cover of episode Is behaviour on X / Twitter dangerous?

Is behaviour on X / Twitter dangerous?

2025/1/3
logo of podcast The Hard Shoulder Highlights

The Hard Shoulder Highlights

People
A
Adrian Kennedy
E
Eoin O’Malley
J
John O'Brennan
Topics
John O'Brennan: 马斯克的行为极其危险,因为他拥有巨大的财富和影响力,能够干预美国和欧洲的政治进程。他利用X平台散布虚假信息,例如在德国马格德堡袭击事件后,他声称袭击者来自穆斯林世界,而实际上袭击者是德国极右翼政党的支持者。马斯克的行为已经激怒了德国民众,并引发了对采取行动的呼吁。他反对欧盟等机构的监管,因为他希望不受限制地进行活动。马斯克的影响力巨大,他的言论通过算法放大效应,对政治产生重大影响,导致信息茧房效应,加剧社会分裂。 John O'Brennan: 马斯克的行为类似于特朗普早期竞选时的策略,但其影响力更大,更应被认真对待。他通过巨额财富和社交媒体平台干涉美国和欧洲政治,例如在德国袭击事件后散布不实信息。 John O'Brennan: 欧盟的《数字服务法案》为规范社交媒体平台提供了工具,可能导致马斯克被禁。德国事件后,欧盟可能会采取更严格的监管措施,甚至可能导致马斯克或其平台被禁。算法操纵导致信息失衡,对政治产生直接影响,需要通过监管来解决。 Eoin O’Malley: 马斯克的危险性并非源于其对X平台的所有权,而是其巨大的财富和对政治的影响力。他试图将许多美国政府职能私有化,并以直接有利于自身的方式干预政府行为。我不认为需要压制像马斯克这样的人的言论,因为仅仅因为观点不受欢迎而压制言论是危险的。对马斯克的担忧不应集中在其言论或平台所有权上,而应关注其对政治和社会议题的影响。社交媒体对选举的影响有限,不应因为马斯克富有或拥有大量粉丝就限制其言论。规范言论可能导致压制言论,限制公开讨论重要公共政策问题。 Adrian Kennedy: 许多人认为自从马斯克接管后,X平台(原Twitter)成为了一个充满恶意内容的平台。对马斯克言论的担忧在于其煽动性,而非其平台所有权。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why is Elon Musk considered a dangerous individual in the context of politics?

Elon Musk is considered dangerous due to his immense wealth, influence over powerful figures like Donald Trump, and his active interference in political processes. He has used his platform to sway political outcomes, such as threatening to fund primary campaigns against Republican congressmen who opposed his views. Additionally, he has spread misinformation, such as falsely claiming a terrorist attack in Germany was linked to open borders, despite evidence showing the perpetrator supported a right-wing party.

How has Elon Musk's behavior on X (formerly Twitter) impacted European politics?

Elon Musk has increasingly interfered in European politics, particularly in Germany and the UK. For example, after a terrorist attack in Germany, Musk falsely attributed the incident to open borders and Muslim infiltration, despite the perpetrator's clear ties to a right-wing party. This has caused significant anger in Germany and raised concerns about his influence on political discourse. His actions have also led to calls for stricter regulation under the EU's Digital Services Act.

What is the Digital Services Act, and how could it affect Elon Musk and X?

The Digital Services Act (DSA) is an EU regulation aimed at tackling disinformation and harmful content on digital platforms. It will fully come into force on February 24, giving policymakers tools to hold platform owners accountable. If Musk continues to spread misinformation or incite hatred, the DSA could lead to his platform being banned in the EU. This regulation is particularly significant in light of Musk's recent behavior, such as his inflammatory tweets about political figures and events.

What are the concerns about regulating speech on platforms like X?

Regulating speech on platforms like X raises concerns about who decides what constitutes acceptable or unacceptable opinions. Critics argue that such regulation could stifle important public policy discussions, as seen with the transgender issue, where certain viewpoints were labeled as hateful and removed. This creates a risk of suppressing legitimate debate and giving authorities too much power to define what is considered hate speech or misinformation.

How has Elon Musk's ownership of X changed the platform?

Since Elon Musk took over X, formerly Twitter, the platform has seen an increase in freedom of speech, which has also led to more unpleasant and extreme content. While some argue it has become a 'cesspit,' others believe it reflects a broader societal shift. Musk's ownership has also been marked by his personal use of the platform to amplify controversial opinions and interfere in political matters, further polarizing the platform.

What role does Elon Musk play in amplifying political content on X?

Elon Musk uses his massive following of 210 million users to amplify political content, often favoring right-wing or controversial viewpoints. His tweets and retweets can significantly influence public discourse, as seen in his involvement in UK grooming gang discussions and his support for figures like Tommy Robinson. This amplification effect has raised concerns about his ability to manipulate political narratives and spread disinformation.

Chapters
This chapter examines Elon Musk's highly vocal and controversial political commentary on X, formerly Twitter, particularly focusing on his interference in US and European politics. His actions are analyzed, and concerns about their potential danger are raised, citing specific examples of his behavior.
  • Elon Musk's frequent and eccentric posts on X are viewed as a serious concern.
  • Musk's significant wealth and influence are highlighted as factors contributing to his dangerousness.
  • Musk's interference in British politics and his response to the Magdeburg attack are given as examples of his problematic behavior.

Shownotes Transcript

In recent months, Elon Musk has been very vocal on X, formerly Twitter, about various political issues both in the US and Europe. But, is his behaviour on X dangerous?

John O’Brennan, Professor in European Politics in Maynooth University and Eoin O’Malley, Associate Professor of Politics at DCU join guest host Adrian Kennedy to discuss.