The story resonates with Americans because it reflects the fear of the American dream turning into a nightmare. It has been parodied in popular culture, such as The Simpsons, and the image of a house with two large windows resembling eyes is deeply ingrained in the American psyche.
In 1974, Ronald DeFeo murdered his entire family with a rifle in their home at 112 Ocean Avenue, Amityville. The lack of a clear motive for the crime created a void that later allowed for the supernatural narrative to take hold.
The Exorcist, released in 1973, created a widespread belief in demonic possession and the supernatural. This cultural moment made it the perfect time to introduce a story about a haunted house, as people were already primed to believe in such phenomena.
The Lutz family reported swarms of flies, a pig-like creature named Jody with glowing eyes, walls bleeding green slime, doors being blasted off hinges, and Kathy Lutz levitating. Some of these claims were later debunked, while others were exaggerated for dramatic effect.
The Lutz family likely fabricated the haunting to make money. They were in debt after purchasing the house and saw an opportunity to capitalize on the supernatural narrative, which was popular at the time due to films like The Exorcist.
The hoax was exposed through a series of lawsuits and counter-lawsuits involving William Weber, the attorney for Ronald DeFeo, and the Lutz family. Weber revealed that they had concocted the story over bottles of wine, aiming to create a profitable horror narrative.
The Exorcist sparked a renewed interest in the supernatural and demonic possession. It led to an increase in demand for exorcisms and influenced cultural beliefs about evil forces. The film's success demonstrated that horror stories based on true events could be highly profitable.
The Amityville Horror contributed to the rise of Pentecostal spiritual warfare, where churches now actively combat alleged demonic presences in homes and public spaces. The story's logic of identifying and exorcising evil places has become a common practice in some religious communities.
112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville (Long Island) is arguably the most haunted house in America. Inside its walls demonic forces were, allegedly, unleashed. It's a story that is a troubling mixture of real murders and deliberate myth-making. It's also a story that owes a lot to a movie that shaped America in the 1970s in profound ways...The Exorcist.
Anthony and Maddy's guest to explore this incredible piece of paranormal history is Professor Joseph Laycock, associate professor of Religious Studies at Texas State University. He's the author of *The Exorcist Effect: Horror, Religion, and Demonic Belief *and The Penguin Book of Exorcisms.
Edited by Freddy Chick and Tomos Delargy. Produced by Freddy Chick. Senior Producer is Charlotte Long.
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe).
You can take part in our listener survey__ here__).
After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal is a History Hit podcast.