Deep Dive
Shownotes Transcript
A New York City bodega recently started selling what they're calling "Lucy Eggs." Instead of a dozen or a half dozen, you can buy a little bag with three little eggs in it. The idea got a ton of attention.
It's not loose cigarettes, but loose eggs drawing people to Pamela's Green Deli. He says the idea to sell the loose eggs came after seeing customers being forced to leave a full carton on the counter. Currently, New York State requires eggs to be sold in packages. And while the price of eggs is cracking wallets right now, Rodriguez tells us he just hopes to help his community one day at a time.
Eggs are too expensive. Ask anyone. Ask the President of the United States. The eggs. Because I'm hearing so much about eggs, you'll figure it out. You've got to figure something out fast. But on today, Eggsplained, Vox's Kenny Torello is actually going to make the case that eggs are too cheap. Get a load of this guy, will ya?
Whatever you look for in a getaway, you can find it at Virginia Beach. When you're there, you'll be able to enjoy some of the best cultural attractions, activities, and culinary experiences the world has to offer. You could take a stroll on the world's longest pleasure beach that travels for miles and miles.
Or you could take part in their annual festivals, concerts, and waterfront dining. And if you're in the mood for dinner, make sure to check out their fresh local seafood with farm-to-table ingredients. It's a trip that everyone in the family will remember for a lifetime. Go to visitvirginiabeach.com to learn more.
Get the Angel Reef Special at McDonald's now. Let's break it down. My favorite barbecue sauce, American cheese, crispy bacon, pickles, onions, and a sesame seed bun, of course. And don't forget the fries and a drink. Sound good? Ba-da-ba-ba-ba. And participating restaurants for a limited time. It's, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's.
Kenny Torellis, senior reporter at Vox, our man on the meat beat. It's been a minute. What is going on with the bird flu? The bird flu is really bad. You know, this outbreak, which has been the worst in U.S. history, it began in early 2022 and it's only getting worse.
According to the USDA, avian flu has been confirmed in 146 flocks in the past month, affecting more than 20 million birds. The U.S. Department of Agriculture is calling this multi-year bird flu outbreak the largest in U.S. history. The impact hits close to home. Dozens of state and federal agricultural workers dressed in biohazard suits, sanitized boots and gloves are assisting in the euthanization of the entire flock here, 100,000 ducks.
This strain known as H5N1, it's a highly pathogenic strain of avian influenza or bird flu, which has been highly lethal to birds raised for meat and eggs like chickens and turkeys. You know, more than 20 million egg-laying hens were killed either because they became infected with the virus or they were killed to slow the spread of the virus. To put that into perspective, that's 6% of America's egg-laying flock.
Is that why the eggs are so expensive, Kenny? I don't want to make this about the eggs when you just said 20 million of our friendly chickens have died, but is that why the eggs are so expensive? That's really the only reason why eggs are so expensive, aside from food inflation.
The bird flu has led to egg shortages across the country. You know, some stores are even placing limits on how many cartons consumers can buy. Can someone explain to me why people are going crazy for eggs? Eggs are now so valuable they've become a target for thieves. Pete and Jerry's Organics had to beef up security after thieves stole 100,000 eggs from their farm in Pennsylvania. And...
The average price for a dozen of eggs is double now what it was before this outbreak began three years ago. All right, guys, today is a day. I know they are going to be $1.99 today. Chickens must be on a strike or something because, baby, ain't no way six eggs is $4.99.
The high price of eggs, it's not the only problem related to bird flu because it's increasingly affecting other animals. Scientists detected bird flu in cows for the first time ever in the United States almost a year ago. And since then, it's infected almost 1,000 dairy cow herds.
But it's also infecting and killing other mammals like sea lions and seals. And it even killed a cheetah and a mountain lion at a zoo in Arizona not too long ago. I don't love it. Yeah, there's not much to love about the bird flu, especially because it's now hitting humans. I don't love that at all. Tell me more about that. Yeah, almost 70 people in the U.S. have tested positive for bird flu since the spring of 2022. We're not doing mass testing, so it could be higher.
But most of them have been people who work with poultry or dairy cows, and most cases have been somewhat mild. But there have been a few cases that have stood out and have concerned experts. For example, last month there was a woman in Louisiana. She had exposure to a backyard chicken flock and also some wild birds. She got the bird flu. She was hospitalized, and tragically, she passed away from the virus.
And in November, a 13-year-old Canadian girl who had no known exposure to wild or farmed birds or dairy cows, she developed a really severe infection and was hospitalized for weeks. She recovered, but it's still a mystery as to how she got it.
But we're not at, like, you know, the pandemic threat yet either. I don't want to freak people out. No, we're not. The most important thing to keep in mind here is that almost all of these cases, again, were connected to people who work directly with animals or were exposed to animals who had the virus.
At this point, this virus is not going from person to person, which is one of the key ingredients for a virus going from one that just circulates among animals to the next global pandemic. And
H5N1 may never gain the ability to transmit from human to human, but the more that it circulates among people and animals and large farms, the more opportunities that it has to evolve and develop the capacity to become more severe in humans and be able to transmit from person to person.
Well, our fair president, I don't know how much he's said about bird flu. I don't know how much he cares, but he certainly has promised to bring down the price of eggs. The eggs, because I'm hearing so much about eggs, you'll figure it out. And since they're intrinsically related, let me ask, how's that going so far?
It's gotten off to a rocky start. You know, Doge and the Trump administration fired a number of employees who monitor bird flu, realized they made a mistake, and then hired them back. But in bigger news today, Brooke Rollins announced a big plan in the Wall Street Journal to fight bird flu and try to bring down the price of eggs. I'm sorry, Brooke who? Brooke Rollins. She's the new secretary of agriculture who has...
Not much of a background in agriculture, more in conservative think tank policymaking, but she does have a new five-point plan to tackle this crisis. Okay, well, what are the five points? Point one is to put $500 million towards increased biosecurity on farms. That includes things like more protective gear for farm workers, requiring them to shower before entering and leaving the facilities.
And this could help. It's worth a shot. But this has also been a main tactic of the Biden administration. So we'll see if it helps. OK, $500 million for some cold showers. What else? Increased funding for farmers who have to call or kill their flocks. Again, this is more of the same. This is something the Biden administration has done for the last three years.
Hmm. Okay. Anything fresh? Anything new? Yes and no. I mean, one point of the plan is to import more eggs, which is what the Obama administration did during the 2015 bird flu outbreak. And then there are some other ideas, like trying to roll back cage-free egg laws, which we're seeing some states already trying to do, and vaccines, which is actually welcome news.
Well, I know President Trump has a history with, you know, vaccinating millions of Americans, Operation Warp Speed, TBT, COVID-19, etc. But his new Secretary of Health and Human Services, Roberts Floride Kennedy, hates vaccines. How does he feel about vaccinating chickens, though?
Well, thankfully, that's the purview of the USDA. So RFK Jr. has no oversight over whether birds get vaccinated. Of course, I am worried that if this does start to transmit to more humans, he will have oversight over the development and distribution and approval of vaccines for people. But at least right now,
It's in the USDA's hands as to whether we start vaccinating egg-laying hens. Okay, so we've got five points, Kenny, ranging from more showers for people working on these chicken farms to vaccinating millions, hundreds of millions of chickens potentially. Do we have any idea when this five-point plan from Brooke Rollins would go into effect? I mean, we've got the Wall Street Journal op-ed. When do we see the money moving?
It's unclear. There's not a lot of specifics as to when and how this money will be deployed and how fast they'll act on things like expanding vaccine development. So it's more of a wait and see situation like the last few years have been with bird flu. OK, but this issue isn't going anywhere. What's cooking in the meantime? So some states are taking matters into their own hands.
New tonight, the Nevada Department of Agriculture has suspended the state's cage-free egg law. As the price of eggs continues to climb, one state lawmaker has introduced legislation that will repeal Michigan's new law requiring all eggs sold to be cage-free. The idea here is that by suspending this cage-free requirement, it'll give grocery stores more flexibility in where and how they source their eggs. But it probably won't work. You know, there is one ag economist at the University of Arkansas who
who said that suspending these cage-free standards could, quote-unquote, very slightly address the egg shortage in Nevada, but it could exacerbate it in other states because the national egg supply is just so limited. So if you shift more to Nevada, you got to take it from another state.
Ultimately, a big part of the problem here is factory farming itself. A typical egg factory farm operation will house hundreds of thousands or even millions of genetically similar animals in just a few barns. And in these barns, the animals, they're in their own waste. They're breathing in toxic fumes from their manure. They're overcrowded. All of this comes together to stress them out and weaken their immune systems. And
One historian who studies animal disease, who I talked to, said that these kinds of conditions create the perfect opportunity for a microbe or a virus like H5N1 to effectively spread through a lot of hosts. This doesn't mean that reverting back to...
The farming that we had a century ago, where chickens were raised in small flocks on small farms, would fix the problem of the bird flu spread. You know, farmers have always been battling disease outbreaks on farms. But the expansion of factory farms really exacerbate the risk. And because these farms are so big and have so many chickens, if the virus affects just a few really big farms, it can send a shock to the egg supply overnight, which is what has been going on for the last several months. ♪
Okay, so the culprit is factory farming, but also the norm is factory farming. Yeah, and it rarely grabs the country's attention. We don't really talk that much about factory farming. You know, we're only doing this show because of this outbreak and how it's affected egg prices and the egg supply. But...
there are millions of people in rural America who have been dealing with the public health effects of factory farms for decades. And many have been sounding the alarm, but no one's really been listening. So I spent the last several months talking to them for a series for Vox. And you're going to hear from them when we're back on Today Explained. Aww.
Support for today explained comes from Shopify. Business owners have a lot of spinning plates to balance. Frankly, it's kind of amazing that anyone is crazy enough to take on the challenge of starting a company. If you think about it, you've got to create a great product, manage a team, reach customers, and so much more. It's a lot. Luckily, there are platforms out there designed to take some of those responsibilities off of your spinning plate. Companies fail.
Like Shopify. Shopify is an all-in-one digital commerce platform that wants to help your business sell better than ever before. It doesn't matter if your customers spend their time scrolling through your feed or strolling past your physical storefront. Shopify says they can help you convert browsers into buyers and sell more over time.
And their shop pay feature can boost conversions by 50%. Want to upgrade your business and get the same checkout all birds uses? Hello, drop in names. You can sign up for your $1 per month trial period at shopify.com slash explained. That's shopify.com slash explained to upgrade your selling today. shopify.com slash explained.
Support for this daily news podcast comes from an entirely different daily news podcast, Up First from NPR. If you listened to Today Explained, you probably like the news, you're interested in the news, but you don't want to be totally grim and depressed all the time. And that's why you tune into our show. Up First actually has a very similar vibe. They cover the three most important stories of the day in just 15 minutes, so you can briskly learn what you need to know and then move on about your day. They cover everything, the current administration, the
business, economics, immigration policy. They're going to keep it brief, but they're going to keep it informative.
Fun fact about me, I used to be a co-host of Up First, and I can tell you that they have some of the best radio journalists in the game. Steve Inskeep, Michelle Martin, Leila Fadl, Ayesha Roscoe, A. Martinez, with you every day in your news feed, keeping you up to date on the most important stories of the day. If you're looking for a little more news and a little less noise, a good way to kick off your day and be a little more informed is Up First from NPR.
Your data is like gold to hackers. They're selling your passwords, bank details, and private messages. McAfee helps stop them. SecureVPN keeps your online activity private. AI-powered text scam detector spots phishing attempts instantly. And with award-winning antivirus, you get top-tier hacker protection. Plus, you'll get up to $2 million in identity theft coverage, all for just $39.99 for your first year. Visit McAfee.com. Cancel any time. Terms apply.
Let's go birds! Today Explained. Kenny Torella, MeatBeat, Vox.com. Factory farms are in the spotlight because of expensive eggs and bird flu. And you've been reporting on them. Where do we begin? So let's start in Malcolm, Iowa. Malcolm? Yep. In the middle? Yeah, it's actually in the middle of Iowa. You're not the boss of me now.
I went there in September. It's this tiny, sleepy town about 75 miles east of Des Moines. There's just a couple hundred people. There's a post office, a bar and grill, a lot of cornfields.
And on the surface, it's a generally quiet and peaceful small town, except it has millions of chickens. Seven and a half million chickens, to be exact. How many people does it have? 270 people. What? Okay, so that's like roughly what off the top of my head, like 28,000 chickens per person? That's right. You must be some kind of math prodigy. I didn't know that, Sean.
I'm Asian. Yeah, and I talked to a few folks in Malcolm. One of them stood out. Her name's Carolyn Bittner. It was probably a few days after I moved in that I smelled anything. She moved to Malcolm in 2008 to become a pastor at two churches. She's now retired.
And she told me that she really likes small-town rural life and that neighbors are kind to each other. Except this one neighbor, Fremont Farms of Iowa. That's the farm that has 7.5 million egg-laying chickens. It's not close to my house, but when they move manure, the stench is. And just last night, there was stench.
And as soon as I got to Malcolm, I understood what Carolyn was saying. There's the smell. The stench of manure hung in the air, and the closer you got to Fremont Farms of Iowa, the stronger and stronger it smelled. It was overwhelming. I love to hang my clothes on the line to dry. And sometimes in the morning, when I put them out, the air is clean because the wind is going the other way.
But if the wind shifts while they're out there, and especially if it shifts while they're still damp, I bring them in, not smelling...
Fresh and ozony, but smelling like chicken shit. Damn. Yeah, livestock farms generate nearly a trillion pounds of manure each year. And fumes from that manure creates terrible air pollution, which is linked to nine times more premature deaths than coal-fired power plants. This isn't like a happy story where like a trillion pounds of manure gets turned into a trillion pounds of fertilizer and recycles and closes the loop and all that.
Well, there's just simply way too much manure for it to all serve as fertilizer. So often farmers will over apply manure, which one, it smells really bad, but it also leaches into water, contaminates drinking water and other issues.
On top of that, other research has found that living near a factory farm is positively associated with risk of non-Hodgkin lymphoma, leukemia, and people who live near them also report higher rates of headaches, depression, anger, and respiratory symptoms such as asthma. Okay, that sounds worse than awful, Kenny. Why would you want to live here in Malcolm, Iowa, next to the manure?
Well, Carolyn moved to Malcolm for a job. She didn't know that there were also seven and a half million chickens in town. Huh. And I've heard that from other people that maybe they moved there and they didn't know, or maybe they've lived there for a lot of their lives. And the factory farms started coming in in the nineties and the early two thousands, and they had no choice but to just deal with it.
You know, Carolyn has tried to speak up for years and tell the farm about how terrible it smells. She's also spoken up at permit hearings, too. What has she said? How's that gone? It hasn't gone that well. I mean, nothing has changed. If anything, it's gotten worse because the chicken farm now has more animals than it did when she first moved in 2008. Hmm.
And a lot of this just comes down to public policy. You know, the problem is that the deck is stacked against Carolyn and people like her because usually local county and state permitting regulations are really lax. They're really friendly to the meat, dairy and egg industries. They allow these massive factory farms to come in to be built really close to people's homes, to churches and schools and businesses. Yeah.
And there's also usually pretty lax rules around how they handle that collective trillion pounds of manure. And she told me that while Fremont Farms is doing fine, the town is kind of disappearing. The population here in Malcolm has been declining since I moved in. Partly, I'm sure, it's because of the smell.
It's just not a very pleasant place to live anymore. So Malcolm cares more about this farm and the revenue it brings in than it does the people who might bounce. It seems so. And, you know, I've talked to a bunch of people in similar circumstances. You know, there are thousands and thousands of these huge factory farms across the country. You know, there are wounds in this neighborhood that...
One person I talked to, her name is Sonia in Minnesota. She says that fights over big dairy operations and pig factory farms near her have torn her community apart. Yeah.
Dang. Yeah, and there's Edith in Worth County, Iowa, who told me that a lot of her neighbors won't speak publicly against the factory farms near them. Hmm.
You know, they'll lose money, opportunities. Small business people really have to watch it because even if they support...
being against factory farms, they'll lose business customers. - Okay, so not only are we killing millions and millions of chickens and not even eating them because of bird flu, and not only are eggs more expensive across the entire country, but just living near these farms is a shit show.
President Trump says he wants to do something about the price of eggs. He's got Elon Musk at his side. I don't know what his diet is, but he's also got RFK at his other side. And that dude's always going on about factory farms and agriculture in the United States and how we need to fix it. I spent a lot of my career suing factory farms. And I probably sued Smithfield more than any other attorney, Tyson's, Purdue. Is there an opportunity to hit reset right now?
Yeah, RFK Jr. over the years has really criticized factory farming. In fact, for 20 years, he was the president of the Waterkeeper Alliance, which is this group that does really great work to combat water pollution from these huge farms. But I have my doubts that he's going to really do much to shake up the agricultural status quo here. How come? Because he wasn't put in charge of agriculture? Yeah, that's right. He's in charge of HHS, which includes the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, but
But it's the Agriculture Department and the Environmental Protection Agency who are really in charge of regulating farms and all of this pollution. It sounds like what you're saying, Kenny, is that the only way this would actually change and there'd be enough attention on factory farming to actually achieve political change would be if there were something as catastrophic as like a bird flu pandemic.
Maybe. I mean, maybe if we get to a point where we're rationing eggs. Even then it's a maybe? I mean, you know, in 2009, over 10,000 Americans died from swine flu, which originated in pigs. And today, pig factory farming looks exactly like it did in 2009. So it's hard to say what, if anything, could push the country to...
really rethink how we raise animals for food. And I'm not even sure a major bird flu pandemic could do it. So that leaves us where? It's on us, the consumers, to make different choices. That's true. We've become really accustomed to cheap eggs and other animal products. And I think visiting Iowa and hearing stories from people like Carolyn and
you come to realize that there is a cost to these cheap eggs and other products. There is a cost to the environment. There's a cost to people who live in rural America near factory farms. There's a cost to the animals who are treated really terribly. So yeah, there's always going to be this tension and trade-off
You know, we can opt to eat fewer eggs. We can eat egg alternative products like plant-based eggs. We can also use this as an opportunity to learn more about the factory farming system and maybe rethink how we produce food. I hope that's the one kind of silver lining of this terrible bird flu outbreak is that it gives us time to pause and think about how we might raise food in a more humane and sustainable way.
Kenny Torella, Vox.com. He also makes music. In fact, he's a music critic.
All of the music you heard on today's show came from Kenny, who goes by Torello when he's dropping beats. Kenny's reporting was supported by Animal Charity Evaluators, which received a grant from the Builders Initiative. And Vox's future perfect fellow, Sam Delgado, assisted with Kenny's reporting. Thank you, Sam. Miles Bryan produced this episode. Amina Alsadi edited. Laura Bullard fact-checked. Andrea Christen's daughter and Patrick Boyd mixed.
I'm Sean Ramos-Firm, and it's today explained. Go Barts!