cover of episode UK forces could be sent to Ukraine

UK forces could be sent to Ukraine

2024/12/19
logo of podcast World in 10

World in 10

People
J
James Nixey
L
Larissa Brown
Topics
John Healey: 英国国防大臣John Healey表示,英国军队可能被部署到乌克兰,但不是为了在前线作战,而是为了在乌克兰境内训练乌克兰军队。这将比在英国训练更有效率,因为乌克兰士兵无需长途跋涉到英国。虽然此举可能被俄罗斯视为升级,但一些英国军事指挥官认为,这将增强乌克兰的安全,并可能威慑俄罗斯。Healey还提出了一个五点计划,包括更多武器、资金支持以及在乌克兰境内进行军事训练。Healey对特朗普的和平计划持怀疑态度,认为乌克兰需要在任何和平谈判开始之前处于更强大的地位。 Larissa Brown: Larissa Brown报道了Healey的言论,并分析了在乌克兰境内训练乌克兰军队的优缺点。她指出,在乌克兰境内训练更有效率,但同时也存在风险,可能被俄罗斯视为升级行动。她还提到,一些乌克兰士兵因为即将到来的和平谈判而开始失去战斗意志。 James Hansen和Alex Dibble: 节目的主持人James Hansen和Alex Dibble对英国可能向乌克兰派遣军队进行军事训练的事件进行了讨论,并采访了Larissa Brown。他们强调了这一事件的重要性以及它可能对俄乌战争产生的影响。 James Nixey: James Nixey分析了普京年度记者招待会的内容,指出其是克里姆林宫的宣传工具,旨在恐吓西方或鼓舞俄罗斯民众。他认为普京对战争进展的描述并非完全真实,俄罗斯经济虽然有所增长,但通货膨胀和利率也都在上升。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why might the UK consider sending troops to Ukraine for training?

Training Ukrainian troops in Ukraine would be more logistically efficient, saving time and resources compared to bringing them to the UK. It also addresses concerns about the security and willingness of Ukrainians to return after training abroad.

How could the presence of British troops in Ukraine be perceived by Russia?

Russia is likely to view the deployment as an escalation, even if the troops are only there for training. The Kremlin may portray it as a combat role, potentially increasing tensions.

What is the UK Defence Secretary's five-point plan for Ukraine?

The plan includes more adaptable training, financial support, lethal weapons, air defense equipment, and additional sanctions on Russia to strengthen Ukraine's position.

Why is the Defence Secretary making these comments now?

The timing reflects concerns about the approaching winter, which will be challenging for Ukraine, and the potential impact of a Trump presidency on US support for Ukraine.

How might a potential Trump presidency affect Ukraine's war effort?

Ukrainians are reportedly losing morale due to fears of a peace deal under Trump, which could weaken their resolve on the battlefield.

What is the UK's stance on potential peace talks under Trump?

The UK government is skeptical of Trump's peace plan, believing Ukraine needs to be stronger before any talks and that Putin cannot be trusted.

Which European countries are supporting Ukraine alongside the UK?

Eastern European countries are stepping up support, but political turmoil in France and Germany has raised concerns, prompting the UK to take a leading role.

What was Vladimir Putin's message during his annual press conference?

Putin claimed victory in Ukraine is nearing, emphasizing daily territorial gains and economic growth, while downplaying challenges like inflation and high interest rates.

How is the war affecting Russian public sentiment?

The war is unpopular in Russia, with many reluctant to send their family members to fight. Putin's speeches aim to boost morale and intimidate the West.

Chapters
The UK Defence Secretary suggests sending British forces to Ukraine for training, sparking debate about the advantages and risks of on-the-ground training versus training in the UK. Concerns about potential escalation with Russia are raised, but some military chiefs see it as a way to deter Russian aggression.
  • UK Defence Secretary suggests sending British troops to Ukraine for training.
  • Training would occur within Ukraine, not on the front lines.
  • Potential for escalation with Russia is acknowledged.
  • Some military chiefs believe this would deter Putin from attacking British troops.

Shownotes Transcript

British troops could be sent to Ukraine for training, the UK Defence Secretary has told The Times. Our Defence Editor, Larisa Brown, who's been speaking to John Healey on his trip to Kyiv and Estonia, gives us her analysis.

The World in 10 is the Times' daily podcast dedicated to global security. Expert analysis of war, diplomatic relations and cyber security from The Times' foreign correspondents and military specialists. 

Watch more: www.youtube.com/@ListenToTimesRadio 

Read more: www.thetimes.com) Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy) for more information.