cover of episode Benito Mussolini Part 2: The March on Rome

Benito Mussolini Part 2: The March on Rome

2024/12/18
logo of podcast Real Dictators

Real Dictators

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
G
Giulia Albanese教授
H
Helen Roche教授
J
John Foote教授
J
Joshua Arthurs教授
L
Lisa Pine博士
N
Nicholas O’Shaughnessy教授
旁白
知名游戏《文明VII》的开场动画预告片旁白。
Topics
@旁白 : 本集讲述了穆索里尼在第一次世界大战中的经历,以及他在战后意大利动荡局势中崛起并最终通过罗马进军夺取政权的故事。从一名士兵到法西斯领袖,穆索里尼的个人经历和政治策略交织在一起,塑造了他独具特色的政治生涯。他的战争经历强化了他的爱国主义和民族主义情感,也让他深刻理解了社会底层的愤怒和不满。战后意大利的社会动荡、经济危机和政治混乱为法西斯主义的兴起提供了肥沃的土壤。穆索里尼巧妙地利用了民众对社会秩序的渴望和对左翼运动的恐惧,逐步壮大他的法西斯党,并通过暴力手段压制反对声音。罗马进军并非一场单纯的军事行动,更像是一场精心策划的政治剧,穆索里尼通过巧妙的策略和政治运作,最终迫使国王任命他为首相,从而合法地掌握了国家权力。 @John Foote教授 : 穆索里尼在1915年意大利参战的决定是其政治生涯中的一个关键转折点,虽然看似背叛,但却让他获得了权力和影响力。意大利的参战对协约国来说具有重要的战略意义,而穆索里尼作为战争的鼓吹者,也因此获得了政治资本。 @Nicholas O’Shaughnessy教授 : 穆索里尼擅长塑造个人形象和传播个人神话,他利用媒体和日记来构建一个充满魅力和英雄色彩的公众形象,这对于他赢得民众支持和巩固权力至关重要。 @Joshua Arthurs教授 : 战后意大利的社会动荡、经济危机和政治混乱为法西斯主义的兴起提供了土壤。民众对社会秩序的渴望和对左翼运动的恐惧,为穆索里尼的崛起创造了机会。 @Helen Roche教授 : 意大利南北部的经济差距和社会矛盾加剧了社会动荡,为法西斯主义的兴起提供了条件。 @Giulia Albanese教授 : 穆索里尼扩大了他的支持基础,吸引了那些担心社会动荡的商人和小业主。 @Lisa Pine博士 : 法西斯冲锋队对左翼组织的暴力袭击是法西斯主义崛起的重要因素,它有效地压制了左翼运动,为法西斯主义的扩张扫清了障碍。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did Mussolini's war end early?

Mussolini was wounded by shrapnel during a mortar demonstration in 1917, suffering over 40 pieces of metal in his body. This injury forced him to be evacuated and undergo multiple surgeries, ending his military service.

What role did Gabriele D'Annunzio play in the rise of fascism?

D'Annunzio, a maverick aristocrat and famous writer, formed his own private army and occupied Fiume, declaring it the Italian Regency of Carnaro. His use of black-shirted uniforms and Roman salutes inspired Mussolini, who later adopted similar tactics and symbolism for his fascist movement.

How did Mussolini's fascist movement gain momentum in post-war Italy?

Mussolini capitalized on the social and economic chaos in Italy, including mass unemployment, industrial unrest, and widespread dissatisfaction with the government. He positioned his fascists as the solution to restoring order, using violence and intimidation to suppress leftist movements and gain support from industrialists and landowners.

What was the significance of the March on Rome in 1922?

The March on Rome was a key moment in Mussolini's rise to power, showcasing the strength of his fascist movement. Although it was more of a political maneuver than a military coup, it forced the king to invite Mussolini to form a government, marking the beginning of his dictatorship.

Why did King Victor Emmanuel III allow Mussolini to become Prime Minister?

The king feared mass bloodshed and was unsure if the army would remain loyal. He also saw Mussolini as a way to quell the perceived threat of communism. By inviting Mussolini to form a government, the king hoped to avoid a civil war and maintain stability.

How did Mussolini's background as a journalist help his rise to power?

Mussolini used his skills as a journalist to craft a compelling narrative for fascism, simplifying complex ideas into catchy slogans. He also controlled his own newspaper, Il Popolo, which allowed him to shape public opinion and build his personal myth.

What was the impact of the Treaty of Versailles on Italian nationalism?

The Treaty of Versailles left many Italians feeling betrayed, as they believed they had been promised more territorial gains, particularly along the Dalmatian coast. This sense of betrayal fueled nationalist sentiment and resentment against the government, creating a fertile ground for Mussolini's fascist ideology.

How did Mussolini's fascist squads operate in Italy?

Mussolini's squads, known as squadristi, were paramilitary groups that used violence to target trade unions, socialist agitators, and leftist organizations. They often operated with the tacit approval of the government, which saw them as useful tools for suppressing labor unrest.

What was the significance of the black shirt uniform in the fascist movement?

The black shirt was a symbol of fascist allegiance, adopted from Gabriele D'Annunzio's private army. It represented unity, discipline, and strength, and became a recognizable marker of Mussolini's movement, distinguishing his followers from other political groups.

How did Mussolini's election to the Chamber of Deputies in 1921 impact his movement?

Mussolini's election to the Chamber of Deputies gave the fascist movement a formal political presence, allowing him to participate in parliamentary debates and negotiations. This marked a shift from purely violent tactics to a more institutionalized form of power.

Chapters
This chapter details Mussolini's participation in World War I, his injuries, and his subsequent return to Milan. It also covers the political climate in post-war Italy, the humiliation of the Treaty of Versailles, and the birth of the Fascist party.
  • Mussolini's war injury and its impact on his later narrative
  • The Treaty of Versailles and its impact on Italian nationalism
  • The founding of the Fascist party and its initial electoral failure

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever find yourself playing the budgeting game? Shifting a little money here, a little there, and hoping it all works out? Well, with the Name Your Price tool from Progressive, you can be a better budgeter and potentially lower your insurance bill too. You tell Progressive what you want to pay for car insurance, and they'll help you find options within your budget. Try

Try it today at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Price and coverage match limited by state law. Not available in all states. It's October the 30th, 1922. A Monday. We're in the Eternal City, Rome. On the concourse of the main train station, an excitable crowd has gathered. It spills out into the street. They're dressed in assorted paramilitary garb. But to a man, and they're all men, they wear a black shirt.

It's the symbol of their allegiance to a new party, a new cult: fascism. Stiff right arms are raised into the crisp autumn air. The old Roman salute: they are here to hail their Caesar. At 10:55 a train pulls in, the overnight sleeper from Milan. It should have been here at 9:30. Not even its VIP passenger could make this one run on time. It's been slowing at stations through the night, allowing the faithful to honor their hero.

For here, flesh and blood is their savior. The man who will put Italy to rights. The carriage door opens, and Benito Mussolini alights. A cry goes up, a chant. "Duce!" they yell. "Duce! Duce! Duce!" It will continue as Il Duce is swept outside. It will swell as he walks at their head towards the royal palace. Today's arrival marks the culmination of an event called the March on Rome.

From all corners of Italy, the fascists have descended. There are 40,000 in the capital today, perhaps 100,000. Some will claim a million, but the result is the same. Through a flexing of their muscles, the fascists have toppled the government, and the panicked king has summoned their boss. Il Duce is the only one now who can end the national crisis. Later, the two men appear together on the royal balcony to even more hysteria.

Mussolini can't stand the king. He refers to him as a dwarf, but the dwarf has made the godfather an offer he can't refuse. He is the new head of the Italy family. From the Noiser Network, this is part two of the Mussolini story. And this is Real Dictators. Let's go back, back to 1915, when we were last in the company of Mussolini. He was going off to fight in the First World War.

Having campaigned for Italy's involvement, he's swift to volunteer. Ironically, at first, he's rebuffed, told to wait. He has a history of political extremism, as well as being a jailbird. But in August 1915, his draft notice comes through. He is one of 1.2 million men rushed to the front. As a journalist of note, he's offered a desk job. He turns it down for the infantry.

Aged 32, Mussolini is old for combat, but he rejoins his former unit, the 11th Regiment of Bessalieri. Italy is a late entrant into the conflict. There were riots in the streets when it abandoned its stance of neutrality. Despite treaty obligations to Germany and Austria-Hungary, Italy has thrown in its lot with the Triple Entente, Britain, France, and Russia.

It was Mussolini, editor of Il Popolo newspaper, who had banged the war drums the loudest. This act of political heresy has seen him kicked out of his beloved socialist party. Professor John Foote: So the big betrayal is 1915. He doesn't really have a movement behind him, but he's fated because the powers that be wanted the war, particularly the king and the industrialists and certain parts of minority nationalist movement. For the Allies,

Italy's declaration of war on Austria-Hungary and later Germany is a strategic godsend. It can tie down the Austrians on their southern flank. It's dubbed the White War, fought high along the Alpine frontier. It will not capture the popular imagination, not in the same way as the Western Front. But the campaign is no less savage, a miserable frostbitten slog. Mussolini is a good soldier.

He's thrown into the battles of Izonzo in what is present-day Slovenia. Commended for his bravery, he's promoted to corporal. But on February 22nd, 1917, he's in a trench observing the demonstration of a new mortar when jagged shrapnel rips through the air. Five men are killed. Corporal Mussolini survives, but his body is riddled with over 40 bits of metal. He's stretched away. His war is over.

Professor Nicholas of Shaughnessy Mussolini, like Hitler, though so many parallels, was originally a draft dodger. But some kind of mortar bomb explodes in his trench. He's invalided out, so there's a long period of recuperation. Mussolini is evacuated to a military hospital at Ronchi. Over the next month, he will undergo a series of surgeries. He's visited by Margherita Sarfatti, the latest in his string of mistresses.

Notwithstanding the fact that on Christmas Day 1915, while on leave, he formally married Rachele. "He was so exhausted he could scarcely speak," writes Sarfatti. "His lips scarcely moved. One could see how horribly he had suffered." Sarfatti is an intellectual, an art critic, journalist, a fallen socialite, later to become Mussolini's official biographer. She's also a Jew. Such things are of no consequence in Italy at the present.

It will one day be a different story. Mussolini will use his convalescence to read and to think. He will later milk his wartime experiences, writing that he's proud, quote, to have reddened the road to Trieste with my own blood. My suffering was indescribable. I had 27 operations in one month. All except two were without anesthetics. Stories will circulate later as to whether he was ever wounded at all.

Did he have syphilis? There's a lot of reinvention in his diaries. He's very good at narrating something which perhaps didn't happen. The myth of Mussolini is a lot of it is invented by him and spread by him. He has his own daily newspaper, which, you know, he builds up his own myth. It's already being created very cleverly in that period. In August 1917, Mussolini is honorably discharged. He returns to Milan, hobbling on crutches.

not that he needs them anymore, into the offices of Il Popolo. He resumes his post as editor-in-chief of the newspaper. Italy throughout the war is plagued with inexperienced troops, poor command, and outdated equipment. A German surge in October 1917 will result in a catastrophic defeat for the Royal Italian Army at the Battle of Caporetto. In Rome, the government collapses. The country is on the brink.

But reinforced by British, French and now American units, Italy mounts a final push. Austria, the historic foe, is beaten. Italy has emerged on the winning side, but at a tremendous cost. Nearly three quarters of a million Italians have perished. There are a million men wounded, men like Benito Mussolini. Mussolini would still describe himself as a revolutionary, even a socialist.

But his war experiences have infused it with a sense of patriotism, of nationalism. It will soon be fueled by something else, a sense of grievance. It's June 28th, 1919, five years to the day after the assassination of Archduke Ferdinand. We're in the Grand Palace of Versailles, just west of Paris. In the spectacular Hall of Mirrors, delegations of the victorious powers assemble.

Their leaders are here to sign the document that will formally end hostilities, drawing a line under Armageddon. And while they're at it, redrawing the map of Europe. Italy is a victorious power. It stands alongside Britain, France, and New Kid on the Block, the United States. No Russia. It is engulfed in revolution. But, posing with Georges Clemenceau, David Lloyd George, and Woodrow Wilson,

Prime Minister Francesco Savelio Nitti can only smile through gritted teeth. Throughout the peace talks, it quickly became evident that these new friends regarded Italy as a junior partner. The Treaty of London which brought Italy into the war is not worth the paper it was written on. Germany's colonies have already been divvied up between Britain and France. Nitti's predecessor, Vittorio Orlando, had stormed out of the conference chamber.

In Europe too, Italy feels short-changed. There remains a huge bone of contention: the Dalmatian coast. For 400 years, the Adriatic seaboard had been part of the Republic of Venice. It remains studded with Italian communities. The deal was that it would get them back. Italy has been granted some territory in the Alps, South Tyrol, Trentino, and it has acquired Trieste, previously the domain of Austria.

But it has not been awarded the port of Fiume, modern-day Rijeka in Croatia. It lies just down the coast. Fiume, despite its 90% Italian population, has been placed under an international peacekeeping force. And it is soon to be transferred to a brand new country, the Kingdom of Yugoslavia. To the Italians, things are not how they were advertised. All in all, Italy has had a terrible war. We have one more act for you this evening.

I don't even need to say his name. Mr. Bob Dylan! From the director of Walk the Line and Ford vs. Ferrari. If anyone is going to hold your attention on stage, you have to kind of be a freak. And starring Timothee Chalamet as Bob Dylan. Are you a freak? Hope so. Inspired by the true story. I want to know which side he's on. This Christmas. They just want me singing Blowing in the Wind for the rest of my life.

Bobby, what do you want to be? Whatever it is, they don't want me to be. He defied everyone. Turn it down! Play it loud! To change everything. He's our Elvis. With no direction. Make some noise, BD. Track some mud on the carpet.

A Complete Unknown. Only in theaters Christmas Day. Rated R. Under $17.99 without parent.

Thanks to IP.

Learn more at phrma.org/ipworkswonders It's September 1919, on the shores of the Adriatic. We are standing on the ancient walls of Fiume. Through time they've seen off the Franks, the Ottomans, the French, the British. We're in the company of a man named Gabriele D'Annunzio. He is a snappy dresser, shaven-headed and with a trim, goatee beard. A maverick aristocrat who cuts a striking figure, or so he likes to think.

As a giant of Italian literature, a playwright and a poet, not to mention a playboy, he is the most famous writer in the land. And as for his sex life, Caligula would have blushed. Denunzio was a pioneer of aviation, well known for flying with the Wright brothers. He's earned celebrity status as an ace fighter pilot.

This makes people sit up and listen when he pledges himself an irredentist, one who believes Italy will not be fully whole till it reclaims its ethnic exclaves. With poetic flourish, he's coined the phrase. The Treaty of Versailles represents vittoria mutilata, a mutilated victory. His solution? He has formed his own private army from demobbed Arditi, Italy's crack troops.

D'Annunzio gets this rag-bag group of militia and this pre-ends the March on Rome in 1922. Fiume was contested territory. It becomes a symbol of being sold out, the mutilated victory, which is D'Annunzio's phrase. And he marches on Fiume, occupies it, and sets up this kind of tin-pot dictatorship. He declares it the Italian Regency of Carnaro, pledging it to the motherland. But the Italian government expresses unease.

preferring not to upset the international apple cart. And so, bizarrely, D'Annunzio declares war on Italy too. The administration in Rome dispatches warships to blockade the city. But Fiuma will survive the siege, and over the coming months it will become a haven for artists and radicals. A fantasy camp for revolutionaries. D'Annunzio will style his army as legionari, legionaries. He dresses them in black-shirted uniforms.

They hail him with a stiff-armed Roman salute. As their leader, he styles himself a "Duke, Duce." Benito Mussolini is furiously taking notes.

Denuncio was never a fascist, even though in so many ways he originated it. But his originality lies with the dramaturgy. He has this shriek, which he claims was the battle cry of Achilles. It's he who makes these great speeches from balconies. It's he who poses as the re-embodiment of Casanova, the greatest lover in history. Even

even though he was a kind of shriveled and ugly little man, and personified this romantic, martial, nationalistic spirit, this ethos, which Mussolini then just inherited. Danunzio will ultimately be evicted from Fiume, but he stands as proof as to what can be achieved by daring, rhetoric, and the application of bayonets.

You make the Italian people through war. Their blood will make Italy, right? And D'Annunzio is very much about blood making Italy. D'Annunzio goes around with these blood-soaked flags all the time that were wrapped around heroes who died on the battlefield. Events at Fiuma are indicative of the basket case that Italy is fast becoming.

It has been politically humiliated. Its economy has tanked. Its government is a revolving door of weak prime ministers and ineffective coalitions. It has had a generation of young men wiped out, with hundreds of thousands of civilians to follow, courtesy of the Spanish flu. In the wake of the Russian Revolution, the Italian left has become radicalized and emboldened.

Beyond mainstream socialism, communists and Bolsheviks dominate the powerful trade unions and local councils. A new strand, anarcho-syndicalism, has emerged. There is a push to reorganize society as Bolshevik-style Soviets. Joshua Arthurs is Associate Professor in the Department of Historical and Cultural Studies at the University of Toronto Scarborough.

To a significant degree, you have to understand the disorder of the post-war years. On the home front, Italians suffered terribly. There were extremely brutal conditions in the factories. There were food shortages, medicine shortages. And so, particularly in the wake of the Bolshevik Revolution, there was a general sense of unrest that exploded in both agrarian areas and in industrial areas. As will happen in Germany.

Nationalists feel cheated. They subscribe to the notion of a stab in the back. At the same time, you also had military veterans returning home, brutalized by their experiences at the front and angry at what they saw as a betrayal by Italy's political elites. And so you had this atmosphere of social breakdown and of a government that seemed incapable of reining it in.

Mass unemployment, industrial unrest, rampant inflation, soaring food prices. This newly constituted country is in danger of falling apart. Professor Helen Roche

I mean, since time immemorial, there had been this very stark difference between the North, which was in general much richer, more industrialised. But in the South, you have all of these immiserated peasants. You have so much illiteracy. You don't have, in some places, running water, let alone electricity or proper roads. It's really another world.

There are people out there who don't really even think of Italy as the nation. They're very centred on their little locality and what that means. To the Italian nationalists, the threat of Bolshevism is acute. Not too far away in southern Germany, a Bavarian Soviet republic has been declared. Over two days in July 1919, Italy's unions call a general strike in sympathy with the Russian revolution.

From the Fiat Machinists of Turin to the Olive Pickers in Calabria, the country succumbs to demos and occupations. The hammer and sickle flies over factory gates. It will mark the start of what will become known as the Bieniuroso, the two red years.

This is a period when it feels like revolution is going to happen any minute. There's strikes almost daily. There are revolts in some parts of Italy, people shot in the streets by the army. It's an incredible time. Occupations of the factories, production falling down, transport strikes on a daily basis. And yes, it does feel terrifying for many people. You know, are we going to become like Russia?

It's certainly true that in many of these uprisings, you have groups trying to emulate the Bolshevik example. That said, when we think about the two red years, we have to think about the perception of threat and disorder more than the genuine prospect of a proletarian revolution. To the nationalists, the very soul of Italy is now at stake.

So, you know, the idea that we can stop this, that we can bring order, you know, the terrible old cliche, which is often trotted out, make the trains run on time, right? Does have a basis in reality, because what that refers to is this chaos. After chaos must come order. A call goes out for someone to do what D'Annunzio did in Fiume, but on a national scale. In his newspaper, Mussolini eulogizes such a redeemer.

A man, he says, who is ruthless and energetic enough to make a clean sweep. And that person, he fancies, is himself. Mussolini may have been cast out by the Socialist Party, but he is building a popular following. He knows how to keep a message simple. He had appealed for Italy's entry into the Great War with the typical slogan: "Blood alone moves the wheels of history." And he has plenty more up his sleeve.

As a wounded veteran too, he is immediately relatable. He can look an old soldier in the eye. Many of them come out of that experience where they've been forced into a kind of camaraderie, a brutal camaraderie of blood. And Mussolini himself, you know, is part of that experience. He fights in the trenches, he gets wounded. He represents our other generation in post-war Italy. That anger, that violence coming out of that forced experience.

This is a phrase that Mussolini uses. Many of them have come to see themselves as a trenchocracy, as a new elite that is born of the experience of the war. So not only are they in dire circumstances, but they've been betrayed by their leaders. They are the true elect who should be leading Italy. In one of his editorials, Mussolini uses an obscure reference. He talks of the fasci of revolutionary action.

Fasci is an arcane term that harks back to ancient Rome. In the days of the Roman Republic, a consul would be accompanied by a ceremonial entourage, a team of priests called lictors. Each lictor would carry a bundle of birch rods, bound around an axe. The idea was that these symbolized the consul's power. They were the tools with which to discipline and punish. This bundle, the rods and the axe, has a name.

Fascius. Mussolini alights on this symbolism and adds to it. A birch rod in isolation is fragile, he says. It can be snapped. But, bundled together, the rods represent strength through unity. Power. Discipline. Strength. Unity. The cogs are whirring. It's March the 23rd, 1919, in Milan. We're in a smoke-filled hall in the Piazza Sansepolcro,

The ink has not yet been blotted at Versailles as Mussolini takes to the stage. It's a fringe meeting. Less than two hundred are present. They're the usual bunch of misfits. Disenchanted socialists, anarchists, would-be revolutionaries, some of whom had been arditi commandos. A good many, too, who are no strangers to a jail cell. Those present will go on to call themselves the Sansepolchristi, the disciples. Present at the creation.

the Mussolini will dub them something else. He declares the birth of a new political party: Fasci Italiani di Combattimento, the Italian Fasci of Combat, which makes them all, for short, fascists. On June 6th, in Il Popolo, he publishes the first fascist manifesto. It's full of radical, if half-baked, policies.

an 80% tax on war profits, the seizure of church property, abolition of the stock exchange. He is anti-monarchy, he's anti-Pope, anti just about everything. One of the things that's really striking about the creation of fascism is the fact that it feels like it happens in quite a haphazard way. I read that the original committee was just picked randomly out of people from the front of the meeting.

And a lot of scholars have talked about the fact that at the beginning, fascism is quite incoherent as an ideology. Mussolini's trying to appeal to so many different constituencies. But I also think that's one of the reasons why fascism could be quite alluring to many different types of people because they could pick out the bits that they liked. There's no dogma that you have to subscribe to.

Mussolini's critics ridicule him. But when the ruling liberal coalition starts to fragment, it presents a chance for Mussolini to put his money where his mouth is. Elections are scheduled for November 16th, 1919. The fasci Italiani are going to the polls. This is a new era for Italian democracy. Pre-war, the franchise had been limited to property-owning men. Parliament had been dominated by conservatives and liberals. Post-war, however,

The franchise has been extended to all adult males, though not yet women. It is about to upend the political order. In the Chamber of Deputies, the ruling liberals lose their majority, but for Mussolini it's a case of too much too soon. His new party fails to win a single seat, garnering just 4,000 votes.

You have the coming together of this, frankly, oddball coalition of groups, right? Military veterans and nationalists, alienated socialists, futurist artists. And they put together this manifesto, the founding manifesto, which is this real hodgepodge of ideas. They run on that platform and are completely wiped out. They don't even register on the electoral seismograph.

By contrast, 1.8 million ballots are cast for the victorious Socialist Party. Avanti, the newspaper Mussolini once edited, bestows the last rites on fascism. In Milan, an effigy of Mussolini in a coffin is carried to the streets and burned. Mussolini doesn't panic. The swing to the left he knows will cause further polarization in society. It will bring more people over to the fascist persuasion.

Sure enough, Mussolini is joined by two star recruits, two generals. They are Emilio de Bono, conqueror of Libya, and Cesare Maria de Vecchi, the governor and butcher of Somalia. The fascist movement is about to shoot off in a new paramilitary direction. Other key players will emerge. Italo Balbo, a young decorated war veteran, Michele Bianchi, the party general secretary,

Together they will become Mussolini's Quadrum Viri, his big four. There are two Dino Grandi and Roberto Farinacci, important players in the Mussolini story, but we will come to them in due course. Things are now about to move at an incredible pace, so quickly that Italy won't know what's hit it.

In June 1920, the centrist Nitti resigns and is replaced by a liberal prime minister, Giovanni Giolitti, returning for his fifth crack at the top job. Giolitti tries to placate the left, only for Italy to be gripped by further industrial paralysis and waves of violence. Professor Giulia Albanese...

Mussolini enlarges his constituency again.

He can now count on businessmen from industrialists to shopkeepers, people whose livelihoods are directly at stake.

Remember, Italy is to a degree a nation of small businesses or very small landowners. That's a huge part of Italian society. It's not some anonymous industrialized proletariat in the millions. It's not a race of serfs as Russia had been. The small independent peasant proprietor, the small shopkeeper, the small little restaurant owner, these are the Italians. And these are not the people who are going to go communist.

we start to see what fascism becomes. In the summer of 1920, they jettison the more radical elements of that original fascist coalition and they instead reposition themselves as allies of industrialists and landowners and as instruments for the repression of labor unrest.

This episode is brought to you by Shopify. Upgrade your business with Shopify, home of the number one checkout on the planet. ShopPay boosts conversions up to 50%, meaning fewer carts going abandoned and more sales going cha-ching. So if you're into growing your business, get a commerce platform that's ready to sell wherever your customers are. Visit Shopify.com to upgrade your selling today.

Freshly made ravioli or hand-pulled ramen noodles. When you dine with Chase Sapphire Reserve, either will be amazing because it's the choice between a front row seat at the chef's table while getting a live demo of how to make ravioli or dining family style as you hear the story behind your ramen broth. This weekend, it's ravioli.

Next weekend, ramen. Find the detail that moves you with immersive dining experiences from Sapphire Reserve. Chase, make more of what's yours. Learn more at chase.com slash sapphire reserve. Cards issued by JPMorgan Chase Bank and a member FDIC. Subject to credit approval. Mussolini will present his fascists as guardian angels. The ones who can keep the country functioning. Where there are transport strikes, his men will operate the trams. Where there are refuse walkouts, his men will sweep the streets.

Such things take organization, but with the movement packed with ex-military men now, this is no problem. They will form themselves into local units, squadristi, or action squads. Stealing from Denuncio, they will adopt as their uniform a black shirt and, of course, that Roman salute. Then there's that term, that one of leadership. Benito Mussolini has been called it before. It is not entirely original.

But, in another nod to Denuncio, he confirms it as his preferred title: "Il Duce".

And he emerges from this as the top journalist in Italy virtually, who has now got not only his own party, but also his own goon squad. In other words, exactly like in Germany, you have a huge residuum of unemployed soldiers who are very angry. Fascism has been described, not by me, I wish I'd thought of it as the socialism of the soldier. They present themselves almost like Boy Scouts.

The helpers of old ladies. But if there's one thing every squadrista knows, it's how to do violence. Tooled up with guns or wooden clubs, the infamous manganello, fascist hit squads, will target trade union and socialist agitators and pummel them into submission. They're squadristi. They're a kind of unofficial army. Obviously they're illegal. Obviously they should all be arrested, but they're not. And they begin to operate around the country. Dr. Lisa Pine,

Now these squads were made up of something like between 200 and 250 very well-armed individuals who by the end of 1920 were going around attacking and burning down socialist headquarters and newspaper offices, chambers of labor, many other left-wing printing presses and newspapers.

And the important thing here is that violence was absolutely crucial from the start. Fascism developed quite a following in rural areas to begin with. The fascist movement then was used by both agrarian landowners and industrialists to destroy the power of working class organizations.

Mussolini's strategy was to play a double game. On the one hand, to promise order. On the other hand, to foment disorder. To encourage squads to engage in political violence against leftists. And then to present the fascists as the only ones who could sort of turn on and off the tap of disorder. That they're both the solution and the cause. As it turns out, Prime Minister Giulietti finds this turn of events all rather convenient.

His government has got someone to do its dirty work, a freelance army of strikebreakers. The police seem quite happy to stand aside, to have the blackshirts break skulls on their behalf.

The reality in the end, particularly by the time Mussolini came to power, was perhaps that that red threat had actually passed. But nevertheless, this use of violence by the fascist squads really was very helpful to landowners and industrialists in trying to keep the communist threat quashed and quelled. And if the message is not getting through, they have a little trick up their sleeve. It's a signature of Varinacci's, the force feeding of castor oil.

The golden nectar of nausea, as he calls it. This household laxative can have a humiliating effect on a dissenter. The most respectable of opponents, once kidnapped and sourced, can be paraded in public while soiling themselves. If there's one thing inevitable in Italy, it's that a fresh round of elections is always around the corner, and the ones of May 1921 will be a completely different proposition.

Not only is Mussolini's popularity soaring, but the squadristi can be used to intimidate voters at the polling stations. This time, 35 fascists are elected to Italy's Chamber of Deputies. Out of 500 seats, they are still in a minority. But they now have a parliamentary voice, in opposition as part of Giolitti's anti-socialist bloc. One of those new deputies is Benito Mussolini.

At 37, he's got his foot in the door. I am obsessed by this wild desire, he writes. It consumes my whole being. I want to make a mark on my era with my will, like a lion with its claw. Mussolini presents himself as an exemplary deputy.

He dresses the part of really a 19th century politician at this point. He is a member of the Chamber of Deputies. He is in negotiations with other parties, including many that do not really align with fascism on many issues, but it's all part of a coalition building process. His anti-clerical stance is ditched for a sudden love of the church. His republicanism is replaced with a new fondness for the monarchy.

He even backs the 1920 Treaty of Rapallo, the international agreement whereby Italy renounces its claims to Dalmatia. But behind Mussolini the Gentleman, there is always Mussolini the Thug. Out there on the streets, his followers continue to do their stuff. In November 1921, he has another rebrand. Sufficiently emboldened, he ditches his liberal partners altogether. His movement will become, more simply,

the Partito Nazionale Fascista or PNF, the National Fascist Party. The membership now numbers 320,000 and is growing by the hour. In the summer of 1922, the Alliance of Labour, a conglomeration of trade unions, calls for another general strike. It will take place on August 1st. Faced with an entire national shutdown, Mussolini has a message for the powers that be.

If the government can't deal with the strikers, then he will do so himself. 1922 is about to become, as one historian puts it, the fascist year zero. In Ancona, Leghorn and Genoa, union officers are attacked and socialist HQs are stormed. Across the country the blackshirts rampage, burn and loot.

So the Italian Communist Party and the Italian Socialist Party, rather than standing up against fascism, were so involved in internecine conflicts and problems amongst themselves that they kind of didn't see early enough or react strongly enough to this fascist threat coming and effectively didn't put up any resistance.

The fascists had a huge advantage on this. They were thugs, but as ex-soldiers, they were used to inflicting violence, you see. I mean, if you've just been a trade unionist all your life, the fistfights and all the rest of it, it doesn't come so natural to you. As it would be to a soldier who's been out there in the trenches, who's made bayonet charges, you know, who's busily stabbed, shot the enemy.

In late July, thousands of blackshirts descend on Ravenna, Forli, Cesena, in Bari and Ancona. Red strongholds. The communists flee. In Ferrara, Bologna and elsewhere, the squadristi are now in control of the town councils. In mighty Milan, where there are pitched street battles, the presses of Avanti are smashed to bits, the building razed to the ground.

Black shirts now occupy the town hall, across the street from La Scala Opera House. Many were starting to look at Italy as a country on the edge of a civil war, which wasn't in reality a civil war, because, as you know, in order to have a civil war, we need to have two actors fighting one with another. And what the fascists demonstrate with their violence was the fact that the Socialist Party wasn't really able to answer with violence

In the battle of black versus red, it's a virtual walkover. In large parts of the country, Mussolini is now running an effective shadow state, and he's not going to stop there. In the capital, shell-shocked, life carries on, and the prime ministers keep tumbling. After Giolitti had come the brief tenure of Ivano Bonomi, Italy is now in the hands of a new centre-right prime minister, Luigi Facta.

A man who devotes more time to combing his lustrous moustache, it seems, than governing the country. It's October 24th, 1922, 4:30pm. We're in Naples, the Piazza San Carlo. Sixty thousand baying black shirts are here for the Fascist National Conference. Fascism now seems an unstoppable force, an immovable object. On stage, Mussolini, bathed in the glow of sunset, performs in broad theatrical gestures.

He's costumed as a black shirt himself now. Before an array of microphones, he nods, he grimaces, he scoffs. He has a new move. He rubs his palm down over his face before adopting a pose, legs astride, arms folded. Then he nods his head knowingly, acknowledgement of his own self-evident truths. And one of them is this: that the old liberal state is dead.

It has, he says, fulfilled its functions. Either the government will be given to us, or we will seize it by marching on Rome. A new chant goes up this time. Not "Duce," but "Roma." Roma, Roma, Roma. That night at the Hotel Vesuvio, Team Musso goes into a huddle. With the threat now issued, they cannot back down.

At the very least, a mass demonstration of fascist strength in Rome is called for. It'll focus the minds in the Italian parliament. On November the 4th, National Victory Day, there has already been a big military parade scheduled to proceed through the center of Rome. It's been set up by the new government in an attempt to steal some of the fascist thunder. They've even roped in Gabriele D'Annunzio as chief cheerleader. Mussolini will not allow himself to be upstaged by anybody. Plus,

With the Red threat now effectively quashed, fascism is losing its purpose. In this situation, Mussolini was very conscious of the fact that this was an exceptional moment which wouldn't last forever, and he needed to seize the good moment in order to gain power. Carpe diem. Seize the day. Should they move on Rome, the General Confederation of Italian Industries assured him of its support.

The US ambassador has even tipped him a wink. Power grab by Mussolini would come as significant international blessing. His big four, de Bono and de Vecchi, Balbo and Bianchi, must go straight to Perugia in central Italy. From this strategic location they can coordinate an advance on the capital and other actions. The marchers will converge at muster points within range of Rome. Everyone must be in position by the night of the 27th, three days' time.

The move must be synchronized with the seizure of national nerve centers, town halls, railway stations, telephone exchanges. General de Weck is anxious. They have numbers, Duce, yes. But firepower? Should the army be called out to defend the capital, they would be completely outgunned. Clubs are no match for cannon. But Mussolini issues a wry grin. He knows it'll never come to that.

Just get the men in position, he assures. Fate will do the rest. Next morning, Mussolini poses for photographs for the Neapolitan marches. He will not take part personally. He is heading back up to his base in Milan. Privately, he has an escape route planned to Switzerland, should the whole thing go belly up. The exact purpose of the march on Rome remains hotly debated. A spontaneous demonstration? Or a serious attempt at a coup?

A genuine armed threat or a bluff?

I think we can view it as theater. We can also view it as a giant game of chicken where both sides are hurtling towards one another and who's going to swerve out of the way first. And it's a gamble by Mussolini. There is every opportunity for the king to order the army to step in to repress them. The fascists, even in some instances where they had clashed with the army, were easily defeated.

In Cremona, where fighting does take place, Farinacci is shot and wounded.

I have a different interpretation which is that actually the March on Rome is a very serious political project. It was backed by this mass violence over two, three years so it's not something that comes out of nowhere. The Italian state had more or less collapsed by 1922. Squadristi are invading entire parts of Italy, occupying them as an army. So the state has essentially either lost control or ceded control to an alternative army.

In fascist legend, the march will be mythologized as columns of smiling black shirts, yumping peacefully through villages to be strewn with flowers. In reality, it's somewhat different. But of course, in the events, only around 20,000 marched. They were poorly armed, lacking provisions, and more or less waiting some miles outside of Rome from orders from Mussolini, which never came.

Those that do pitch up on Rome's outskirts are a sorry sight, deluged by the storms that are lashing the country. They will reach their assembly points a bedraggled, starving rabble. But Prime Minister Factor is taking no chances. He declares a state of siege. The army is marshaled to defend the capital. Key buildings are sandbagged, ringed with barbed wire. At the first shot fired, a loyal general assures Factor, fascism will totally collapse.

The Subaru Share the Love event is a fulfilling way to get in a great vehicle and support a great cause. When you buy or lease a new Subaru from now until January 2nd, Subaru and its retailers will donate a minimum of $300 to charity. By the end of this year's event, Subaru will have donated nearly $320 million to charity. Visit Subaru.com slash share to support a great cause today.

Imagine a world-class graduate education that's accessible, flexible, and designed for career impact. That's Harvard Extension School. Build actionable knowledge and skills in challenging online classes taught by Harvard faculty and industry experts. Explore new opportunities and expand your network with high-achieving professionals from around the world. Part-time learning. Real-world impact. This is Harvard on your terms. Learn more at extension.harvard.edu.

Milan. It's 8pm on the night of Friday, October 27th. We're in the Teatro Manzoni for a performance of Ferenc Molinar's play The Swan. The show, as they say, must go on. Mussolini sits in a box with his mistress, Margherita Sarfatti, taking approving nods from well-wishers. Afterwards, he returns to the offices of Il Popolo. Armed blackshirts have turned the building into a fortress. They've used bundles of newspapers to form a barricade.

which is now being squelched into papier-mâché by the incessant rain. Ever since Naples, the phone has been ringing off the hook from officials in Rome, from his confederates in Perugia. There have been visits from industrialists, journalists, friends, all wondering what the hell is going to happen next. All he can tell them is that his black shirts are in position, ready to move in. It's the morning of the 28th, in the Quirinale Palace in Rome.

The Prime Minister Luigi Factor stands before the King, Victor Emmanuel III. Both men look tired. The current crisis has caused the King to rush back from his holiday. Factor, meanwhile, has been locked in an all-night cabinet meeting. His lustrous moustache is beginning to droop. "The only way to stop Mussolini now," Factor explains, "is to upgrade the current emergency status to full-on martial law. Let the army be proactive in dealing with this national insurrection."

His Majesty, head of state, as well as head of the armed forces, just needs to put his signature to the order. A civil servant brandishing a leather folder steps forward. Victor Emmanuel sighs. He's hesitant. He walks to the window and gazes out. What he is about to tell his prime minister is absolutely the last thing Fracta will want to hear. "He has been thinking long and hard," the king explains. "He fears mass bloodshed.

As such, he cannot comply. Plus, though he doesn't voice it, he's not entirely convinced his army won't go over to Mussolini. "The only way to end this episode," insists His Majesty, "is to offer the fascists a stake in government." Factor splutters an objection, but the King raises a hand. He will abdicate right there on the spot should his Prime Minister not respect his wishes. A shocked Factor leaves.

Within the hour he will have penned his resignation. And this is a fundamental moment because from this moment on Mussolini understands that he won. Back in Milan, Mussolini prepares for the inevitable. He is swamped by a deluge of proposals. But Il Duce keeps his cool. He now holds all the cards. Next day, the 29th, mid-morning, and the phone rings yet again.

This time the call comes direct from the Quirinalli Palace. Mussolini has been invited for a special audience with his majesty. It can mean only one thing. Mussolini replies, insouciantly, that he wants the invitation in writing. Thirty minutes later there is the sound of a motorbike. Ilduce looks out. There, racing across the glistening cobbles, is a dispatch rider. A conversation at the front door is followed by the scurry of footsteps up the stairs.

An excited black shirt bursts in, brandishing a telegram. "Very urgent. Top priority. Mussolini, Milan," it reads. "H.M. King asks you to proceed immediately to Rome as he wishes to offer you the responsibility of forming a ministry. Benito Mussolini is being invited to become Prime Minister."

The king, through a combination, I think, of opportunism and personal weakness and cowardice even, is the one who flinches in the end and leaves the coast clear for the blackshirts to march into Rome. And I think really calculating that the Bolshevik threat as he saw it was always going to be greater than the fascist threat. Had they attempted to take Rome by force, the Roman garrison could have stopped them.

But in the event, of course, no force was needed. And of course, the really, really important point about this then is that Mussolini's accession to power was not inevitable. So he could have been stopped.

What options did the king have? It's often said, oh, they just needed to put the army out there, it would have been all over in five minutes. I totally don't agree with that. This is a serious set of people. They've been in the trenches, they're not a joke. And, you know, it would have been civil war. I mean, kind of, you've got civil war already. Mussolini smiles. Not in his wildest dreams did he imagine that it would be this easy. There'll be a train waiting for him at 3pm, he's told. The king has sent it.

He can be in Rome tonight. But Mussolini is in no rush. He wants to write tomorrow's headlines. He'll catch the later one at 8.30. The king appoints the head of the insurrection prime minister, which is an extraordinary thing to do in many ways. It is a legal seizure of power backed by an illegal series of events. So it's a very bizarre moment. So he is prime minister on the back of marching with an illegal army. It's kind of a coup, kind of isn't.

It's 11:45 on the morning of October 30th. We're in the Quirinale Palace again. Benito Mussolini enters. He cuts a strange figure. He's squeezed himself into a too-tight civilian suit. He's thrown it over his black shirt to add a veneer of respectability when meeting his majesty. On his head sits a bowler hat. Over garish yellow shoes are a pair of white spats. He bought them on a trip to the French Riviera. He looks like a chimp at a tea party.

Amid the Rococo splendor and the gold leaf finery, Mussolini apologizes to the king for his unconventional attire. "I come from the battlefield," he quips. Not so long ago, Benito Mussolini was a vagrant, a convict. Just 18 months earlier, he wasn't even an elected politician. And now, he is the brand new leader of the nation. The Duce of Fascism is now the Duce of Italy.

The liberal elites, the king, think, "Oh, well, he won't last long. They don't take him seriously enough. We can control him. He's done the dirty work for us. He's killed all the socialists. Great. But that's a terrible mistake because he will soon turn on them. The liberals will start to get killed and the Catholics. He turns on anybody and ruthlessly destroys anybody who opposes him." The day after Mussolini's appointment, October 31st, there will be a huge fascist victory parade.

Styled after a Roman triumph, the columns of Squadristi would take six hours to pass.

Among the things that Mussolini and the king discuss, there is also the fact that the squadristi will be able to enter the capital. They will be able to enter and do a huge demonstration in the center of the town as if they were a victorious army coming back from the war. And the king will wait for them and greet them.

This is, I think, the chef d'oeuvre of Mussolini because he not only managed to be called as head of the government, but he also managed to legitimize his violent and private army as if it was an official army.

From this moment on, I think that the dictatorship starts because, in a way, all the parameter of liberal democracy has already been defeated or has already been changed at the symbolic level, which is a fundamental level for power. Mussolini reflects. Perhaps he should have entered Rome on a white horse. No one has mentioned it, but it is, coincidentally, Halloween.

In the next episode, world leaders line up to hail the new Italian strongman. With his public works and economic reforms, Il Duce is a big hit. But Mussolini will dismantle democracy and kill off the opposition, quite literally. The cult of fascism will soon spawn a dictatorship. That's next time. The Mussolini story will resume after a short break over the festive period.

From your fryer to the table, it's a quick trip for crispy fries. But how about a Crosstown delivery? McCain Sure Crisp Fries are designed to go from fryer to container to carrier to passenger seat across town during rush hour down a shortcut that wasn't all that short to a doorstep before they hit the table. And that first bite, the crispiness speaks for itself.

To the last bite. McCain's Sure Crisp Fries. Go the distance. See how far our fries can take your business at surecrisp.com slash delivery.

This holiday season, surprise everyone on your list with the best gifts. Tickets to see their favorite artists live. Choose from thousands of concerts and comedy shows, including Mariah Carey, Mary J. Blige, Matt Matthews, Metallica, Thomas Rhett, Trans-Siberian Orchestra, Sarah Silverman, and so many more. Share a memory together.

or give a gift they'll never forget. Find the most exciting gift for every fan at LiveNation.com slash gifts. That's LiveNation.com slash gifts.