cover of episode Julia's Book Club – Blue Sisters

Julia's Book Club – Blue Sisters

2024/9/4
logo of podcast A Podcast of One's Own with Julia Gillard

A Podcast of One's Own with Julia Gillard

People
J
Julia
K
Kathy
Topics
Julia: 本期节目讨论了Coco Mellors的小说《蓝色姐妹》。小说讲述了四个姐妹在其中一个姐妹意外过量服用药物去世后,如何应对悲伤和彼此疏远的故事。姐妹情谊是小说中一个重要的主题,作者通过小说探讨了姐妹之间复杂的关系,以及她们如何应对失去亲人的痛苦。此外,小说还探讨了成瘾问题,以及它如何影响家庭成员之间的关系。Julia认为,公开讨论女性选择或不选择成为母亲的原因很重要,并且无子女的女性也是一股强大的力量。她还分享了自己与姐妹之间亲密无间的关系,以及她们如何互相支持和理解。 Julia认为小说中姐妹之间的关系缺乏快乐和幽默感,她们总是争吵,这与她自己与姐妹之间的关系形成了鲜明对比。她认为小说中姐妹们除了共同的成长经历和失去姐妹的悲伤之外,似乎没有什么共同之处。她还对小说中对母亲的刻画表示不满,认为小说对母亲的刻画过于负面,忽略了她们的付出和努力。 Julia认为小说探讨了姐妹情谊、成瘾、母性以及悲伤等主题,但深度不足。她认为小说中对母亲的刻画不够全面,忽略了她们的付出和努力,并且小说没有将姐妹们的个人经历置于更广泛的社会背景下进行讨论。她还认为,即使没有亲姐妹,女性也可以在其他女性朋友中找到姐妹情谊。 Kathy Lette: Kathy Lette同意Julia的观点,认为小说中四个姐妹之间的关系缺乏可信度,姐妹们的性格设定缺乏一致性,而且她们的关系描写也不可信。她认为小说中四个姐妹都不同程度地存在着成瘾问题,这与她们的家庭背景有关。她认为小说探讨了成瘾和应对悲伤这两个主题,但并没有带来什么新的见解。 Kathy Lette认为小说未能引起读者的强烈情感共鸣,她认为小说中对母亲的刻画过于负面,缺乏对她们的理解和同情。她认为小说中对父亲酗酒和暴力行为的描写很精彩,体现了家庭环境对孩子造成的影响。她还认为小说探讨了女性是否选择生育的主题,但深度不够。 Kathy Lette认为公开讨论女性选择或不选择生育的原因非常重要,尤其是在当前社会背景下。她还认为,不应该过度责备母亲,她们也需要被理解和支持。她认为小说中对母亲的刻画过于负面,忽略了母亲的付出和辛劳。她最后总结说,小说中有一些精彩的描写,但整体深度不足。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

What are the central themes explored in Coco Mellors' novel 'Blue Sisters'?

The novel explores themes of sisterhood, grief, addiction, and motherhood. It delves into how the sudden death of their sister Nicky impacts the lives of the three remaining Blue sisters—Avery, Bonnie, and Lucky—and how they navigate their relationships and personal struggles with addiction and loss.

How does the novel portray the relationship between the Blue sisters?

The sisters are depicted as estranged and emotionally distant after the death of their sister Nicky. Their interactions are often marked by bickering and conflict, lacking the joy and camaraderie typically associated with sisterhood. Despite their shared grief, they struggle to reconnect and support each other emotionally.

What role does addiction play in the lives of the Blue sisters?

Addiction is a recurring theme in the novel, affecting each sister differently. Nicky died from an accidental overdose due to painkiller addiction, Lucky battles substance abuse and a party lifestyle, Avery overcame heroin addiction but is now a workaholic, and Bonnie is addicted to her boxing lifestyle and the pain it brings. Their father's alcoholism also influenced their upbringing.

How does the novel address the theme of motherhood?

The novel critically examines motherhood through the lens of the sisters' experiences. Their mother is portrayed as emotionally distant and overwhelmed, while Avery takes on a maternal role for her siblings. The book also explores the ambivalence some women feel about becoming mothers, particularly in the context of societal pressures and personal choices.

What is the significance of Nicky's death in the novel?

Nicky's death from an accidental overdose serves as the catalyst for the sisters' estrangement and their individual struggles with grief. Her death highlights the impact of untreated endometriosis and the tragic consequences of her dependence on painkillers, as she refused a hysterectomy to preserve her dream of motherhood.

How does the novel critique societal expectations of motherhood?

The novel critiques societal expectations by portraying the ambivalence and challenges of motherhood. It highlights how women are often judged for their choices, whether they choose to have children or not. The book also touches on the lack of support for mothers and the unrealistic expectations placed on them, as seen in the portrayal of the sisters' mother and Avery's partner's mother.

What is the significance of the sisters' father in the novel?

The sisters' father is depicted as an alcoholic with violent outbursts, whose moods dominated their household. His addiction and abusive behavior shaped their childhood and contributed to Avery taking on a maternal role. The novel uses his character to explore the generational impact of addiction and the emotional scars it leaves on families.

How does the novel handle the theme of grief?

Grief is a central theme, as the sisters struggle to cope with the loss of Nicky. The novel examines how grief manifests differently in each sister and how it affects their relationships and personal lives. Despite their shared loss, they find it difficult to support each other emotionally, highlighting the isolating nature of grief.

What is the novel's perspective on sisterhood?

The novel presents a complex view of sisterhood, emphasizing both the deep bonds and the conflicts that can arise between siblings. While the sisters share a profound connection, their relationships are strained by grief, addiction, and personal differences. The book contrasts their experiences with the idealized notion of sisterhood, showing both its strengths and limitations.

How does the novel explore the impact of addiction on family dynamics?

The novel shows how addiction affects each family member differently, from the sisters' struggles with substance abuse to their father's alcoholism. It highlights the generational cycle of addiction and its destructive impact on relationships, as well as the challenges of breaking free from its grip.

Chapters
This chapter introduces Blue Sisters, the second novel by Coco Mellors, focusing on the story of three sisters dealing with the death of their fourth sister, Nicky. It explores themes of sisterhood, grief, addiction, and motherhood, with the sisters scattered across the globe attempting to navigate their loss and reconnect.
  • Coco Mellors's second novel, Blue Sisters, centers on three sisters coping with the loss of their sibling, Nicky.
  • The novel explores sisterhood, grief, addiction, and motherhood.
  • The sisters are geographically separated and estranged after Nicky's death from an accidental overdose.

Shownotes Transcript

In this episode of Julia's Book Club, Julia and Kathy Lette sit down to discuss Blue Sisters by Coco Mellors.

Blue Sisters is the second novel from Mellors, following her bestselling debut Cleopatra and Frankenstein. It tells the story of three very different sisters – strait-laced lawyer Avery, party girl Lucky and stoic world champion boxer Bonnie – who are torn apart by grief and scattered to different corners of the globe after the sudden tragic death of their fourth sister, Nicky.

As the sisters try to come to terms with this devastating loss, the book explores the bonds of sisterhood, how grief changes us and the ways that addiction manifests between generations.

Julia and Kathy unpack these central themes of grief, sisterhood and addiction, and delve into the book's exploration of motherhood. Why do some women choose, or not choose to have children, what happens when that choice is taken away, and how much do our own mothers shape us?

Shownotes

  • Blue Sisters is published by HarperCollins and is available at all good bookstores: https://www.harpercollins.com.au/9780008623012/blue-sisters/
  • CW: This episode covers themes of addiction, and reproductive health, and parts of this conversation may be distressing for some listeners. If this brings up anything for you, help is available by contacting the 24-hour national counselling service 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732. You can also contact the Alcohol Drug Information Service (ADIS) 24 hours a day, 7 days a week on 1800 250 015.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy) for more information.