cover of episode 影评《好东西》:“我不要打拳!”

影评《好东西》:“我不要打拳!”

2024/11/21
logo of podcast 什么电苔|认真调侃电影

什么电苔|认真调侃电影

People
孔老师
梁梁
蛋黄酱
Topics
孔老师: 《好东西》是一部优秀的都市清喜剧,其喜剧效果出色,远远超越了性别议题本身。影片并非排斥男性观众,反而鼓励男性去了解和观看,因为它以一种善意的方式表达了都市生活中男性和女性的相处关系以及不同类型。 影片中展现了都市生活中男性和女性的不同类型和相处模式,以及男性对女性需求的理解和学习过程,以及男女之间仍然存在的冲突。 宋佳在影片中的角色与以往角色不同,展现了更加立体和有层次感的女性形象,与她在《山花浪漫时》中饰演的张贵梅角色有相似之处,都展现了有层次感和活人感的女性形象。 钟楚曦在影片中也摆脱了以往的“花瓶”形象,展现了更复杂和多面的女性形象,与她在《二十一世纪》中的角色有很大不同。 影片中小孩的角色是去性别化的表达,代表了纯真的视角,也代表了对未来的期待。 影片中男性角色也各有特点,赵又廷饰演的前夫哥是一个“觉醒”但未完全觉醒的男性角色,张宇饰演的小马展现了男性在感情中的脆弱和自尊心,胡医生则是一个自恋、沉浸在自我世界中的男性角色,缺乏爱的能力。 影片中很多细节展现了上海独特的城市文化和人性化执法,以及导演对年轻人的关怀。 影片通过喜剧的方式表达了深刻的社会议题,并巧妙地消解了潜在的说教性。 邵艺辉导演的选角和对演员内心的把握细腻,这可能是女性导演的优势。 邵艺辉导演与冯小刚导演有相似之处,都开创了新的叙事角度,并注重当下性表达,追求商业成功。 蛋黄酱: 《好东西》是一部优秀的都市爱情喜剧,值得推荐给所有女性,尤其是喜欢《芭比》和《爱情神话》的观众。 影片的角色并非从压抑到觉醒的过程,而是已经处于觉醒状态,邵艺辉导演的女性主义视角超越了以往的觉醒叙事,建立了新的游戏规则。 《好东西》是一部现象级电影,回应了时代呼唤,包含女性主义及其他社会议题,将故事和人物镶嵌在时代背景中,细节饱满,值得在2024年观看。 钟楚曦在《好东西》中摆脱了以往的“花瓶”形象,展现了更复杂和多面的女性形象。 小叶渴望长期稳定的关系,但同时也展现了缺爱和脆弱的一面,展现了女性的多面性。 铁梅和小叶互相学习和成长,互相治愈。 茉莉(小孩)是全剧最成熟的角色,是导演的化身,代表了对未来的期待。 影片中包含了很多彩蛋,这些彩蛋与时代背景相关,值得细细品味。 影片通过喜剧的方式表达了深刻的社会议题,并巧妙地消解了潜在的说教性。 梁梁: 《好东西》是一部言之有物、欢乐的电影,让自己感到开心和激动。 钟楚曦在《好东西》中饰演的小叶是一个恋爱脑但又可爱、脆弱的角色,展现了女性的多面性。 小叶是一个自卑、习惯自我保护的角色,渴望爱情但又习惯降低底线。 铁梅和小叶互相学习和成长,互相治愈。 影片中声音蒙太奇的片段展现了母亲的伟大,令人感动。 影片中并没有说教,而是通过包袱消解了潜在的说教性。 喜剧是一种保护色,可以保护表达者和听众免受冒犯。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did the movie 'Good Stuff' receive mixed reviews on Bilibili?

The movie 'Good Stuff' received mixed reviews on Bilibili due to its marketing leaning towards gender issues, which made some users and up主 uncomfortable. However, the film itself transcends gender topics and is an excellent urban comedy that appeals to a broad audience, including men.

What is the significance of the character Wang Tiemei in 'Good Stuff'?

Wang Tiemei in 'Good Stuff' is a multi-dimensional character who breaks away from traditional female stereotypes. She is a strong, independent woman who also shows vulnerability and growth, particularly in her relationship with her daughter. Her character represents a new kind of female protagonist in Chinese cinema.

How does 'Good Stuff' address gender issues through its characters?

'Good Stuff' addresses gender issues by presenting characters who have already undergone a form of awakening or enlightenment. The film avoids the traditional narrative of women moving from oppression to liberation, instead showing characters who are already aware of gender dynamics and are navigating modern urban life with this awareness.

What makes 'Good Stuff' a unique film in the context of Chinese cinema?

'Good Stuff' is unique in Chinese cinema for its focus on urban, middle-class life and its use of humor to address serious social issues. The film's director, Shao Yihui, brings a fresh perspective by blending comedy with subtle commentary on gender, relationships, and societal norms, making it a standout in contemporary Chinese film.

Why is the sound montage in 'Good Stuff' considered one of the best scenes of 2024?

The sound montage in 'Good Stuff' is considered one of the best scenes of 2024 because it creatively uses everyday sounds to represent a mother's household labor, transforming mundane tasks into a poetic and powerful visual and auditory experience. This scene highlights the often invisible work of women and does so in a way that is both artistic and emotionally resonant.

How does 'Good Stuff' compare to other films by Shao Yihui?

Compared to Shao Yihui's previous works, 'Good Stuff' is more self-assured and commercially oriented. While maintaining her signature humor and sharp observations, this film expands her narrative scope and targets a broader audience, making it a significant step forward in her career as a filmmaker.

What role does humor play in 'Good Stuff'?

Humor in 'Good Stuff' serves as a protective layer that allows the film to address serious and potentially controversial topics without alienating the audience. The comedic elements make the social commentary more palatable and engaging, ensuring that the film's messages are delivered in an accessible and entertaining manner.

Why is 'Good Stuff' considered a must-watch film for 2024?

'Good Stuff' is considered a must-watch for 2024 because it captures the zeitgeist of the past few years, embedding contemporary social issues and cultural references into its narrative. The film's relevance is tied to its timely exploration of gender, urban life, and societal changes, making it a poignant reflection of the current era.

Chapters
本期节目是关于电影《好东西》的影评,三位嘉宾分享了各自的观影感受,并给出了五星好评。他们认为这部电影是一部优秀的都市轻喜剧,值得推荐给所有观众,尤其适合那些喜欢《爱情神话》和《芭比》的观众。
  • 豆瓣开分9.1分,国产影视剧中少见高分佳作
  • 三位嘉宾一致好评,认为其为优秀的都市轻喜剧
  • 推荐给喜欢《爱情神话》和《芭比》的观众

Shownotes Transcript

公众号:SMFM2016 尽管邵艺辉导演在电影里和采访里反复强调“我不要打拳”,在性别对立愈演愈烈的当下,《好东西》不可避免的被扣上了对当前形势推波助澜的帽子。但在我们看来,虽然金句乱飞,这部电影其实是一部很纯粹的都市商业喜剧,并且在努力对所有人释放善意。 这次为了在性别上更加均衡,孔老师请来了好朋友「宇宙尽头小酒馆」的蛋黄酱和梁梁,聊聊为什么这部电影,其实男的真的也爱看。 03:59 开分9.1,聊聊我们的观影感受,顺便打个分 13:37 从角色聊起,电影里令人心疼和可敬的女性 38:56 讨论:铁梅的人生状态是否过于悬浮理想,没有代表性? 41:04 电影里可爱又可笑的男孩子们 58:32 金句乱飞,笑点横行,深谙朋友圈爆文之道的邵艺辉 1:09:07 这是不是一部属于上海的电影?电影里的上海彩蛋 01:17:48 声音蒙太奇,年度最佳镜头之一 1:19:43 邵艺辉如何用喜剧来消解说教感 1:22:44 为什么我说,邵艺辉其实是这个时代的冯小刚 1:29:01 邵艺辉和文牧野是中国电影未来的遮羞布 想做嘉宾,联系我们:[email protected] 片尾曲:《明天会更好》by 2022.5.26 上海延庆路部分部分市民 歌曲素材来源:UP主@niaokuxia转载,地址:https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1nZ4y1b72X,视频拍摄:上海市民 孔老师微博@做着学生的孔老师 王老师微博@浩浩很含蓄 什么电台官方微博@什么FM B站:什么电苔孔老师  本期阵容:孔老师、蛋黄酱、梁梁