Home 
Key Insights
Why did Karen Swift's car have a flat tire?
A screw was intentionally inserted into the tire.
Why did Karen Swift want a divorce?
She felt David was too controlling.
Why was John Hogshooter initially suspected?
He had poisoned neighborhood dogs, including the Swifts'.
Why did investigators focus on David Swift?
All evidence pointed to him, including his controlling behavior and the divorce filing.
Why was David Swift's bond revoked?
He was charged with felony stalking of his second wife.
Why did the jury find David Swift not guilty of murder?
They felt there was not enough evidence to convict.
Why did the prosecution believe David Swift killed Karen?
They theorized he stomped her head in the garage.
Why did the defense argue David couldn't have killed Karen?
They claimed his knee injury limited his mobility.
Why did the jury struggle to reach a verdict?
They were divided, with some believing in David's guilt and others not.
Why did the prosecution want to retry David for manslaughter?
They felt they had an obligation to pursue justice.
Chapters
The episode begins with the mysterious disappearance of Karen Swift after a Halloween party, setting the stage for a complex investigation.
- Karen Swift goes missing after a Halloween party.
- Her car is found with a flat tire, raising suspicions.
- Initial theories and community reactions are discussed.
Shownotes Transcript