《志愿军2》、《浴火之路》、《749局》-影迷的角落Vol.94
影迷的角落 | 院线电影 经典佳片 娱乐影视类播客
Deep Dive
Why is 《志愿军2》 considered better than the first part?
《志愿军2》 is considered better than the first part because it focuses more narrowly on the story of a single family, particularly Zhang Zifeng, Zhu Yilong, and Xin Baiqing, during the Korean War. The first part was more fragmented, covering multiple perspectives including the battlefield, negotiations in Zhongnanhai, and the U.S. embassy. The second part provides more detailed war scenes and tactical explanations, such as how to dig trenches to prevent secondary injuries from shrapnel and how to measure distances to counter American tanks.
What are the main criticisms of 《浴火之路》?
The main criticisms of 《浴火之路》 include its lack of logical coherence, especially in the latter part of the film where the story devolves into chaotic action scenes. The film's portrayal of the antagonist's intelligence and the timing of police intervention are also criticized for being unrealistic. Additionally, the character development, particularly for Zhao Liying's role, is seen as lacking depth and complexity, making her performance feel out of place in the film's narrative.
What are the key issues with 《749局》?
《749局》 suffers from a lack of logical coherence and poor storytelling. The film introduces a plot about an alien monster growing underground and a group of children with superpowers, but fails to explain why only Wang Junkai can solve the problem. The special effects are subpar, and the film's pacing and character development are inconsistent. Additionally, the film's attempt to tie into the universe of 《九层妖塔》 feels forced and underdeveloped.
How does the portrayal of war tactics in 《志愿军2》 stand out?
《志愿军2》 stands out in its portrayal of war tactics by providing detailed explanations of defensive strategies, such as how to dig trenches to minimize shrapnel injuries and how to measure distances to counter American tanks. The film also includes a unique scene where a military expert gathers feedback from soldiers on weapon effectiveness, highlighting the challenges faced by the Chinese military in terms of manufacturing precision and the sacrifices made by soldiers.
What is the audience's reaction to the special effects in 《749局》?
The audience's reaction to the special effects in 《749局》 is largely negative, with many describing them as outdated and poorly executed. The film's attempt to create a visually stunning experience falls short, particularly in scenes involving Wang Junkai's character, who is supposed to have wings. The wings are criticized for being static and unrealistic, detracting from the overall visual appeal of the film.
- 《志愿军2》比第一部更聚焦，视角更微观；战争场面和特效出色；对战争细节的刻画更细致；演员表现中规中矩；豆瓣评分在7分到7.5分之间；票房为国庆档最高，但未突破十亿。
Shownotes Transcript