Deep Dive
Why did Matthew Plody keep his impending fatherhood a secret?
He wanted to maintain his private life and avoid changing his lifestyle, which involved juggling multiple women.
What evidence suggested that Melissa Lamish was murdered before the fire?
Autopsy results showed no soot in her airways and normal carbon monoxide levels, indicating she died before the fire. Strangulation marks were also found.
How did the Lamish family react to Matthew Plody's arrest?
They were relieved but still pained, as no punishment could bring Melissa and her unborn child back.
What was the motive presented by the prosecution for Melissa's murder?
Matthew Plody killed Melissa because he didn't want to be a father and wanted to keep his lifestyle and multiple relationships intact.
What was the significance of the 'deadline' phrase used by Matthew Plody during his interview?
It implied that he had a limited time to act before Melissa gave birth, suggesting premeditation.
How did the defense attempt to discredit the prosecution's case?
They called an independent inspector who disputed the arson findings and argued for an undetermined cause of the fire.
What was the outcome of Matthew Plody's trial?
He was found guilty of first-degree murder, the intentional homicide of an unborn child, and arson, and was sentenced to life imprisonment.
How did the Lamish family honor Melissa after her death?
They donated to shelters, sponsored a tree in her memory, and took actions to keep her spirit alive in their community.
- House fire on November 25, 2020
- Victim: Melissa Lamish, 27-year-old EMT, nine months pregnant
- Initial uncertainty about fire cause
- Matt Plody, firefighter paramedic, is a person of interest
Shownotes Transcript