cover of episode News Watch: PinkNews allegations, Syrian asylum claims, and don't forget about Georgia

News Watch: PinkNews allegations, Syrian asylum claims, and don't forget about Georgia

2024/12/12
logo of podcast Media Storm

Media Storm

People
H
Helena Wadia
M
Matilda Mallinson
Topics
Helena Wadia:媒体报道中存在偏见,过分关注Ariana Grande而忽略了Cynthia Erivo在《Wicked》中的贡献,反映了媒体对名气和种族的偏见。这种偏见也体现在对其他社会新闻的报道中,例如对格鲁吉亚政治动荡的关注不足。 Matilda Mallinson:格鲁吉亚的政治局势动荡,但国际媒体对此报道不足,其全球意义被低估。格鲁吉亚政府镇压抗议活动,国际社会反应迟缓,媒体报道不足。西方媒体对格鲁吉亚事件的关注不足,可能与西方国家自身政治立场的尴尬有关。 Tata Chikviladze:格鲁吉亚政府对和平示威者的残酷镇压,以及对记者的攻击,旨在压制异见。国际媒体对事件的报道不足,未能反映事件的严重性。格鲁吉亚人民渴望加入欧盟,并摆脱俄罗斯的影响。 Matilda Mallinson:PinkNews丑闻以及一些媒体利用这些指控来推动反跨性别叙事。对PinkNews创始人的性行为不端指控,以及一些媒体利用这些指控来推动反跨性别叙事,反映了媒体对社会议题的操弄。一些媒体利用PinkNews丑闻来攻击支持跨性别权利的媒体,这是一种转移视线和打压异见的策略。 Helena Wadia:叙利亚政权更迭后,一些西方国家暂停了叙利亚难民的申请处理,此举不人道且缺乏远见。西方国家暂停叙利亚难民申请处理,反映了西方国家对难民问题的冷漠和政治算计。此举不仅不人道,而且缺乏对国际关系和地区稳定的理解。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why is Georgia's political situation significant globally?

Georgia's political crisis is significant because it represents a clash between Russia and the West, EU federalism versus anti-EU nationalism, and a revolution against a totalitarian coup. It also highlights the struggle for EU integration, a goal supported by 80% of Georgians, and the country's desire to distance itself from Russia.

What are the key allegations against the founders of PinkNews?

The founders of PinkNews, Anthony James and Benjamin Cohen, have been accused of multiple incidents of sexual misconduct, including inappropriate behavior towards junior staff members who appeared too drunk to consent. Over 30 current and former staff members have reported a culture of heavy drinking leading to unsafe work environments and allegations of bullying, misogyny, and inappropriate requests to female staff regarding surrogacy.

Why has the international media coverage of Georgia's protests been limited?

International media coverage of Georgia's protests has been limited because it is awkward for Western political leaders and media, who often base their narratives on liberalism and EU membership. The situation in Georgia challenges these values, as many Western leaders have risen to power by rejecting liberal identity and embracing nationalism. Additionally, the UK media has under-interrogated the consequences of Brexit, making it uncomfortable to cover a foreign population risking their lives for EU integration.

How has the UK's decision to pause Syrian asylum claims been received?

The UK's decision to pause Syrian asylum claims has been met with criticism as it sends a hostile message to Syrians, both those trying to enter the UK and those already living there. It is seen as ignorant, as one day after the fall of a brutal regime does not make a country safe and prosperous. The decision also fails to consider the ongoing instability in Syria, including Israel's invasion, and undermines the international community's role in supporting democratic transitions and effective governance in post-regime Syria.

What is the significance of the Golden Globe nominations for Wicked?

The Golden Globe nominations for Wicked highlight the media's tendency to focus on high-profile celebrities like Ariana Grande, overshadowing the achievements of lesser-known talents like Cynthia Erivo. Erivo, who has been nominated for an Emmy, Grammy, Oscar, and Tony Award, is one of the few artists to be EGOT-nominated, yet her recognition in the media is often secondary to more famous names.

How has the international community responded to the Georgian protests?

The international community has imposed sanctions on the Georgian Dream Party, with calls for further action from Ukraine's Zelensky and the Baltic states. However, the US has only considered sanctions without taking action at the time of recording. Georgian protesters have expressed frustration with the delayed response, holding signs saying, 'Dear West, you are late again. Sanction oligarch and his puppets now.'

What is the role of Hayat Tahrir al-Sham in the Syrian revolution?

Hayat Tahrir al-Sham is a rebel group that has led the Syrian revolution, overthrowing the Assad regime. Despite being labeled a terrorist organization by the UK and EU, the group has shown adaptability to global pressure and national needs, making it a key player in the transition of power in Syria. The international community's support is crucial for ensuring a democratic transition and effective governance in post-regime Syria.

Shownotes Transcript

Content warning: descriptions of violence, mentions of rape, descriptions of transphobia

Join Mathilda and Helena on their weekly news debriefs! We pick apart the most unhinged headlines and try to make sense of the mainstream media - helping you consume the news critically.

This week, we point out a gaping blind spot in the international press: Georgia, a country at the intersection of Europe and Asia and on the southern border of Russia, is on fire politically. And its people need the world to care. We hear from journalists on the ground, and spotlight how and why this story has been underreported, and its global significance downplayed. Next, serious allegations of sexual misconduct against the founders of PinkNews have been uncovered, thanks to over 30 former and current staff members at the outlet. But some media outlets and personalities have capitalised on victims' testimonies to promote transphobia - and they think they can get away with it. And finally, one day after the fall of the Assad regime in Syria, the UK has paused decisions on Syrian asylum claims. We discuss why this announcement is politically trigger happy: focused on cheap domestic wins, not international emergencies. Also... Helena holds more space for Wicked.

The episode is hosted and produced by Mathilda Mallinson (@mathildamall)) and Helena Wadia (@helenawadia))

Follow us @mediastormpod) and support us on Patreon).

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices)