Trump's victory can be attributed to a disciplined campaign, normalization of his persona, perceived economic stewardship, and a broad-based appeal that extended beyond his initial narrow coalition. Additionally, the Democratic Party's strategy tied them to an unpopular administration, making the Republican message of change more appealing.
Trump's campaign in 2024 was more disciplined, and he had become normalized in the public eye. His perceived economic stewardship and non-politically correct demeanor attracted voters who might have been skeptical in 2016. The Democratic Party's failure to address economic concerns and their loyalty to an unpopular administration also bolstered Trump's appeal.
The Democratic Party tied themselves to an unpopular administration and failed to address the economic concerns of voters. Their refusal to acknowledge the unpopularity of Joe Biden and dismissing primary challenges reinforced a sense of disconnect with the electorate, making the Republican message of change more compelling.
Trump's second term victory suggests a potential shift towards authoritarian governance, with promises to expand presidential power, bring independent agencies under direct presidential control, and use the Department of Justice to prosecute enemies. This could fundamentally alter the balance of power and democratic norms in the U.S.
While abortion rights were a significant motivator for Democrats, the power of the issue may have been diminished by state referendums and Trump's distancing from the most extreme anti-abortion positions. Additionally, the Democratic Party's broader strategy failed to resonate with voters seeking change, making the Republican message more appealing.
Trump created distance from the most extreme anti-abortion wing of the Republican Party, which may have helped him appeal to voters who support abortion rights. This positioning allowed some voters to support both abortion rights and Trump, contrary to the Democratic narrative that he was an existential threat to abortion rights.
The lack of a Democratic primary prevented the party from taking the temperature of the country and selecting a candidate who better fit the moment. This failure to reset and address voter concerns through a primary process left the party with a candidate who was not the best fit for the election's dynamics, contributing to their loss.
A unified Republican government under Trump could lead to significant policy changes and a reshaping of the federal government in line with Trump's vision. This includes expanding presidential power, bringing independent agencies under direct presidential control, and using the Department of Justice to prosecute political enemies, potentially leading to a more authoritarian governance style.
In the early hours of Wednesday morning, Donald J. Trump was elected president for a second time.
Shortly before that call was made, the Times journalists Michael Barbaro, Nate Cohn, Lisa Lerer and Astead W. Herndon sat down to discuss the state of the election.
Guest:
Background reading:
For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily). Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.
Unlock full access to New York Times podcasts and explore everything from politics to pop culture. Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts) or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.