cover of episode Why have Spurs appealed Bentancur's ban?

Why have Spurs appealed Bentancur's ban?

2024/11/21
logo of podcast The View From The Lane: The Athletic FC's Tottenham show

The View From The Lane: The Athletic FC's Tottenham show

People
D
Danny Kelly
J
James Maw
J
Jay Harris
Topics
Danny Kelly: 热刺队就本坦库尔的禁赛提出上诉,这看起来很糟糕,即使上诉成功也只是将禁赛场次从七场减少到六场。这会造成负面影响,得不偿失。 Jay Harris: 本坦库尔在采访中公开发表评论,而其他球员的类似评论是在社交媒体上发表的,这是热刺上诉失败的关键区别。此外,热刺认为处罚过重。热刺队目前中场球员储备充足,上诉行为显得没有必要。上诉行为拖延了事件的解决,并再次引发公众讨论,这损害了球队的声誉。 James Maw: 热刺球迷对其他球员的类似事件的处罚往往持批评态度,而热刺对本坦库尔的处罚上诉显得双重标准。热刺队并不否认本坦库尔犯规,只是对禁赛时长提出异议。对禁赛时长的上诉行为,传递出球队对种族歧视问题的重视程度不足的信号。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why have Spurs decided to appeal Bentancur's ban?

Spurs believe the seven-game ban for Bentancur is too severe compared to previous cases, particularly as other players like Edinson Cavani and Bernardo Silva received lesser bans for similar offenses. They hope to reduce the ban by one game, potentially making him available for the Liverpool match.

What is the range of bans for similar offenses?

The range for such offenses is typically six to 12 games, with Bentancur receiving a seven-game ban. Other players, like Cavani and Silva, received lesser bans for similar offenses on social media.

What are the potential consequences of Spurs appealing Bentancur's ban?

The appeal could lead to reputational damage, as the best-case scenario is only reducing the ban by one game. Additionally, the appeal prolongs the situation, drawing more attention to the incident and potentially undermining the seriousness of the offense.

Who could replace Bentancur in midfield during his suspension?

Yves Bissouma is likely to rotate in the holding midfield role, and there is also the option of using £40m signing Archie Gray, who is considered an exceptional talent but has yet to feature in his preferred central midfield position.

Why might Spurs fans be divided on the appeal?

Fans have varying opinions, with some believing the ban should have been longer and others questioning its severity. The club's stance of not denying the offense but only quibbling the length of the ban has further polarized opinions.

What is the significance of the upcoming fixtures for Spurs?

Spurs face a challenging run of 11 games up to Christmas, including matches against top teams like Manchester City, Chelsea, and Liverpool. The team will need to balance their performances in both the league and cup competitions.

How many consecutive wins would it take for Spurs fans to regain belief in the team?

Fans, like Philip Kavanagh, suggest that three consecutive wins could restore belief in the team's direction under Ange Postecoglou, especially after a series of disappointing results before the international break.

What is the current status of key players like Bentancur, Odegaard, and Richarlison?

Bentancur is suspended for most of the upcoming fixtures, Odegaard is long-term injured, and Richarlison is also out. These absences will significantly impact Spurs' lineup and tactics during the busy period.

Why hasn't Archie Gray been given more minutes in central midfield?

Gray faces stiff competition for places in central midfield, with players like Bissouma, Bentancur, and Kulusevski already established. Additionally, Gray has more experience playing at right-back, which has limited his opportunities in his preferred position.

What is the potential impact of Dejan Kulusevski's recent form on his role at Spurs?

Kulusevski's strong performances for Sweden, including being named man of the match, have sparked discussions about his potential as a future captain for Spurs. His leadership qualities and recent form suggest he could play a key role in the team's future.

Chapters
Tottenham Hotspur's decision to appeal Rodrigo Bentancur's seven-game ban for a comment made in June is analyzed. The appeal is considered a poor decision, potentially damaging the club's reputation, and may only reduce the ban by one game. The discussion includes comparisons to similar bans and the impact of the appeal on public perception.
  • Tottenham appealed Bentancur's seven-game ban, aiming to reduce it to six games.
  • The appeal is seen as a bad look for the club, potentially causing reputational damage.
  • The minimum ban for this offense is six games, with a maximum of twelve.

Shownotes Transcript

Host Danny Kelly is joined by James Maw and Jay Harris to discuss Spurs's decision to appeal Bentancur's ban, the now infamous rebrand & our next run of 11 fixtures up until the end of the year!

We also preview Man City away!

PRESENTER: Danny Kelly

WITH: James Maw, Jay Harris

PRODUCER: Tom Fuller

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices)