cover of episode The future of legal representation

The future of legal representation

2025/4/4
logo of podcast The Future of Everything

The Future of Everything

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
N
Nora Freeman Angstrom
R
Russ Altman
Topics
@Russ Altman : 我关注到美国法院系统中存在严重的法律代理缺失问题,这影响了司法公平与效率。许多民事案件中,一方当事人缺乏律师代理,导致弱势群体在法律诉讼中处于不利地位,最终可能加剧社会不公。 @Nora Freeman Angstrom : 我长期研究法律伦理和司法改革,发现美国民事案件中,高达四分之三的案件至少有一方当事人缺乏律师代理。这并非源于当事人自愿选择,而是因为律师费用高昂且法律援助资源匮乏。这种现状导致了严重的司法不公,弱势群体难以维护自身合法权益,最终可能面临驱逐、房屋止赎、工资扣押等困境。法官在对抗性司法制度下,难以有效介入,只能被动地见证这种不公平的发生。 互联网上的法律信息良莠不齐,自诉者难以从中获取可靠的帮助。此外,法律援助机构的资源有限,无法满足所有需要帮助的人的需求。 目前,法律行业缺乏类似于医疗行业的护士从业人员那样的中级专业人员,无法提供价格合理的法律援助。在大多数州,非律师提供法律建议是违法的,这进一步限制了法律援助的可及性。 一些州正在探索允许经过培训的非律师提供法律服务,以扩大法律援助的可及性。这需要谨慎地设计监管框架,既要保证服务质量,又要避免过度监管,阻碍创新。 历史地看,美国法律体系并非一直如此。在20世纪初,银行、汽车俱乐部等机构曾雇佣律师为客户提供法律服务。然而,20世纪30年代的大萧条期间,律师行业为了应对经济压力和减少竞争,推动了限制非律师提供法律服务的政策。 人工智能技术在法律领域存在潜力,但目前其准确性和可靠性仍有待提高。法院可以利用其掌握的法律信息,开发和改进人工智能工具,以提升法律援助的质量和效率。

Deep Dive

Shownotes Transcript

Nora Freeman Engstrom is a professor of law who says that in three-quarters of cases one or more of the parties lacks legal representation. Worse yet, often the litigants are involved in high-consequence civil cases where there is no right to a lawyer and costs are prohibitive. Some states are looking at alternatives including non-lawyer representation, curated legal help for low-income citizens, and even AI, as Engstrom tells host Russ Altman on this episode of Stanford Engineering's The Future of Everything podcast.

Have a question for Russ? Send it our way in writing or via voice memo, and it might be featured on an upcoming episode. Please introduce yourself, let us know where you're listening from, and share your question. You can send questions to thefutureofeverything@stanford.edu.

Episode Reference Links:

Connect With Us:

Chapters:

(00:00:00) Introduction

Russ Altman introduces guest Nora Freeman Engstrom, a professor of law at Stanford University.

(00:03:11) Path to Justice Work

Nora’s journey into legal ethics and justice reform.

(00:04:46) Misconceptions About Civil Court

How civil cases often involve one represented and one unrepresented party.

(00:08:40) Limits of Judicial Help

Why the U.S. adversarial system limits judicial involvement.

(00:10:40) Problems with Self-Help

The lack of reliable resources for people trying to represent themselves.

(00:13:41) The Cost of Legal Help

The high cost of representation and how legal aid is overwhelmed.

(00:15:20) A Missing Middle

How law lacks mid-level professionals to offer affordable legal help.

(00:17:41) Expanding Legal Access

Why law lacks mid-level roles and bans non-lawyer advice.

(00:22:22) New Models for Legal Support

The ways some states are testing trained non-lawyers to expand access.

(00:27:22) Legal Help in the Past

The history of legal access, including lawyers in banks and auto clubs.

(00:30:29) Legal Protectionism

How depression-era protectionism led to today’s lawyer-only model

(00:32:48) The Role of AI in Legal Access

The potential of AI for creating smarter legal tools for courts.

(00:35:52) Conclusion

Connect With Us:

Episode Transcripts >>> The Future of Everything Website

Connect with Russ >>> Threads / Bluesky / Mastodon

Connect with School of Engineering >>>Twitter/X / Instagram / LinkedIn / Facebook