True Crime Vault: The Devil In Disguise
49:07 Share

This episode is brought to you by Amazon. The holidays are here, and you know what that means? It's time to get your friends and family the gifts they deserve. Take the stress out of shopping with Amazon's great deals and low prices on a huge range of items from toys to tech and much more. Whoever you're gifting for, Amazon has great prices on everything you need this holiday season. Shop early holiday deals now. This is Debra Roberts. Welcome to the 2020 True Crime Vault.

Each week, we reach back into our archives and bring you a story we found unforgettable. He broke her teeth. He broke her bones. Poisons that you could use that would be undetectable. Oh my goodness! What have you done? Take a listen. Coming up... See my hat? I love it. A wife and mother telling the story of her life online. I got a friend request from Chris on Facebook. One thing led to another.

We have two kids. And he's the best thing that has ever happened to me. Then her posts suddenly gone silent. We began tonight with breaking news. Shanann Watts and her two young daughters haven't been seen in the last two days. Her husband's plea for their return. Shanann, Bella, Celeste.

If you're out there, just come back. But in his mind was another woman already taking her place. Kessinger described it as very passionate that they were having sex three, four times a day. And were there warning signs in their marriage? I didn't believe it. I was like, there's no way this happened to them. Not that. Who? Why? A husband accused of murder. I think that you killed these girls. I love those girls.

And a heartbreaking discovery. The wife's parents speak out. Devil in Disguise.

I'm John Quinones. It was a story that gripped the nation. Shanann Watts and her two small daughters missing, her husband taking to television to plead for their return. But that return would never happen. Shanann and the girls were found murdered, and Chris Watts, it would be revealed, was not the loving husband he seemed to be. What was it that brought their storybook romance to such a tragic end?

In 2018, Amy Robach set out to unravel the story behind the headlines. Shanann's parents and friends talk about her marriage and her final days. And they raise the question, do you ever really know the one you love? Meet 34-year-old Shanann Watts.

We're here from the boat today. A social media maven and master of the digital stage. I am so excited. I'm thriving with you. I am confident. I am determined and I'm successful. She was fun, full of life. She did so many things. She had her hand in everything. She was amazing. Love you guys. Have a great day. Just about every waking moment of Shanann's life streams live over Facebook. We get to enjoy your life and live it.

and live again and have a blast. Shanann's views on life. I'm grateful. Can you see it? Beauty. Isn't it so fun to watch someone take off their makeup? Parenting. Careful. Shanann's parents, Sandra and Frank Rusek. She was very open on Facebook, and if you were from the outside looking in, she seemed to have the perfect life. She did. Did you believe that she was happy? Absolutely. Yes.

Chris and I are sitting here. Going home? Waiting to board our flight to Miami. We're going to Toronto in June. You guys have an amazing day. Bye. See my hat? I love it. Next to Shanann, that's her husband Chris, a field coordinator at a local oil company. I love the hat. Shanann loves sharing their love story, which started, not surprisingly, on Facebook. I got a friend request from Chris on Facebook. Oh.

One thing led to another, and he's the best thing that has ever happened to me. And because of my health challenges, because I got so sick, I let him in. Shanann suffers from the debilitating disease lupus. You just don't sleep very good with lupus. And she had her head on his lap, and they were watching TV, and he didn't move. He let her sleep for four hours. And I told her, God must have sent him to you.

What did you all think of him? Loved him. Less than two years later, Shanann and Chris are married. He was so in love with her. Oh, my God. He did everything he could for her to make her happy. The couple has two little girls, four-year-old Bella and three-year-old Celeste, also known as Cece. Say hi, Cece.

Careful, Bella. It's hot. You guys like my mug? Oh my gosh, this is so good. The fire, some cookies. And a lot of snow. Nicole Atkinson is Shanann's close friend. Tell me about Bella and Cece. Bella was a picky eater. I do remember that. She had to have her hamburger a certain way. I heard Cece was a spitfire. Oh, she was. She was a daredevil.

She would try anything and everything even if she was told no. She always ate her pizza upside down.

How was Chris as a father, as far as you could see? He was a very loving father. As far as I knew, he loved his family. Addie, who asked that we not use her last name, looks up to her friend Shanann. She was always the social butterfly. She was the person who was, you know, always taking pictures and always just on. She was always on. Addie also admired Shanann's parenting skills.

I just felt like she did everything the right way with so much patience. She was an amazing mom. She'd do anything for her children, and she wanted them to have everything growing up. There's nothing she wouldn't do for those children. And then in June 2018, another baby is on the way. I got a doctor appointment in...

Two hours. I know. Boy, boy. Chris wants a boy. I hope it's a boy for him. It'll make him happy. That's just a test. As luck would have it, it's a boy. She had a name for him already? Nico. She had to keep it Italian, you know? She was very proud to be part Italian. Christina Meacham and Shanann Watts have been close friends for 14 years. I look at Bella and I look at Shanann and I was like, you guys are exactly the same.

With Cece, it was just joy. Like, complete joy. The Watts home? Frederick, Colorado. A tight-knit Denver suburb with a family-friendly motto. Built on what matters. For Shanann and Chris, family matters most. It was amazing just to see how they were as parents and as a couple. We could organize the basement, so. They had a great marriage.

What happens in space? I don't know. Chris was a good dad. He would come home from work and take care of the girls. Mine is a hero. He helped them shower and get them ready for bed, anything that he needed to. Can you guys tell I'm like super like happy, excited? She was hard driven, hard worker. She would work 12, 14 hours a day.

In 2016, Shanann takes that strong work ethic to Lavelle, a multi-level marketing company that sells vitamin-infused patches. I'm very determined, and I am going to be extremely successful. She not only loved her job, she excelled at it, even winning an award from the company. Our team is just loaded with a lot of passion, a lot of heart, and I love that we're out there sharing the love with everybody. Shanann was reaping the rewards of her hard work,

Everything's paid for. And I got to spend it with my husband. That's the best part. Company-sponsored trips to San Diego and New Orleans. So excited, guys. It's about to start.

And then in August 2018, another company trip to Arizona. This time, Chris stays behind with the kids, but her friend and co-worker, Nicole Atkinson, was with her on the flight home. Being that she was pregnant on the flight home, she was very uncomfortable on the plane. And I believe it was around 1.45 in the morning that you dropped her off? Roughly, yeah. What was the last thing you said to her? I just told her, if you need help in the morning, let me know. And we gave each other a hug, and I watched her go into the house.

That morning, Shanann Watts goes offline. She didn't text me, which is really odd because she texts me every morning. The hunt for Shanann Watts. Oh my God, something happened. Next.

This is Andi Mitchell, host of Good Morning America's Pop Culture Moms podcast. You know what I miss during the holidays? That warm, buttery bread that just makes everything feel cozy. Like soft dinner rolls or a big dish of stuffing. But let's be honest, all that bread, it adds up.

That's where Hero Bread comes in. With Hero Bread, I don't have to think twice about indulging because it's packed with flavor but has 0 to 1 gram of net carbs, 0 sugar, and is high in fiber.

Their Hawaiian rolls are perfect for a holiday dinner, and honestly they're so fluffy I couldn't believe they were low carb. I've even made grilled cheese with their sliced bread and paired it with some pumpkin soup for that nice fall feel. And it's the same satisfying soft bread I love, just without the extra guilt. Hero bread isn't just for the holidays, though. It's a game changer for my everyday meals, too. From quick breakfast sandwiches to tortillas, for Taco Tuesday it's versatile and delicious.

Plus, with their monthly small batch drops, like the 2-gram net carb croissant, I know I've got some tasty surprises to look forward to all season long. So, if you're ready to enjoy bread without compromises, check out Hero Bread. Get 10% off your order at hero.co with the code 20. That's h-e-r-o dot c-o code 20. T-w-e-n-t-y. Your holiday table and your New Year's goals will thank you.

Hey there, I'm Andi Mitchell, host of Good Morning America's Pop Culture Moms podcast. You know, it's amazing how much this podcast has grown since last holiday season. We have expanded our content, interviewed outstanding guests, and even started thinking about merch, or at least I have. A year from now, I want to deliver even more to you. And if you've got a growing e-commerce business, you're probably feeling the same way, especially as the holidays approach.

This is why you need ShipStation. Whether you're just trying to get through the busy season or scaling beyond your old shipping solutions, ShipStation helps you achieve seamless efficiency. I've used ShipStation and the ability to manage orders, printing labels, and automating tasks from one simple dashboard has been a game changer. It has saved me and so many others so much time and their carrier discounts have saved thousands.

ShipStation integrates over 180 of the most popular platforms and carriers, helping you cut costs and ship smarter. Plus, with discounts up to 89% on USPS, UPS, and DHL, it's the most affordable way to get products to your customers. It's no surprise that 98% of businesses that use ShipStation for a year stick with it for life.

If you're ready to scale your business, switch to ShipStation today. Go to ShipStation.com and use code 20 to sign up for your free 60-day trial. That's ShipStation.com code 20. Nothing says summer in Frederick, Colorado quite like the town's annual hot air balloon festival.

But in August 2018, resident Nicole Atkinson has fear, not fun, on her mind. Her friend Shanann Watts is missing. What was your first feeling in your stomach and your gut that something was wrong? She didn't text me. I tried calling. She didn't answer, which is really odd because she texts me every morning. But on this morning, no communication from the pregnant Shanann. Nicole decides to try her in person.

She knows the code to the front door. What happened when you got to the house? I couldn't get in. They had the latch on the top like they do in hotel rooms, kind of. So it was locked from the inside. It was locked from the inside. And then I called Chris and asked if he knew where Shanann was. And he said she went on a play date. And I said, Chris, her car's in the garage. How could she have gone on a play date when both Bell and Cece are in car seats?

Nicole goes to Shanann's OBGYN where she knows she had an appointment, but Shanann is a no-show. Your friend, Shanann, who was so excited about having this third baby. She wouldn't have missed that doctor's appointment. And then you knew something was really wrong.

As Nicole impatiently waits for the cops, Shanann's husband, Chris Watts, who's at work, calls her friend Cassie Rosenberg to see what's going on. He called me and I was screaming at him. I was frantic.

Frederick Police Officer Scott Coonrod races to the Watts house. This is real-time footage captured on his body camera. After a quick check of the perimeter...

Chris Watts finally shows up. Scott, how you doing? How's it going? So this is the only vehicle she would have? Only one of those, yeah. She would drive? Okay. Officer Coonrod then asked to search the home. Mind if I look around? Go ahead. Go ahead. Thanks. The basement, bedrooms, bathroom. The only signs of life? You're fine. The barking dog.

Chris tells police he saw his wife early that morning before he left for work. The last time I talked to her was this morning. She said she was going to take the kids to a friend's house and that's where she was going to be. And then I've texted her today and never heard anything. The house appears neat and orderly, nothing out of place or rummaged through. We all ran through the house kind of looking for her. You checked up there? She's not there? It was odd, the things that you did see. It didn't make sense to me.

Shanann's purse and wallet on the counter, wedding ring on the nightstand, and unmade beds. So does she normally make the beds, the kids' beds? No. And their beds would have definitely been made? Yes. And her sheets wouldn't have been stripped off the bed? No, they wouldn't have. Or even if they had, it wouldn't have been in the manner that they were. There were sheets missing from a couple of the beds. There was a sheet missing from the bed in the master bedroom.

Eventually, they find her cell phone. And in the kitchen.

The biggest clue of all, medicines, including little Cece's EpiPen. My daughter never leaves the house without her phone or the EpiPens. Definitely an odd one.

Police get a break in the form of the Watts' next-door neighbor, Nate Trinastic. He has a security camera on the front of his house. It's right there above your head. What I did is said I have the video surveillance. The only thing I caught was Chris backing his truck into the garage. Chris comes over to your home along with the police to watch that surveillance footage. Yes, he was standing right in my living room basically watching it. Some of the tools that I have in the toolbox. And he looked very frantic. Hard.

He had his hands like this in the air on his shoulders, and he was really swaying back and forth. Was he saying anything? No, he wasn't saying anything. He basically, the only time I saw him show any emotion was a little bit of nervousness when he was watching that tape. My detective just showed up. You just want to go talk to him? I'm going to get his info real quick. No. No.

Seemingly desperate to find his family, Watts turns to the media for help. Going into the interview, you know, we were just going to ask the husband, you know, do you know where she could have went? Are you afraid? Are you afraid for their safety? It's one of those type of stories. Thomas Hoppo of ABC's Denver station, KMGH, is the first reporter to interview Watts. The kids are my life. I mean, those smiles light up my life. His demeanor was very serious.

calm, it was very relaxed. I really hope that all this can lead to something positive. Which was a little bit weird for me and my photographer. Everything seemed repetitive or rehearsed. Shanann, Bella, Celeste, if you're out there just come back. Like if somebody has her just please bring her back. I need to see everybody.

So this driveway obviously played a role, the surveillance camera over here, but this was the very porch where Chris Watts talked to the media. Pleading for his wife and children's safe return. There's two things to look at here, which is verbal and nonverbal behavior. Typically when we cross our arms, it means we're into a defensive mode and we want to hold in.

If they're not safe right now, that's what's tearing me apart. I miss this. I want that. So it's like the interview is all about him. And to go into their rooms and know that I wasn't going to turn their rain machines on, and know that I wasn't going to turn their monitor on. Did he sound worried? No, he didn't give a flying flip. I said, Chris, you know, I said, I don't think you should do any media. I said, you're the last one to have seen them.

I don't think you should. And yet he did. I thank God he did it. I thank God in heaven that he didn't listen to me. Who did you see on that front porch? Not him.

Definitely somebody else. It was frightening. When we come back, warning signs inside the marriage. Chris said he wasn't happy anymore. Private text messages, hidden photographs, and a strange visit to the police station by this woman. You can lie to me about this. What else are you lying about? Next. Next.

And Celeste are missing. Her husband, Chris, has turned to the media, pleading for their safe return. But as images of the seemingly grief-stricken spouse spread across the country, those closest to Shanann say those pictures may not tell the real story. Once again, here's Amy Robach.

We began tonight with breaking news. The disappearance of a pregnant Frederick woman and her two children has captured the nation's attention. Shanann Watts and her two young daughters haven't been seen in the last two days. They always just seem like a normal family. It was a media frenzy, and among those covering it, ABC News Denver correspondent Clayton Sandell.

Chris was actually on television doing interviews. He admitted that he and his wife had heated words before she disappeared. It wasn't like an argument. We had an emotional conversation, but I'll leave it at that. So what was happening behind closed doors in the weeks before the family went missing? On Facebook, Shanann was ecstatic about the summer.

I feel really blessed this summer. Six weeks we're going to be in North Carolina. That's easy, right? We're going to have a little, a lot of fun. She was very excited to be going to North Carolina, seeing her family. The children love the grandparents so much. You were with them for six weeks? Six weeks. We went to the beach. We played in puddles. You played in the rain. You got all wet. We went to the zoo. Goodness. We had a lot of fun and

Chris stays home in Colorado working, but even from across the country, Shanann senses a change in her husband. How did your daughter describe it? Did she say it happened suddenly? A few weeks, maybe a month, just cold as ice and not responding and

Text messages between Chris and Shanann show their marriage unraveling. While you are working and living the bachelor life, I'm carrying our third and fighting with our two kids daily. It's not hard texting love you and miss you. She was looking forward to him getting there. Did you ever at any point feel like anything was going on in their marriage? She just couldn't understand why he was so cold. Something had changed. Yes. Nothing that was really that I could physically see.

I'm not just staying because of the kids. They are my light, and that will not change. I'm not sure what's in my head.

"What did she told you?" "She just told me that Chris said he wasn't happy anymore and that she didn't know what was wrong." And once they are back home, the relationship appears to be going from bad to worse. Shanann texts her friend, "Chris told me last night he's scared to death about this third baby and he's happy with just Bella and Celeste and doesn't want another baby. He has changed. I don't know who he is."

With her crumbling marriage in mind, Shanann goes on that business trip to Arizona, leaving Chris with the girls and her bubbly self behind. She wasn't herself. She was trying really hard, but her mind and her heart were really with what was happening in her marriage. I sometimes can be bitchy, and he gets that side of me. I know I tend to make him feel like he isn't able to do things because I have control issues.

She was trying to figure out how she could fix it. She was very much analyzing everything she said or did. She was reading a book that weekend too. She wanted to make it work. She wanted to try and fix it. She did. A mutual friend of ours had recommended a book and she wanted to fix it so bad that she

An alert to a credit card charge from the Lazy Dog Sports Bar

that certainly looked fishy. A $62 salmon dinner that's literally not adding up. She realizes or believes that that's too much money for just one person and suspects that Chris is having dinner with somebody else. And her suspicions are right. That somebody is a young, pretty brunette named Nicole Kessinger. This is audio from an interview she would later give police. We got along really well. I thought...

What we had, it was very comfortable for me. I enjoyed it. I think he did very much as well. Kessinger is a co-worker in Chris's office, and he tells Nicole that he is separated and that they're working on getting a divorce. These are photos released by authorities of their time together. He didn't have a wedding ring on his finger. He didn't even mention his kids right away either. And then one day he told me that he had two kids. I thought it was kind of cute. I was like, oh, he's a dad.

Chris appears to be falling hard for Nicole, searching on Google when to say I love you for the first time in a new relationship.

So did he ever tell you that he loved you? Yes, he did. Did you ever tell him the same? A couple times. By all accounts and by all descriptions, it sounds like they were beginning a dating and intimate relationship. A blossoming romance with love letters and all. Have you read those love notes that Chris Watts was writing Nicole Kessinger? Something like, you turn me on, you make me melt, and then you cool me off like rain? Really? They had gone to a...

Mustang Car Museum. They had gone camping and hiking in the sand dunes. All these videos and photos, including nude pictures of Nicole, would end up in a secret app camouflaged as a calculator in Chris's phone. My daughter, she had no clue. She was clueless. Back in Arizona, a storm delays Shanann's flight home. At dinner, she confides in her closest friends.

She was definitely wanting her friends to be able to give her some advice, support. Her friends don't know it then, but the very next day, Shanann would vanish.

And when word of her disappearance hits the news... Tonight, police issued a missing endangered alert for Shannon Watts and her two daughters. Nicole Kessinger learns Chris's wife is not only missing, but she's 15 weeks pregnant and decides to go to the police. I just realized that he was lying to me, and I was like, well, if you can lie to me about this, what else are you lying to me about? That's exactly what police want to know. In another interrogation room, Chris Watts makes a rather unusual request...

asking for his father instead of an attorney. Can I talk about that or something? What he reveals with the cameras rolling, next. This is an ad for BetterHelp Online Therapy. What's something you've always wanted to learn? An instrument? A new language? How to not burn pasta? Whether it's big or small, imagine how great it would feel to finally do it. As kids, we were always learning and growing. But as adults, sometimes we lose that curiosity that made life feel so exciting.

It's easy to think that we are who we are and we can't change, but BetterHelp is here to tell you that it's never too late to be who you want to be. Therapy can help you reconnect with your sense of wonder because your back-to-school era can come at any age. BetterHelp makes it easy to get started with affordable phone, video, or live chat sessions you can do from anywhere and the option to message your therapist between sessions if anything comes up. Rediscover possibility with BetterHelp.

Visit BetterHelp.com today to get 10% off your first month. That's BetterHelp, H-E-L-P, dot com. Fever, cough, congestion. When the symptoms keep coming, but you've got to keep going, you can rely on Mucinex FastMax All-in-One. Just one dose of Mucinex FastMax All-in-One relieves up to nine cold and flu symptoms, helping you get on with your day.

Need cold and flu relief? Get Mucinex Fast Max All-in-One and Dunn Relief. It's comeback season. Use as directed. The vast open field surrounding Frederick, Colorado, had become ground zero in an all-out search for mother, Shanann Watts, and her daughters, Bella and Cece.

This became a massive law enforcement effort to find Shanann and the two girls. It was all hands on deck. The FBI, the Colorado Bureau of Investigation, had joined the Frederick Police Department. Monster lines from the Frederick Police Department. Have you seen this lady? This young lady and her kids are missing right now. Got a whole team of people working on this.

They were setting up roadblocks so that anybody coming in and out of the area who might have seen something or handed a flyer asked if they had heard or seen anything suspicious that might lead them to Shanann and the girls. How you doing? They're handing out flyers regarding the missing woman in the neighborhood. Have you heard about her? Okay. With Chris Watts' permission, authorities bring out canine units to track assent. But over in North Carolina, Shanann's parents smell a rat.

You immediately suspected Chris? When I told the police to find his GPS, because his GPS is going to tell them where my family is.

The GPS from Chris Watts' work truck showed he left his house at 5.46 a.m. and arrived at the Servi 319 oil well 47 minutes later, exactly what he had told police. Saying he has nothing to hide, Watts agrees to a polygraph exam.

Did you physically cause Shanann's disappearance? No. Are you lying about the last time you saw Shanann? No. Do you know where Shanann is now? No. In the end, the polygraph shows that he's being deceitful, that he's not telling the truth. So it is completely clear that you were not honest during the testing, and I think you already know that. You did not pass the polygraph test. Okay. Okay. I didn't lie to you on that polygraph, I promise. I need to talk about what actually happened.

Investigators press Watts. It appears to work, sort of.

He doesn't admit to a crime. Instead, Chris Watts confesses to an affair. But he refuses to name his mistress. I saw her, took my breath away, and...

I'd never thought in million years that could happen. I never felt that way about anybody, anybody in my lifetime. Struck me as very odd because investigators even said, "Well, can we stop talking about the other woman and get back to trying to figure out where your wife and two daughters are?" Can you leave her out of it? Okay. Get back to your wife and your daughters. Okay. Where are they? They were at the house when I left. They were there. They weren't there. They didn't leave. They vanished.

The only way they could have left is in your truck. The agents seem to be getting nowhere, so they switch strategies. Could she have been in an accident?

something happened in the house that you know about. The key here is to find some lever in Chris that will get him to tell the truth. Whether it's saving face, whether it's to minimize what he in reality he has done,

but also to maybe blame other people. But I want to know, did something happen to these baby girls first that you had to take into your own hands and deal with? You had to clean it up for us, yeah. Chris, you've got to tell us. There's something that happened to these baby girls.

Eventually, Watts asked to speak with his father, Ronnie Watts, who has just flown in from North Carolina. Police oblige. An unusual move, allowing a third party into the interrogation room. She choked on death. I freaked out when you said that. She killed Lucy Seaman. Choked on death. I loved it when she choked on death. Choked on her? No, just rage. I don't know.

It's a stunning statement. Chris Watts claims in the middle of the night, Shanann had attacked the kids and he killed her in a fit of rage. CBI agents re-enter the room. I saw on the monitor, those covers were like pulled off and she was laying there. It's like a little bit of a scene. She was in there with her. I was off-guard. I was like...

He speaks quietly. He's not very animated. He's just kind of laying it out matter-of-factly. Was it a choke like this or was it like a headlock? And your wife, you saw her with one hand or two hands? I kind of moved back. I couldn't really like tell.

never attempted resuscitation, never checked on him, never called 911, never asked for assistance. According to him, he knew that they were already dead by their appearance. I think that you killed these girls.

He blames her for the murders.

of her two little girls, that would never happen. He lied to take the blame off himself. With everything that we knew about Shanann, we knew that she had just gotten home from this work trip, that the first thing that she would have done when she got home, according to her family and friends, was run upstairs, check on the girls, tuck them in, kiss them goodnight, and then go to bed herself. And then all of a sudden, for some inexplicable reason, for her to get up in the middle of the night and...

According to the defendant, strangle them to death made zero sense. Authorities arrest Chris Watts for the murder of his pregnant wife, Shanann Watts, and his two daughters, four-year-old Bella and three-year-old Cece. How do you reconcile the Chris you loved with the one who's being arrested? The devil comes to you in any shape, size, and form and can be transformed into anything. Did he snap? He must have snapped because there's nothing else I could figure out what happened to him.

Next, police have a suspect in custody, but they need to know what he did with the bodies. When 2020 returns. Time to move? Skip the hassles of selling during the holiday season and sell your home directly to Opendoor. Request an all-cash offer in minutes, close, and get paid in days. You can even pick your close date so you can move after New Year's. Start your move at opendoor.com or download the Opendoor app.

Open Door is represented by Open Door Brokerage, Inc., License 02061130 in California, and Open Door Brokerage, LLC, and its other markets. Terms and conditions apply.

This episode is brought to you by LifeLock. So much of your personal info is out of your control, like your insurance provider that has your social security number and your favorite retailer that has your payment details. If they get breached, your information, your identity, is vulnerable. That's why LifeLock monitors millions of data points a second for threats. If your identity is stolen, they'll fix it, guaranteed to your money back. Save up to 40% your first year at LifeLock.com slash podcast. Terms apply.

In a dramatic turn of events, Chris Watts is in jail. When you learned that Chris was 100% involved, how did you react? To be honest with you, I kind of went numb. I sat in my bed and watched the news. And I couldn't move. And I couldn't breathe.

Once Chris Watts admits that his wife and his daughters are dead, the question now is, where are they? Back inside that interrogation room, Chris reveals the heartbreaking details of how he disposed of his family's bodies. He's asked to point in a photo the exact location. Whereabouts?

Watts marks the spots with their initials. The two girls in separate oil tanks, their pregnant mother, Shanann, in a shallow grave nearby. The missing bed sheet also found on the scene. Where he pointed to where? Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

This had to be one of the most grim scenes any investigator could come across. At some point, Chris has to take

Chris's mistress breaks down, thinking about what he did to his daughters. He's so disgusting. I'm so ashamed of him and everything. And I just, all those little girls. They're so little. They're so little.

The little girls' autopsies are key to District Attorney Michael Rourke's case. They weren't strangled. Those girls were smothered. His...

The statement that he had seen Shanann strangle those girls all of a sudden became an enormous lie. This kid keeps me going. I knew in my heart of hearts the friend that I cared so much for would never hurt her babies. They knew from day one that that was not true. And Bella has her baby. Bella, the four-year-old, had tried to struggle back against her father as he smothered her. To find out that my granddaughter...

struggled to live, that probably threw us over the edge. People I know came from all across this country to where your daughter and Chris lived, to pay respects, to light candles, to leave stuffed animals. That had an impact on you. Oh yeah. Yeah, it did. Let them know that there will be a day that they will hold those babies again.

that they will see Shanann's beautiful smile. As this small community in mourning comes to grips with the depths of its loss. It's too close to home. It's heartbreaking. Shanann Watt's family celebrates the lives of their loved ones in a funeral that not surprisingly streams live over the internet.

It gave everybody a chance kind of virtually to be there, pay their respects, mourn together. We did scream at God. Yes, we did. Why? That's the big word. Why? Why?

There appeared to be some serious financial trouble in the Watts' home. They were months behind on their mortgage. They had thousands of dollars in debt. The motive that we know of is wholly unsatisfactory. The result in this case, because of some newfound love coupled with the occasional financial issues that arise in many households, just didn't make any sense. Mommy has a baby in her belly. A baby!

When you look at pregnant women that are killed, right behind automobile accidents is homicide. The reason people like Chris don't get a divorce is that they want to get out from under the financial hardship of soon-to-be three kids and a wife. What's interesting about him is he comes across as a rather passive person.

introverted person but you really have to be this narcissistic anti-social person that's full of anger and rage to commit this type of crime. You know what makes this case so scary? That he seemed like a good guy. A really good guy. I have listened over and over to audio of his little girl singing "Daddy's My Hero" and he was. He was the mom's hero.

She loved him so much. There was not a clue. That's why it's so scary. You think you have a good one and you have Chris Watts. Next year to the developing headline out of Colorado tonight and to a father and husband offering a plea deal to save his own life.

In November 2018, Chris Watts agrees to plead guilty to killing his pregnant wife and young daughters in exchange for no death penalty. First-degree murder, disposing of a body, and the unlawful termination of a pregnancy. He took responsibility for all of it. Just three months after murdering his pregnant wife and two young daughters, it is judgment day for Chris Watts. Watts must listen to victims' impact statements.

You carry them out like trash. You buried my daughter Shannon in a shallow grave, and then you put Bella and Celeste in huge containers of crude oil. This is hard to say, but may God have mercy on your soul. Shanann's mother, Sandra. We loved you like a son. We trusted you. I didn't want death for you because that's not my right. Your life is between you and God now, and I pray that he has mercy for you. Watt's mother, Cindy, speaks directly to her son.

It is when Cindy turns to look into her son's empty eyes that he finally breaks down.

But we will remain faithful as your family, just as God remains faithful because of his unconditional love for us all. We love you and we forgive you, son. But for many in this packed courtroom, there is very little room for forgiveness. You know, I have sat in court many, many times. I would look over at the defendant and wonder why. But here, getting rid of them was expeditious.

There goes debt, there goes problems, there goes the issue of a divorce. It was just simply the easiest thing to do in his mind. Through his attorney, Watts issues a short apology. Mr. Watts has asked us to share this morning that he is devastated by all of this. And although he understands that words are hollow at this point, he is sincerely sorry for all of this.

Chris Watts is sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. I love the smile on her face in that one. Oh, I love that picture. Isn't that beautiful? It really is. How do you want your daughter to be remembered? How do you want the world to remember her and your granddaughters? She was an amazing daughter. Bella wanted lipstick on like mommy today. Show her your lips. And CC too. No kisses.

She wanted to soar the earth and she always said, Mom, I want to leave my mark on the earth. And she did. Sandra's unshakable faith gives her the strength to keep alive the happy memories of Shanann and her beloved granddaughters. Oh, my goodness. Oh, I love you. This is Deborah Roberts. Join us next time for another edition of the 2020 True Crime Vault.

Tune in Friday nights at 9 o'clock for all new broadcast episodes of 2020 on ABC. Thanks for listening.

This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. It's Brad Milkey, host of ABC's daily news podcast, Start Here. You chose to hit play on this podcast today. Smart choice. Make another smart choice with AutoQuote Explorer to compare rates from multiple car insurance companies all at once. Try it at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates not available in all states or situations. Prices vary based on how you buy.