The Mary Celeste was found with its sails partly set but torn, ropes hanging loosely, and no crew on board. The main hatch cover was secure, but two smaller hatches were open. The ship had three feet of water in the hold, soaked belongings, and its lifeboat was missing. Supplies, including food, water, and 1700 gallons of alcohol, were intact. The ship's papers and navigational tools were missing, but there was no evidence of violence or disaster.
Frederick Solly Flood, the Attorney General of Gibraltar, theorized that the crew of the Mary Celeste had sampled the industrial-strength alcohol they were transporting, leading to violent actions against Captain Briggs and his family. He claimed evidence of a struggle, including notches on the ship's bow and rust on the captain's sword, which he believed was blood. However, his theory was disproven when blood tests returned negative, and he was forced to release the ship.
In 2006, Professor Andrea Sella from University College London conducted an experiment suggesting that an explosion caused by the alcohol cargo or its fumes was the most likely explanation. The explosion would have left no scorch marks but would have been terrifying enough to prompt the crew to abandon the ship in a hurry. This theory aligns with the missing lifeboat and the open hatches found on the ship.
The Mary Celeste story captivated the 19th-century public due to its mysterious nature, the dramatic image of a ghost ship, and the human tragedy of a missing crew. The media sensationalized theories of murder, mutiny, and natural disasters, fitting into the Victorian fascination with mystery and the unknown. The story also reflected anxieties about global trade and the dangers of maritime travel during the height of the British Empire.
Captain Benjamin Briggs was unusual for bringing his wife and two-year-old daughter on a merchant voyage, a rare domestic setup for the time. He was a devoutly religious teetotaler with extensive maritime experience. Briggs had modified the ship's cabin to accommodate his family, reflecting his desire to combine work with family life. His decision to bring his family on board added a layer of tragedy to the mystery of their disappearance.
In 1872 the ghost ship *Mary Celeste *is found sailing across the Atlantic without a single crew member left on board. Theories over what happened on the Mary Celeste range from insurance fraud to a violent mutiny... this week, Maddy and Anthony discuss what they think happened to the ship's crew.
Edited by Tom Delargy. Produced by Freddy Chick. Senior Producer is Charlotte Long.
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe).
You can take part in our listener survey__ here__).
After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal is a History Hit podcast.