cover of episode The Best And Worst Post-Election Hot Takes

The Best And Worst Post-Election Hot Takes

2024/11/11
logo of podcast FiveThirtyEight Politics

FiveThirtyEight Politics

Key Insights

Why did the polls underestimate Trump's support in the 2024 election?

Polls were historically accurate with a 2.7% national error and 2% in battleground states, but they have consistently underestimated Trump's support in three consecutive elections, suggesting a persistent issue in capturing his voter base.

Why did Democrats lose support among working-class voters in the 2024 election?

Democrats' policies, such as the American Rescue Plan, contributed to high inflation and perceived inaction on immigration, aligning with Bernie Sanders' more liberal positions and alienating working-class voters who prioritized economic stability and border control.

Did Democrats lose because they focused on niche cultural issues?

Democrats did not primarily run on niche cultural issues; Republicans framed the narrative around these issues, but Democrats failed to effectively counter these attacks, leading to perceptions that hurt their campaign.

Does Trump have an unprecedented and powerful mandate after the 2024 election?

Trump does not have an unprecedented mandate; his victory was narrow, and Democrats retained control in several key states, indicating a divided nation rather than a clear mandate for his agenda.

How did the 2024 election reflect global trends in incumbent party losses?

The 2024 U.S. election mirrored a global trend where incumbent parties were punished by voters, with Democrats performing relatively well compared to other countries, suggesting they did as well as could be expected given broader political dynamics.

Chapters

The discussion revolves around the accuracy of polls in predicting the election results, with some arguing that polls underestimated Trump's popularity, while others highlight the polls' overall accuracy in swing states.
  • Polls were within 2.7 percentage points nationally and 2 percentage points in battleground states.
  • Polls have underestimated the Republican candidate in three consecutive presidential elections.
  • There is a debate on whether this is a systemic issue or a statistical fluke.

Shownotes Transcript

Since Election Day, there’s been no shortage of hot takes explaining what happened and what it all means. Have Democrats lost the working class? Does President-elect Donald Trump have an unprecedentedly powerful mandate? Were the polls wrong? On this episode of the 538 Politics podcast, the crew dives into these questions and others, determining which ones are more fact than fiction. They also check in on the status of the House and Senate and discuss how many downballot Democrats managed to overperform compared to Vice President Kamala Harris.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices)