Why is horror so fun?
21:52 Share

Let's go places.

At Apple Podcasts, we're obsessed with good stories. That's why this fall, we're introducing Series Essentials. Each month, our editors choose one series that we think will captivate you from start to finish, presented completely ad-free.

This month, we invite you to check out Wondery's ghost story. In this gripping tale, journalist Tristan Redmond's investigation into a haunted bedroom takes a surprising turn when he discovers a dark secret connecting his own family to the ghost. The story features homicide detectives, ghost hunters, and even psychic mediums. Apple Podcasts Series Essentials. One story you won't want to miss. Selected each month. Listen completely ad-free, only on Apple Podcasts.

Matthias Klassen spends a lot of his time thinking about terrifying things. I have a fondness for scary books. I really like that experience of being really messed up by letters on a page. And I remember being really interested in scary stuff as a teenager, but also being puzzled at why. Because I would read a Stephen King novel or watch a slasher movie and then feel compelled to sleep with the lights on for several nights.

It's kind of weird if you think about it from an evolutionary standpoint, right? Like, running away from scary stuff makes sense. We're probably more likely to survive if we skedaddle when we're spooked by something. But why do we also then run towards scary things sometimes? Like, why do we run towards scary things?

Why do we pay good money to go to a movie theater and freak out? It is this paradox of horror that fascinated Matthias. He wound up studying horror for a living. He joined the English department at Aarhus University in Denmark, but also looked at other disciplines to try and understand his subject matter better.

And that is where Mark Anderson winds up coming in. About a decade ago, Mark was doing his PhD at Aarhus University as well, studying cognitive science and religion. And Matthias was this weird dude who came to our department and presented on, you know, all this weird horror stuff that he was very interested in. Talking about his questions like... Why is it that humans are attracted...

to experiences that at their core are negative. Why is it that we like stuff that we don't like? Now, Mark does not really experience this contradiction firsthand. I'm not really that much into horror. I don't like it very much. It's mostly Matthias that likes it, and he's the sort of stone-cold person in the room. I'm a much more timid kind of guy.

he was still really intrigued by the weird paradox of horror that Matias was talking about. And so this scientist, who does not really love horror, and this literature professor who loves it quite a lot, ended up starting a cross-disciplinary quest to explore horror together. I think that's one key to our success is we have these nicely overlapping perspectives

domains of expertise. You know, Mark is really good at designing experiments and doing statistical analysis. And I like Stephen King novels.

Matthias and Mark are now co-directors of an entire lab devoted to studying this thing that they call recreational fear. We see it everywhere. It's little kids enjoying peekaboo. It's teenagers liking scary movies. It's middle-aged people going on dark tourism or getting on roller coasters. But at the same time, it's sort of scientifically understudied or even ignored. So there was something there that...

mandated, serious scientific study. Plus, we were having a hell of a lot of fun doing it. So, this is Unexplainable. I'm Burt Pinkerton. And today on the show, a hell of a lot of fun with a paradox of horror. ♪♪

Mark and Matthias and some of their colleagues, they decided to explore some basic aspects of the relationship between fear and fun. They wanted to understand what was going on in people's heads and bodies when they were spooking themselves. And to do that, they went to a haunted house. Dystopia Haunted House is an old abandoned fish factory lying in the midst of the woods.

The factory consists of about 50 rooms, and so guests buy a ticket, they walk through the 50 rooms where they're chased by, you know, pig men with chainsaws and killer clowns and zombies and so on. Mark, do you enjoy this house? From the outside, very much, yes. I have been forced into the haunted house, I think, three times by now, and...

I mean, it is getting easier each time. Yeah, I remember once we were in the haunt with a collaborator and we kept yelling at each other, you know, you go first, you're the postdoc. No, you go first, you're the PI. All in a relatively good spirit. We made it through. It was a fun bonding experience, but it could have gone the other way. You know, one of us could have pushed the other in front of the guy with the chainsaw, which might have ended the collaboration right there and then.

I'll just add that that is exactly what Matthias did to me, who was the postdoc back then, by the way. This may not seem like a great place to do serious science, but Matthias and Mark thought it actually might be kind of ideal. Because in this setting, they could study people who were really freaked out.

After all, in a lab setting, there's only so much you can do to scare the bejesus out of people before you start crossing some ethical lines, right? But if someone shows up at an abandoned fish factory literally looking to be scared, that is their choice. So it's a ridiculously chaotic context in which to try to do any kind of controlled, systematic, scientific investigation.

They're trying to mount a surveillance camera and then some clown, a literal clown actor will come and throw fake blood on us. But in a way, this kind of horror house is much more well calibrated to investigate the kind of phenomena that we are really interested in deep down. The kind of insight we can get into recreational fear, it's just, it's out of this world.

Take this one study, for example, that gave Matias and Mark and their colleagues a really key set of insights into how fear and fun might be connected. In the study, they asked a bunch of participants to fill out a questionnaire before they went through the haunted house. They hooked them up to a heart rate monitor, filmed them during some of the house's biggest jump scares, and then surveyed them again right after they left the house.

All of this to kind of get a sense of both how scared they'd been, but also how much they had enjoyed themselves. And they found that their relationship between self-reported fear and self-reported fun in the surveys had this kind of upside down U-shape.

You can think of it as sort of the Goldilocks principle of horror, right? That too little fear is not that enjoyable when you are in a haunted attraction, but a lot of fear is actually not that enjoyable as well. There seems to be sort of a middle way where participants report the highest levels of enjoyment.

And this pattern showed up in their other measurements too. Like some of the data from the heart rate monitors again showed that the people who enjoyed themselves the most tended to be the people whose hearts were behaving a little differently from their usual, but not like enormously so. So it is as if humans dislike being very far from their normal physical state.

But we seem to like being a little bit out of our comfort zone or a little bit out of our normal state. Studies like this have fed into a hypothesis that Mark and Matthias have developed about the potential purpose for recreational fear, like why we might seek it out. And the deeper that they have gone into their research, the more they've started to feel this nagging sense that something is terribly, terribly wrong.

Like now that they've unlocked this awful secret, they will never be able to lock it away ever again. I'm just kidding. Their research has not led to anything deeply horrifying, but it has given them a window into how we might be facing our fears. So more on that after the break.

Support for Unexplainable comes from Autograph Collection Hotels. That's from Marriott. And just saying, did you know it was pronounced Marriott? I always said Mary-on. Marriott. Now we know. Every hotel in the collection is inspired by a clear vision and story that makes it individual and special.

Guests can have unforgettable experiences that leave a lasting imprint, from practicing medieval falconry in an Irish country estate, to exploring ancient Costa Rican mangroves, to tasting volcanic wines on the Greek island of Santorini. Hand-selected for their inherent craft and distinct perspectives, each hotel tells its own unique story through immersive design, whether inspired by the horse and mule barns of Fort Worth, Texas, or the 13th century monasteries of Prague.

Autograph Collection is part of the Marriott Bonvoy portfolio of more than 30 hotel brands around the world. You can find the unforgettable at autographcollection.com.

Support for Unexplainable comes from Huntress. If you're a small business owner, you know how scary hackers can be. But Huntress offers a new approach to managed security that isn't all about tech. It's real people providing real defense. When threats come up or issues happen, they say their team of seasoned cyber experts is ready 24 hours a day, 365 days a year for support.

They provide real-time protection for endpoints, identities, and employees, all from a single dashboard. And they can do this because their cutting-edge solutions are backed by experts who monitor, investigate, and respond to threats with unmatched precision. Huntress has helped over 125,000 businesses, and now you can bring enterprise-level expertise to your business without needing a massive IT department. You can visit huntress.com to start a free trial or to learn more.

At Apple Podcasts, we're obsessed with good stories. That's why this fall, we're introducing Series Essentials. Each month, our editors choose one series that we think will captivate you from start to finish, presented completely ad-free.

This month, we invite you to check out Wondery's ghost story. In this gripping tale, journalist Tristan Redmond's investigation into a haunted bedroom takes a surprising turn when he discovers a dark secret connecting his own family to the ghost. The story features homicide detectives, ghost hunters, and even psychic mediums. Apple Podcasts Series Essentials. One story you won't want to miss. Selected each month. Listen completely ad-free, only on Apple Podcasts.

In a horror story, there are only victims and monsters. And the trick is not to end up as either. So in their haunted house study, Mark and Matias saw this kind of U-shaped relationship between fear and fun. Basically, too much or too little fear. Not that fun. Somewhere in the middle, just kind of like sweet spot of fear. Very fun.

And they were seeing the same pattern in other research too. We know from studies on curiosity that humans get curious about things where they expect a moderate surprise. They are not really curious about things where they know that their predictions are going to be way off.

They are typically interested in things that lie a little bit outside of their normal knowledge. So that same kind of Goldilocks effect, where something that's just the right amount out of your comfort zone is the most interesting or the most fun. And seeing these similarities between curiosity on the one hand and fear for fun on the other, it led Marc and Matthias to their hypothesis, which is,

Maybe when people seek out a little fun fear, they're actually trying to learn through play, like trying to teach their bodies how to handle fear. It's about learning how your body reacts, for instance, when you become scared.

We know from other studies in cognitive science that the brain has a tendency of suppressing input that it can predict. So if you have tried something several times, then oftentimes that experience feels less intensive. So one of the main hypotheses that we have is that recreational fear exposure allows you to learn about fear and handle it in a sort of more optimal way, you could say.

Unfortunately, Matthias and Mark's lab got a great opportunity to explore this idea further. During the COVID pandemic, where the whole world closed down and we were all, you know, deadly scared of what this virus was, no one knew at the time. I remember this vaguely. Yeah, definitely.

And so one really surprising thing that happened was that the horror box office exploded. So people became really, really interested in watching horror movies all of a sudden. A British science journalist who had written about some of my work years ago, in which, you know, I told her that I thought horror might help us prepare for a dangerous world,

She tweeted me and asked me if I thought that horror movie fans were doing a better job of keeping their stress levels down during the pandemic. Matias and some of his colleagues wound up running a study to investigate this question, to see if people who watched a lot of scary movies exhibited fewer symptoms of psychological distress in those early scary days of lockdown.

Now, because it was the middle of the pandemic, they couldn't go out into the field for this. So we distributed questionnaires looking at people's symptoms of mental distress, getting a personality profile, and also getting a measure of how often they watch disaster movies, prepper movies, that sort of thing. And when they went through the results, they found that people who watched a lot of scary movies...

reported, at least, feeling less psychological distress. And people who watched a lot of prepper movies, they said that they felt better prepared. They had lived through similar scenarios in their imagination hundreds of times. So for them, you know, it wasn't just science fiction in an abstract sense. They felt like they'd sort of been there before. Anecdotally, these results fit in with their own experiences. Because Matthias, the horror fan...

He was not super phased by the pandemic. I was sort of cool with it, you know. Mark, by contrast. I was not cool with it at all. I remember, you know, the first days where I would like disinfect Amazon packages. Oh, yeah. Have them rest three days in our shed before I dare to touch them. Yeah.

Now, to be clear, their study results were all self-reported stuff, right? And also, as Matias told me... This is all correlational. We can't say, based on this study, that watching a scary movie makes you better at keeping your stress levels down during a pandemic. So maybe the kind of person who likes scary movies is just less likely to get stressed out in the first place.

But they're excited to continue exploring this question. Mark says they want to do a longitudinal study with randomized control groups to see if exposing people to some kind of recreational fear does actually bring their stress level down over time.

And they also want to see if this hypothesis could be applied to help kids who've gotten treatment for anxiety disorders. We would like to sort of enroll them, if they would like, in sort of a bravery module or whatever, inviting them to the roller coaster theme park, having them enroll in a climbing course, maybe seeing some scary movies. Not like seriously freak some anxious kids out, but let them have a little bit of fun with their fear.

Matthias and Mark want to know if that would actually help these kids learn how to deal with anxiety better. Like, could you do rollercoaster therapy, essentially? Could we fight fear with fear? So basically, right now, Matthias and Mark have a lot of cool, exciting questions about why we seek out fear for fun. And not that many perfect, complete answers. Like, they're still a long way from solving the paradox of horror.

One thing they do feel pretty confident about, though, is that these questions are worth exploring. Like, there is something both really fascinating and kind of important at the heart of our obsession with horror. I mean, it seems to be the case that stories and fiction are vital instruments for navigating the world for humans. You know, we rely on the imagination. The imagination might be our coolest asset.

We can use our uniquely evolved imaginations to run through scenarios, to imagine different states of affairs, and to prepare. If you want to read more about the research that Mark and Matthias and their various colleagues have done,

please look up the Recreational Fear Lab from Aarhus University in Denmark. They have got papers about Stephen King and the Exorcist and peekaboo in daycares. It's like great Halloween reading all around.

In the meantime, this episode was produced by me, Bird Pinkerton, and edited by Meredith Hodnot, who also runs the show. Noam Hassenfeld is our host and does the music. Christian Ayala did the mixing and sound design. Anouk Dussault did our fact-checking. Manding Nguyen is the fact that ostriches can run as fast as horses. Jorge Just is a gem of a human. And we are always excited.

Always, always grateful to Brian Resnick for co-founding this show. Thanks also to Jonquan Hill and Coleman Lowndes for their help with this episode.

If you have questions about this episode or thoughts or just like spooky vibes, I don't know, please send them to us. We are at unexplainable at Vox.com. You can also support this show and all of Vox's journalism by joining our membership program today or any other day. It would be very, very appreciated. That's at Vox.com slash members, Vox.com slash members to sign up.

You can also support the show by leaving us a nice rating or a review. So many options. Maybe do one of them. But no matter what, Unexplainable is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. And we will be back next week.

Support for the show comes from Alex Partners. Did you know that almost 90% of executives see potential for growth from digital disruption? With 37% seeing significant or extremely high positive impact on revenue growth. In Alex Partners 2024 Digital Disruption Report, you can learn the best path to turning that disruption into growth for your business.

With a focus on clarity, direction, and effective implementation, Alex Partners provides essential support when decisive leadership is crucial.

You can discover insights like these by reading Alex Partners' latest technology industry insights, available at www.alexpartners.com. That's www.alexpartners.com. In the face of disruption, businesses trust Alex Partners to get straight to the point and deliver results when it really matters.

Thank you.

It's time to cut through the noise and make a real impact. So tune into the future of marketing, a special series from the property podcast sponsored by Canva. You can find it on the property feed wherever you get your podcasts.