Book of Esther. So that in itself, obviously, was fascinating to both Jews and Christians, but also we learnt a lot about this strange community out there in Qumran who were a kind of mix of

Radical Jews and proto-Christians. You know, I think you have to see this very fluid environment. It tells us a lot about the sort of people who invented modern Judaism and modern Christianity. Do you think that there are still secrets hidden within the scrolls, within the documents that we are yet to find out? The scrolls have disintegrated into so many small fragments and the assortment of these fragments, it's like a huge number of jigsaw puzzles.

that we're still playing with. So every year there's a new publication, more than one publication, which offers a new identification of fragments, a new assortment, a new joining of fragments, and then this in turn recolors our understanding of the text. Do you think it's possible that there are more scrolls hidden in Qumran or in the mountains nearby? Personally, I very much hope that there are.

It would be wonderful, of course, if we get other scrolls. Even if we get other copies of the same text that we have in Qumran, even that would be a major help because so many of the texts are so hopelessly fragmentary that every new bit of information would be crucial.

It's possible there's a lot more to find at Qumran because we don't know the extent of the cave network. People did bury stuff and certainly around the time of the Roman suppression in about 130 AD, a lot of those documents have gone missing. Something of a dark age in historical knowledge. And yes, there probably is a lot more stuff, but whether it's going to be explosive and sensational, you know, to outsiders or just some more academic stuff,

is absolutely open to question. With an hour before boarding, there's only one place to go: the Chase Sapphire Lounge by the club. There, you can recharge before the big adventure or enjoy a locally inspired dish. You can recline in a comfy chair to catch up on your favorite show or order a craft cocktail at the bar.

Whatever you're in the mood for, find the detail that moves you with curated touches at the Chase Sapphire Lounge by the club. Chase, make more of what's yours. Learn more at chase.com slash sapphire reserve. Cards issued by JPMorgan Chase Bank and a member FDIC. Subject to credit approval.

This episode is brought to you by CarMax. Searching for your next car? Don't settle, thrive. At CarMax, it's easy to shop online or in person. With upfront pricing and tools designed to help, finding a car you love has never been easier. Plus, you can sell or trade in your current vehicle with an online offer in minutes. No strings attached. Start shopping now to find a car you'll love at CarMax.com. CarMax, the way it should be.

But there is another equally fascinating story related to the Dead Sea Scrolls. An Englishman came forward in March 2011, claiming that he had found a small leather codex in a cave in Jordan. His name is David Elkington. According to the story, these ring-bound lead and copper codices were in the possession of an Israeli Bedouin farmer named Hassan Seyda.

who claimed that they'd been found by his great-grandfather in a cave a century ago. Elkington believes the codices could contain the earliest historical evidence of Jesus' existence, and was quoted in the press that they might be as important as the Dead Sea Scrolls. But could the codices really contain genuine information on the formation of Christianity in Qumran over 2,000 years ago?

The group at Qumran were obviously Nazareans, called in Greek Essenes. There's obviously a lot of evidence of connections between Jesus and this group, although he perhaps wasn't specifically a member of that group. My personal theory is that he wasn't a member of that group because he superseded them. In other words, they were kind of on a program to bring about the real, the true king of Israel in the proper way.

Hebrew-Jewish messianic sense of the word. And I think that when it came to Jesus, they had succeeded. So therefore, he's not a Nazarene. As the Gospels refer to him, he is the Nazarene.

He's the A1, number one, that's it, we've done it. I think that gives us quite a few pointers as to the connection between the teacher of righteousness and Jesus, the codices and the Dead Sea Scrolls, because the codices share much with the scrolls, and I believe that the codices will show the scrolls to be proto-Christian documents. I think that's why they've caused such an enormous amount of controversy.

The David Elkington codices are probably the best example of the fact that the world wants to maintain the status quo. Nothing new, don't rock the boat.

Immediately, everyone jumps on them and says, "No, they're fake. They're frauds." So the Israelis, every institution in the world say, "No, no, don't believe anything they say because they're frauds." And it makes you wonder if a real discovery, and maybe this is one, comes out. Will anyone believe it? Is everyone that intent on maintaining the status quo? We had no other option than to pursue it.

in order to quell the verification. It was the only way we could go about this, otherwise we would have to run and hide and be forever scarred by this appalling campaign. So I called Roger Webb, we looked him up online, I called him and we had a chat. And he was very jolly about the whole thing. He said, "Well," he said, "Yeah," he said, "they might well be fakes." He said, "Let's prove it." All the official channels have written off the codices as fake.

But Elkington decided to have the age of the lead tested by Professor Roger Webb of Surrey University in England, a leading expert on ion beam physics. His first test on the front cover found radioactive isotopes still active in the lead, meaning they are less than 150 years old. Not satisfied with the results, he ran some more tests on the inside pages.

So the second test showed no activity for the inner pages of the lead of the book, demonstrating that the lead now was genuinely old, at least over 150 years old, compared quite favourably to both a 400-year-old sample we had from a sash window and also a sample we had that was an example of Roman lead that had been in the ground for 2,000 years.

So this was quite favourable and suggested that we had actually real old lead greater than 150 years. There are aspects to the codices that could not have been faked. I mean, one of them being that over the course of 2,000 years, the metal matrix has disturbed. So what's happened is that impurities in the metal have gradually leached out of the metal and they've appeared on the surface where they've taken a crystalline form and then fallen out.

Okay, and you can see on some of the codices there are holes in the pages. And if you look on others, you can see the crystalline growth. Now, according to our expert, he said, well, you're looking here at a process that takes 1,600, 1,800 years, 2,000 years, easily. These are old. I mean, I certainly believe they are more than 150 years. That I don't have a problem with.

Going back 2,000 years, I don't know. I can't put an age on that at all. There are other evidences that it is actually quite old. The patina on them does actually indicate that these have been around and in contact with the ground for a long period of time. They look very similar to lead that we've dug up out of the ground from 2,000 years ago, so it's been in contact with the ground in the same way, and they look very similar to that. So in terms of the way they look, they look very authentic. I've never believed them to be fake.

If you follow a logical progression of why and how they exist and the circumstances in which you found them, it simply does not tell you that they are fake. And furthermore, nobody has yet convinced us of how they were faked. We've seen fakes, we've seen modern ones, and they are remarkably different. I mean so remarkably different that you want to fall about laughing at how crude they are, because when you're using lead, it can only be crude when you're using it in a modern circumstance.

It seems that experts are saying there are multiple dates ascribed to various bits of the codices. So it looks like it's been a bit of a mishmash put together at some point, not necessarily very recently.

there is still a wall of silence. There is still a wall of dogma, preservation, that I don't care what you've discovered or how accurately it dates or how authentic the non-biased laboratories say it is, it's not going to be accepted. It's really quite worrying. The Jordan Codice's legitimacy is inconclusive at best, but the mystery of the Dead Sea Scrolls is very much alive.

In the vast open space of Qumran, there may well be fragments waiting to be discovered by archaeologists still digging the site today.

I think what's more fascinating about the Dead Sea Scrolls and what's in them is actually why they were written, why they were hidden. You know, this was a community that was about to be slaughtered, basically, by the Romans. You know, they were on their way out. And we learn more about, you know, the desperate measures they took to hide the knowledge they had, how much importance they put on this knowledge. And then, of course, the Copper Scroll, you know, the treasure map, you know, which is fascinating. Indications are...

that we may have in the Dead Sea Scrolls, the tip of the iceberg. There's probably a lot more. And local and recent excavations are validating that there's signs of

shards of pottery and little fragments of papyrus that indicate that even more of the Dead Sea Scrolls are on the black market. And there's probably all sorts of caves and hideaways around the Dead Sea that we've yet to find. They are, without a doubt, a significant historical and biblical discovery. But how many other texts and scrolls still lie buried at Qumran and other sites in Israel and Jordan? Importantly,

How different are their facts from what we know from the Bible? Is this difference, or perhaps a fear of it, the reason why the authorities covered up the release of the Dead Sea Scrolls for over 40 years? And how much else is buried out here, in the caves and the deserts, that would challenge the Church's view of events of 2,000 years ago?