cover of episode Elon Musk’s DOGE Is Getting Audited

Elon Musk’s DOGE Is Getting Audited

2025/4/9
logo of podcast Elon Musk Podcast

Elon Musk Podcast

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
播音员
主持著名true crime播客《Crime Junkie》的播音员和创始人。
Topics
@播音员 :我关注到一个令人担忧的情况:缺乏联邦经验且与埃隆·马斯克有关联的人员被授予了美国财政部支付系统的访问权限。这引发了人们对数据安全和隐私的担忧,特别是考虑到这些人员与政府机构的联系以及他们所获得的访问权限级别。 政府问责办公室(GAO)目前正在进行一项全面的审计,以调查政府效率部门(DOGE)的数据行为是否合法或危险。审计范围涵盖多个联邦部门,包括劳工部、教育部、卫生与公众服务部、国土安全部、财政部和社会保障管理局。 DOGE的前身是美国DOGE服务(USDS),其创建的初衷是精简官僚机构并使过时的联邦系统现代化。然而,其执行方式引发了广泛的担忧。许多DOGE成员并非公务员,也未接受联邦网络安全协议培训,而是马斯克私人企业(如X或特斯拉)的前雇员,他们拥有前所未有的访问权限。 GAO的审计源于国会对DOGE行为可能违法或违宪的担忧。审计内容包括系统访问、内部安全措施以及任何涉及滥用敏感系统或数据的事件。GAO要求各部门提交与系统访问、内部安全措施以及任何涉及滥用敏感系统或数据的事件相关的文件,这表明这是一项深入的调查,而非简单的表面调查。 审计的重点是DOGE人员在处理税务记录和社会保障金支付等系统中的存在,以及他们试图合并本应保持独立的数据孤岛的行为。DOGE员工缺乏明确的监管结构,并请求访问权限以修改核心系统代码,这可能干扰政府职能或使关键基础设施面临外部影响。 劳工部内部会议记录显示,DOGE员工目前只有读取敏感数据的权限,但他们已经申请更广泛的权限。劳工部创建了一个缓冲区,让DOGE员工描述他们的目标,以便常规机构员工代表他们执行必要的行动,而不是直接让他们操作系统和代码。 GAO要求各机构不仅要提供安全协议,还要提供发放给DOGE关联人员的笔记本电脑的具体设置,以及关于系统访问、访问级别、访问权限授予方式以及访问权限是否被修改的文档。GAO还想知道DOGE人员是远程工作还是现场工作,他们是否使用政府发放的硬件或个人设备,以及有哪些保障措施来确保机密性和法律合规性。 此次事件质疑了政府权力是如何被管理以及由谁管理的。如果未经审查或适当监督的个人被授予访问和操作这些数据库的权限,将会损害人们对这些系统的信任,并增加错误或滥用的风险。DOGE的创建并非通过传统的立法渠道,而是通过特朗普总统的行政命令,这使得其运作缺乏透明度。 马可·阿莱兹(Marco Alez)拥有财政部系统的完全访问权限,这引发了对政府支付系统可能被破坏的担忧。阿莱兹的权限并未得到财政部的确认,但他与劳工部和社会保障管理局有关联,并且由于正在进行的诉讼,他被法院命令限制了对社会保障管理局系统的访问。 特朗普于3月20日发布的行政命令指示联邦机构开始整合其数据存储库,这可能会创建一个不受监管的个人信息巨型数据库。DOGE员工开始连接以前出于隐私原因而被隔离的系统,这可能会使美国人的私人数据面临不必要的风险。 弗吉尼亚州众议员鲍比·斯科特(Bobby Scott)和马萨诸塞州众议员理查德·尼尔(Richard Neal)的来信促使了GAO的审计。GAO预计将在未来几周内直接会见机构人员,并实时观察DOGE的活动,包括检查笔记本电脑配置、审查用户活动日志以及确认是否到位适当的数据丢失预防工具。如果发现违规行为,可能会导致法律行动、更严格的法规,甚至彻底拆除DOGE的部分部门。审计预计将于春季末结束,调查结果将公开发布。

Deep Dive

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

The NBA playoffs are here, and I'm getting my bets in on FanDuel. Talk to me, Chuck GPT. What do you know? All sorts of interesting stuff. Even Charles Barkley's greatest fear. Hey, nobody needs to know that. New customers bet $5 and get $250 in bonus bets if you win. FanDuel, America's number one sportsbook.

21 plus and present in Virginia. Must be first online real money wager. $5 deposit required. Bonus issued is non-withdrawable bonus bets that expire seven days after receipt. Restrictions apply. See full terms at fanduel.com slash sportsbook. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. At Sierra, discover top workout gear at incredible prices, which might lead to another discovery. Your headphones haven't been connected this whole time. Awkward. Discover top brands at unexpectedly low prices. Sierra, let's get moving.

The spirit of innovation is deeply ingrained in America, and Google is helping Americans innovate in ways both big and small. The Department of Defense is working with Google to help secure America's digital defense systems, from establishing cloud-based zero-trust solutions to deploying the latest AI technology. This is a new era of American innovation. Find out more at g.co slash American innovation.

Why would someone with no federal experience and ties to Elon Musk be granted access to the Treasury's payment systems? And why are agencies like the Department of Labor and Social Security Administration quietly preparing detailed logs and security records for government auditors?

And why more than a year after Donald Trump created the Department of Government Efficiency are so many insiders sounding alarms about who is inside the nation's most secure data systems and what they're doing with access? Now,

The Department of Government Efficiency, DOGE, was created under Trump's administration with the stated mission of streamlining bureaucracy and modernizing outdated federal systems. And while that objective on its face sounds like a technical improvement project, the execution has triggered a wave of concern.

Federal employees are now grappling with the realization that many of the people embedded inside their agencies under the Doge banner are neither civil servants nor trained in the protocols of federal cybersecurity. Instead, they're often former employees of Elon Musk's private ventures, such as X or Tesla, who have taken on public roles with unprecedented access.

Now, the audit now underway by the Government Accountability Office seeks to determine whether DOGE operatives have violated laws governing data protection and privacy across a sprawling list of federal departments. Among those under review are the Departments of Labor, Education, Health and Human Services, Homeland Security, the Treasury, and the Social Security Administration.

Now, DOGE itself, formerly known as the U.S. DOGE Service, USDS, is also being examined. GAO is requesting comprehensive logs, security protocols, and risk assessments from these agencies, many of which show signs of scrambling to comply.

The GAO's mission is not administrative in nature. Its role is to independently investigate government performance on behalf of Congress. Now, this audit was initiated following congressional concern that DOJA's actions might not just be unorthodox. They could be completely illegal or unconstitutional.

The watchdog agency has also asked departments to turn over documents related to system access, internal security measures, and any incidents involving misuse of insensitive systems or data.

These requests are precise and technical, indicating that the GAOs review not just a surface-level inquiry, but a forensic investigation against Doge. At the heart of the concern is the presence of Doge personnel inside systems that handle everything from tax records to social security payments. And in some cases, these operatives have reported, attempted to merge systems of data silos that were intentionally designed to remain separate.

Agency insiders have stated that DOGE staff often have no clear supervisory structure and have requested access that would enable them to modify core system code, which is an action that could interfere with government functions or expose critical infrastructure to outside influence. Not secure. And one of the clearest examples of this tension emerged from the Department of Labor, a

In confidential notes from an internal meeting held on March 18th, agency staff detailed the extent of Doge integration into their system. Doge workers currently hold only read access to sensitive data, they said, including payroll and grants. However, they had already asked for broader privileges.

The Department of Labor staff responded by creating a buffer, asking DOGE operatives to describe their goals so that regular agency employees could execute any necessary actions on their behalf rather than letting them directly manipulate the systems and the code themselves. But the level of scrutiny being applied by the GAO is very unusual.

Agencies like the Department of Labor have been asked to present not just security protocols, but even the specific settings on laptops issued to Doge affiliates.

Logs tracking cybersecurity incidents, audit trails, and data loss prevention efforts have all been requested. And furthermore, agencies must provide documentation outlining who has system access, what level of access they had, whether it's read, write, or execute, how access is granted, and whether it was later modified.

GAO wants to know whether DOGE personnel are working remotely or on-site, whether they are using government-issued hardware or personal devices, and what safeguards are in place to ensure confidentiality and also legal compliance. Now, this story matters to you because it calls into question how government power is being administration and by whom.

The federal government holds massive troves of personal data on you right now, from health records to financial filings. Everything you do in its systems are designed to shield that information from tampering or unauthorized exposure.

Now, if private individuals without vetting or proper oversight are granted access to manipulate these databases, it erodes trust in the systems themselves. And it also roads trust in institutions that are meant to guard them. People rely on these systems every single day, social security, whether it's to receive tax refunds, the IRS, and also healthcare subsidies. Now, moreover, the audit raises deeper concerns about accountability.

Doge was established not through traditional legislative channels, but via an executive order by President Donald Trump. This has allowed it to operate with minimal transparency. Even now, months into this audit, some Doge operatives reportedly do not know who is technically in charge of their work. Without clear leadership or oversight, the risk of error or abuse escalates, especially when the people involved may not fully understand the systems they're accessing.

Lowe's is the destination for Ego outdoor power equipment this spring. See what's new and exclusive, like the 17-inch string trimmer with Line IQ technology that auto-feeds to save you time, and the 22-inch select-cut self-propelled mowers with a multi-blade system for precise cutting. Shop Ego Days, happening now during Spring Fest at Lowe's. We help, you save. Selection varies by location while supplies last.

This episode is brought to you by Shopify. Forget the frustration of picking commerce platforms when you switch your business to Shopify, the global commerce platform that supercharges your selling wherever you sell. With Shopify, you'll harness the same intuitive features, trusted apps, and powerful analytics used by the world's leading brands. Sign up today for your $1 per month trial period at shopify.com slash tech, all lowercase. That's shopify.com slash tech.

Now, one name repeatedly associated with high-level access is Marco Alez, a 25-year-old former engineer at X, Elon Musk's social media company. And according to reports and internal records, Alez was given right access to treasury systems, which means he had full power to alter any code in the treasury. Now, this access created the possibility of disrupting government payments, including those authorized by Congress.

Treasury staff compared the situation to having unauthorized users in the system with the capability to bring core functions to a halt and being powerless to intervene against this one person.

Now, Les's access was reportedly not confirmed to the Treasury, though. He has also been linked to both the Department of Labor and Social Security Administration. However, due to ongoing litigation, his access to Social Security Administration systems has been restricted by a court order. And while Les has not commented publicly, internal records confirm his presence across multiple agencies and hit at a wider network of Doge affiliates working in parallel roles.

Now, of particular concern is the executive order issued by Trump on March 20th, which directs federal agencies to begin consolidating their data repositories under the pretext of fighting waste and fraud. Now, while this may sound efficient, critics warn that it could create an unregulated mega database of personal information.

accessible to individuals with no clear accountability. Doge operatives under this directive have started the process of linking systems that were previously siloed for privacy reasons. This change could expose Americans' private data to unnecessary risks. And congressional concern has been growing since at least February. In a letter dated February 6th, Virginia Representative Bobby Scott described the situation as a constitutional emergency.

and formally requested the GAO open an investigation. Soon after, Massachusetts Representative Richard Neal sent his own letter, specifically naming the Treasury and Social Security Administration as areas of concern. These formal inquiries helped trigger the audit that is now expanding in scope.

So in the weeks ahead, the GAO is expected to meet directly with agency personnel and observe Doge activities in real time. This is a scoop. The Doge employees didn't know about this, and this includes inspecting laptop configurations, reviewing user activity logs, and confirming whether proper data loss prevention tools are in place.

These steps will help determine whether Doge access is being monitored and controlled in line with legal requirements. Now, this story will continue to develop as more documents are reviewed and more officials are questioned. But for now, the GAO audit marks the first major attempt to bring transparency to Doge's operations. If violations are uncovered...

they could result in illegal action, tighter regulations, or even dismantling parts of DOGE altogether. The audit is expected to conclude in late spring with findings to be made completely public. And until then, agency staff, elected officials, and the public remain in a state of unease, waiting to learn just how deeply DOGE has dug into the federal data system and what consequences may follow.

I was never really a runner. The way I see running is a gift, especially when you have stage four cancer. I'm Anne. I'm running the Boston Marathon presented by Bank of America. I run for Dana-Farber Cancer Institute to give people like me a chance to thrive in life, even with cancer.

Join Bank of America in helping Anne's cause. Give if you can at bfa.com slash support Anne. What would you like the power to do? References to charitable organizations is not an endorsement by Bank of America Corporation. Copyright 2025. I want to say thank you so much for listening to the show today. I'm going to make you a deal right now. I want one thing from you and you're going to get 10 years from me. The one thing I want from you is for you to subscribe or follow on whatever podcast platform you're on right now. Takes a second completely free.

And I'm going to give you 10 years of content. I've been doing this for five years already. So 10 years more, I promise you, I will not put this show behind a paywall. So one thing from you, one tiny thing, and you're going to get 10 years of my life. So thank you so much for that. I appreciate you. Please take care of yourselves and each other. And I'll see you in the next one.