A Spurs fan should feel a mix of delight at the team's free-flowing, goal-scoring performance and despair at the chaotic defensive lapses, creating an emotional tightrope between joy and frustration.
Forster made two significant errors that directly led to goals, despite also making a remarkable, almost comical, kick save that highlighted his nerves and lack of comfort in playing out from the back.
With only Pedro Porro as a regular defender, Spurs' lack of experience and cohesion in the backline was evident, leading to chaotic moments and goals that could have been avoided with a more stable defense.
The momentum shifted when Spurs conceded two quick goals after being 3-0 up, changing the atmosphere and energy of the game, making it feel like anything could happen.
Spence was impressive, fitting well into the system and providing a much-needed boost to the fullback position, which has been overplayed and under-rested this season.
Solanke's goals were crucial, especially after a game against Southampton where the team scored multiple goals without the center-forward contributing. His performance was a positive sign for Spurs' attack.
The commentators were so accustomed to the goal-review process in the Premier League that they found it odd to accept a goal without VAR, creating a momentary confusion about the rules.
The draw against Liverpool means Spurs will face a tough sequence of games, including a semi-final with Liverpool and potentially two North London derbies, which could be emotionally and physically demanding.
The intense and emotional win against Manchester United will likely leave Spurs fatigued, especially with limited rotation options, making it a significant challenge to face a fresh and strong Liverpool side.
Postecoglou suggested that some criticism is offensive and influenced by preconceptions about his background, including his Australian heritage and experience in leagues not considered top-tier.
Host Danny Kelly is joined by The Athletic's James Maw and Charlie Eccleshare to discuss the bonkers events that unfolded last night during Spurs' 4-3 win against Manchester Utd.
They discuss the goals, Forster's performance, Solanke, Spence and much more! Whilst also previewing Liverpool on Sunday and looking ahead to the semi final against them in January.
HOST: Danny Kelly
WITH: James Maw, Charlie Eccleshare
PRODUCER: Tom Fuller
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices)