cover of episode China fights back

China fights back

2025/4/8
logo of podcast World Business Report

World Business Report

Transcript

Shownotes Transcript

This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

This is Shirley Strawberry from the Steve Harvey Morning Show. Toyota has been building a legacy of excellence for years, from developing hybrid technology to upping the standards of safety and efficiency. Toyota is always innovating, always making progress. And with a superior lineup of in-stock SUVs, including the adventure-ready RAV4 and capable, affordable Corolla Cross, you can experience the legacy of Toyota for yourself. Visit

buyatoyota.com, the official website for deals to find out more. Toyota, let's go places. If you're just starting your personal finance journey, Financially Inclined is exactly what you need. I'm Janely Espinal, host of Financially Inclined, and each week we discuss money lessons you need to know. Listen to Financially Inclined wherever you get your podcasts.

Hello and welcome to World Business Report from the BBC World Service. Namaste. I'm Divina Gupta and I'm joining you from Delhi. On this edition, two economies and a trade war. As the US and China clash over tariffs on goods, we find out how it's impacting their economies and global businesses.

And what if your country ran out of workers? With birth rates hitting record lows, South Korea is scrambling to find people to work in their industries. The Korean economy will not survive even a day if there's no immigrant workers. The real question is whether we should have even more immigrant workers or less.

More on that in just a bit, but let's dig in. It's a high-stakes standoff between the world's two biggest economies. And it's getting personal. Here's the story so far. Just months into his presidency, US President Donald Trump hit the ground running with more tariffs on Chinese imports. Last week, China hit back with tit-for-tat levies on US goods. But President Trump didn't like that.

With China, as you know, against my statement, they put a 34 percent tariff on above what their ridiculous tariffs were already. And I said, if that tariff isn't removed by tomorrow at 12 o'clock, we're putting a 50 percent tariff on above the tariffs that we put on.

Well, that's got to hurt because Mr. Trump says he may impose an additional tariff on China, which could mean some Chinese companies will have to pay up to 104% of the product cost in tax to enter the U.S. market.

China says it will fight to the end. Here's Lin Jian, spokesperson of China's foreign ministry. It is a typical move of unilateralism, protectionism and economic bullying.

Let me stress once again that trade wars and tariff wars have no winners. Pressuring, threatening or extorting China is not the right way to engage with us. If the U.S. insists on waging the tariffs war and trade war regardless of the interests of both countries and the international community, China will play along to the end.

That spokesperson of China's foreign ministry, Lin Jian, not mincing his words there. Let's get in BBC's Kerry Allen, who is a media analyst in BBC's China monitoring team. And she's joining me right now. Kerry, you've been going through this, all of it in China, covering the media there, noticing what's been reported. Tell us about what are people

What are people feeling there? How are businesses reacting to this kind of war of words leading to an ultimate trade war?

Well, it's difficult to know because China has a very tightly controlled media environment. So the government very much wants to lead messaging on this and to reassure businesses that they're not going to be heavily impacted. I mean, obviously, there's a lot of media internationally at the moment saying that this is going to have global repercussions. But China's

very much been wanting to tell businesses through its media that they will, through its own domestic economy, be able to soften the blow. So there's very much been a message of reassurance that China has very quickly moved with a series of measures to stabilize its own capital markets and restore investor confidence. And today, if you look on social media platforms, the equivalent of a platform like Facebook or Excel,

Thank you very much.

Mm-hmm.

Well, so things are under control is what the message is from China. Carrie, be with me because let's get in our expert as well. We have first Fiona Sankota, Senior Market Analyst of Citi Index joining us. Fiona, is that message also translating into the Asian markets? Are you seeing that there's been some sort of breather today after those panic selling modes that stock markets have been witnessing here for the past few trading sessions? Yes.

Yes, we have seen a calmer sense in the markets today. We've also seen Chinese state holding companies vowing to increase share investments, as well as a slew of listed firms that have announced share buybacks.

as they sort of step up efforts to stabilize the markets. And it has worked. Chinese stock markets rebounded. The Chinese blue chip CSI 300 was up 1.7% today. And the Shanghai Composite Index was also up 1.6%, as well as the Hang Seng being up. But this is after very steep slumps at the start of the week.

Well, there was another report from Citibank, which has cut China's GDP or growth forecast to 4.2% from 4.7% for 2025. Now, this means that the fundamentals are still weak for the economy, which was on a brink of a slowdown as well. There were efforts to stimulate economy by the Chinese government to pump in some extra cash. Now, how far does this trade war now go?

get the Chinese economy? How much of a setback will it be? Yeah, I think, you know, if these planned tariffs and the threats that we have from Trump do actually go ahead, then, you know, this will have a very serious impact on the Chinese economy. This is a Chinese economy that if we remember was, you know, in a

quite a difficult situation anyway. It was already dealing with weaker domestic demand. It was already dealing with a property sector in crisis. And so it was leaning on exports to sort of prop up the economy. So if you then sort of put on those very, very strict or harsh, aggressive tariffs from the U.S., that will have a serious impact. Yes.

So would you agree with what Kerry said earlier, the Chinese government messaging that things are under control as of now? Is that what investors are feeling as well for this economy or is just a brief pause for now?

Yeah, the sense that I have and what we've seen, I mean, if we look at the extent of the sell-off that we have seen at the start of the week, we saw stocks in China slump 7%. We saw the Hang Seng down 13%. We have seen that slight recovery today. But I think it's a very modest recovery, which suggests there's still a lot of fear there. All right, Fiona, stay with us because let's get in Dr. Ji Yu, Senior Research Fellow on China at Chatham House, who's joining us.

Doctor, same question to you. How are you assessing things from here? Because how much is China's economy dependent on the U.S. trade for now to feel the impact of this trade war?

Thank you for having me. Obviously, Chinese economies, particularly Chinese export, are particularly dependent on U.S. market. However, that proportion has really come down, I think, judging from back to eight years ago, where China already had a first round of trade war with Washington. So in the past, it was around 20% of the total Chinese export depended on U.S. market. But I think the number now has come down to the 13%.

So obviously, China's already began that process of diversification of its export market. But having said that, I think what really the signal from yesterday's 50% or even the 34% from the last week,

This is irrelevant. It's completely irrelevant. I think the key thing in here is the United States is a charter, a hard way of looking to a hard decoupling between China and the United States. And that is really, I think, a tariff. It's only a reflection of an extremely difficult bilateral relationship between the two.

Gary, let me get you in. Do you get a sense that companies which are operating out of China, including American companies, are now looking at China plus one when it comes to establishing their supply chains away from China? Is that what they're going for in this environment?

Well, there have been voices from American businesses within China that have expressed concern about these Trump tariffs. But one of the messages that Chinese media wants to make clear is that there are no... I mean, this is something that's been coming up in government messaging again and again. There are no winners when it comes to

by the trade or tariff wars. And one of the things that we've seen is that Chinese companies that were impacted in 2018 by the trade war that went overseas to areas like Vietnam, they're still feeling the impact by these fresh tariffs. So there's this idea...

that's penetrating in state media that's saying it doesn't matter where you go now, that these tariffs affect everybody. But China's got a large market. It's got a large population. It's innovating at a very quick speed. It's saying that it can...

basically soften the blow of these tariffs compared to other countries. And there's going to be a real issue with this. And the only way to deal with that is to fight back, which is what Canada, China and the EU are doing. And Dr. Yu, what could be that scenario where we see the endgame of it all? Who do you think will blink first between the US and China? What seems to be the endgame here?

Well, I mean, we're not sure at this stage. I think Kelly was absolutely right in here. It's really the politics rather than economic rationality that both sides are playing right now. Presidency cannot afford to look weak domestically because the Chinese public opinion towards the United States has become less favorable than compared with eight years ago, to put it mildly. So you have to come up with a rather defiant approach, but also measured approach

to targeted US companies and particularly in the tech sectors that operate within the Chinese market, but also American agriculture import into China, which again is really come from the heartland of Republican Party, something that to hurt American farmers.

So that is a way that Beijing is really aiming at. So all this added together, I would say, is both sides are doing some sense of mutually destruction in order to gain much harder bargaining chips when it comes to the trade negotiation. So we're going to see a very strong and robust responses from both sides.

for several rounds of several diplomatic wrestling and word on words. And then we'll probably come back to the negotiation table when both Beijing and Donald Trump realize how much damage they both have done.

So no winners here for now. And we'll have to see who comes to that negotiation table and how. But thank you so much for joining us, Dr. Zhiyu, Senior Research Fellow on China at Chatham House. You're with World Business Report from the BBC World Service. Moving now from the

the talks China is having with the US to the one it's having with Europe. On Tuesday, the EU chief Ursula von der Leyen had a call with China's Premier Li Keqiang, where they discussed how the two countries can work together in light of the new US tariffs. Kerry Allen is still with us. Kerry, this seems to be

a different kind of development where it's after the snap from the US, it seems China is willing to sit down with Europe, with which it has had tariff and retaliatory tariff kind of issues as well.

Yeah, absolutely. And this is a message that's really gone back to when Trump returned to the White House. I mean, China was putting messaging out saying that there was a whole opportunity for a reset of ties. And with regards to Europe, I mean, one of the things that Chinese businesses really value is those face-to-face talks. So there was the... When there were these tariffs in the auto industry, there was this...

You know, there was this messaging saying, well, we can sit down and we can talk about this. And especially with the introduction of these new tariffs. I mean, this is something that state media did expect. They thought for sure there's going to be a return to a trade war when Trump comes to power. And it was an opportunity early on to start thinking

establishing a good relationship with European nations and the EU as a whole. And there has been a lot of messaging in state media saying that there's an opportunity for China and the EU to work more closely together and write a new narrative for a multipolar world. At the same time, though, China does perceive the West as having prejudices against China. So you'll often see messaging...

on human rights where Europe and the US align and China's very critical of that. So it's looking at this sincerity under a microscope and very much saying that it does want to work closely with the EU and there are opportunities, but at the same time it comes with caveats.

BBC's Kerry Allen, thank you so much for joining us. We'll let you go back to what I'm sure what's a breaking news every hour, it seems, coming on this particular subject. But keeping up with what Kerry had said as well about this newfound opening of doors between the European Union and China, let's get in someone who's got all the knowledge.

all the details from the inside. Because joining us from Brussels is Olof Gill, European Commission spokesperson for economic security and trade. Thank you so much for joining us, Olof, at this time. Now, it's a simple thing. Have the Trump policies fundamentally shifted now how the EU needs to think about trade with China?

Good afternoon and thanks for having me on. I wouldn't say that there's any fundamental shift per se. The EU's position vis-à-vis China has been very clear and consistent for a number of years now. We've made very clear that we want to grow the EU-China trade and investment relationship for mutual benefit.

But we see many challenges, particularly on the Chinese side, that we would need to see addressed before we get to that stage. These include level playing field issues. These include some business environment difficulties that our companies perceive as

in China, issues like that. So in order for us to get to a stage where we feel we're getting towards stronger trade and investment relations with China, we would need to see some movement on those issues first and certainly engagement is a good step. But China is seeing

But China is saying that you need to meet halfway. It can't be that you're imposing tariffs on their electric vehicles at the same time trying to negotiate a resolution there.

It's fundamentally misleading to say that we need to meet them halfway when our European single market of some 450 million consumers is entirely open and rules-based for Chinese companies. They can compete here on a fair basis with European companies, provided they respect our rules, whereas we see clear evidence in China that our companies are not allowed to compete on a fair basis. So this and many other issues would need to be addressed in a meaningful way by China before

So how do you address that?

Well, that's up to the Chinese government to address our longstanding concerns on these questions. And should they demonstrate a willingness to do so, then we can talk about other issues, including resolving the longstanding saga on electric vehicles. You'll recall that we, following a detailed and lengthy investigation, found that Chinese electric vehicles

vehicles made in China were benefiting from massive amounts of unfair and illegal subsidies. And on that basis, we imposed tariffs on imports into the EU of battery electric vehicles made in China. It has been our position all the time that we are willing to find a negotiated outcome to this, provided it has the same end goal, i.e. eliminating the unfair competition and benefits from which those Chinese electric vehicles benefit.

But there's got to be a start somewhere, right? So if both the sides are wary of protectionism, how is it different from the kind of conversation you're having right now, especially with what the U.S. is being threatened with some more tariffs from the U.S.? So how do you try and work out a middle ground with China? Is there a realistic plan on the table?

I'm not sure what you're referring to when you say a middle ground with China. As I said, we have been clear and consistent in our view that we want the EU-China trade and investment relationship to be as strong and beneficial for both sides as it can be. But there are some conditions that we need to see met. OK, so tomorrow now you'll be voting on countermeasures against the US steel and aluminium tariff. What's on table for that?

So what's happening tomorrow is that the European member states will vote on the Commission's proposal for a certain number of countermeasures against the tariffs on steel and aluminium imports announced by the US around a month ago.

we want to be very clear that we don't want to do this. We don't want to have to take this step of retaliating. But unless our US counterparts are willing to negotiate in a serious way to find win-win outcomes rather than this direction of travel, we feel we have no course but to take this action to protect our industries and to protect our member states. And briefly now, Donald Trump has said that

the European Union could avoid the duties by purchasing more American liquefied natural gas. Now, if it comes to that, is there a discussion on it?

It's rather bizarre that President Trump flags this as something new when we've been saying since the day of his inauguration that LNG is one area that we're willing to look at in terms of finding deals and win with outcomes with our American counterparts. And we're still willing to do so. But it takes two to tango. And right now, there's no meaningful engagement from the US to try and find the type of deals we're talking about.

We leave it there. Thank you so much for joining us, Olaf Gill, European Commission spokesperson for economic security and trade, joining us there.

Now, to the country with the world's lowest birth rate. It's South Korea. With declining fertility rates, businesses there are facing a serious shortage of workers. So the government is now looking at increasing immigration, a move that is not exactly popular with locals. My colleague David Kan visited South Korea to find out more. Welcome.

Osan in Gyeonggi-do, South Korea, is a city with amongst the highest percentage of foreign workers in the country, mainly from other parts of Asia. And it's here where I meet Jones Galang, a Filipino missionary who is also the head of the Osan Migrant Workers' Center. Compared to other countries, Korea is very popular. Why? It is very new to Asian people and the salary is high.

more compared to other countries like Saudi, Hong Kong, UAE, like that. Especially the non-skilled workers.

The second, of course, it is a foos from their own countries because no job and poverty. So, for example, the Filipinos, nobody will come here if we can't find work in our country. It is very a shame. And then, of course, the third one is Korea needs workers. Korea needs workers to maintain his image in the international market.

and tend to maintain the economic up-load. So they need workers, and then for the workers, Korea is like a heaven.

Korea does really need its workers, especially young workers. Jaehyun Yoo is a professor of social welfare studies at Gacheon University in South Korea. He also sits on the advisory board for the Presidential Committee on Aging Society and Population Policy. South Korea now has more job seekers in their 60s than those in their 20s.

With the ongoing low birth rate, fewer teenagers are transitioning into adulthood. It's inevitable that the working age population will drop significantly. That is, unless we have immigration. It'll take time for the birth rate to increase, and even if more babies are born, it will take 20, 30 years for them to enter the workforce.

On the other hand, immigrants can make an immediate visible impact, quickly contributing to the economy. And the South Korean government is keenly aware of this. In August last year, Hyemi Yoo, senior secretary of low birth rate, spoke about immigration in an interview with the national radio station KBS. One potential solution to address the rapid decline in working age population is to utilise foreign labour. I believe we need to develop a medium to long-term plan for this.

Foreign workers have already been contributing significantly by filling the short-term labour shortages. However, we need to look beyond this. But with 95% of the population identifying as ethnically Korean, racial discrimination is a major concern for many migrant workers.

Udayarai is the president of the Seoul-Gyeonggi-Incheon Migrants Trade Union. He's originally from Nepal and he told me about his experience of moving and settling here. When I came to this country over 30 years ago, I was in my mid-20s. I couldn't speak any Korean and they looked down on me so much.

telling me that I'm not good at the job. They made me do more dangerous work than Korean workers. They scolded me more for the same mistakes. They made fun of my culture and food. They would sometimes hit me, and they didn't pay us properly either.

People treated me as an inferior, at least that's how I felt. There was a manager called Mr Kim and he would scold me so much, calling me lazy all the time. I think he felt threatened that foreigners will take over the industry and take his job away. And even now, when I meet someone with a surname Kim, I feel uncomfortable.

Udaya Rai's concerns aren't falling on deaf ears. Jung Hoon-cho is a member of Conservative People's Power, the ruling party at the National Assembly. It's how attractive Korea is.

more broadly, more welcoming and hospitable social environment to our migrants. The Korean economy, even today, will not survive even a day if there's no immigrant workers. The real question is whether we should have even more immigrant workers or less. At the moment, current signal is upward. Almost all sectors are demanding more visa quota for immigrant workers.

While concerns remain, those wanting to move to South Korea have been steadily increasing, with the immigration application numbers almost tripling between 2022 and 2024. A welcome increase for a country that's facing depopulation unprecedented anywhere else in the world.

That was David Kan reporting, and you can hear more from his report. Just search for Business Daily wherever you get your podcasts. Fiona Sankota still with us. Fiona, very quick reaction from the U.S. markets now. They seem to have opened in green, a slight reprieve from the tariff market turmoil so far.

Yes, that's right. We've seen a strong open on Wall Street. The stock indices are rising just shy of 4%. And that comes after falling around 10% over the past three sessions. So, as you said, you know, we are seeing a little bit of a bounce today, but it remains to be seen whether that can be maintained.

I'm sure your fingers and toe fingers are all crossed for this market to go ahead in the green. But thank you so much for joining us, Fiona Sankota, Senior Market Analyst at Citi Index. This is also coming on the back of news that Treasury Secretary Scott Besant has told a U.S. network that around 70 countries had approached the U.S. for tariff negotiations so far. So hoping that negotiations would be the way forward for some sort of a

climb down from the tariffs that have been proposed so far by US President Donald Trump. You've been listening to World Business Report. This is Davina Gupta joining you from Delhi with Isabel Izzy and James Wickham on the show. Thank you for being with us.

This is Shirley Strawberry from the Steve Harvey Morning Show. Toyota has been building a legacy of excellence for years, from developing hybrid technology to upping the standards of safety and efficiency. Toyota is always innovating, always making progress. And with a superior lineup of in-stock SUVs, including the adventure-ready RAV4 and capable, affordable Corolla Cross, you can experience the legacy of Toyota for yourself. Visit

buyatoyota.com, the official website for deals to find out more. Toyota, let's go places.