cover of episode The Parasitic Ideas Threatening the West

The Parasitic Ideas Threatening the West

2024/10/24
logo of podcast Honestly with Bari Weiss

Honestly with Bari Weiss

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
B
Bari Weiss
G
Gad Saad
Topics
Gad Saad: 我在黎巴嫩的成长经历让我深刻理解了身份政治、部落主义和非自由主义的极端后果。作为一名移民,我亲身经历了缺乏言论自由、思想自由、理性以及真正自由主义的社会,这让我对西方社会目前面临的文化和政治风险有着独特的理解。许多捍卫西方理想的最杰出人物都是移民,例如Ayaan Hirsi Ali、Salman Rushdie和Masih Alinejad,这并非巧合。 目睹黎巴嫩内战让我对身份政治、部落主义和非自由主义的极端有了深刻的了解。我认为,像我这样的移民,因为在没有西方自由价值观的社会中生活过,所以更能理解西方目前面临的文化和政治风险。 我目前在美国担任客座教授和全球大使,但我无法忍受回到康考迪亚大学的可能性,因为该大学的反犹太主义猖獗。所有这一切都构成另一场战争:一场针对西方逻辑、科学、常识和现实的运动,这在我的著作《寄生思想:有害思想如何扼杀常识》中有所阐述。 Bari Weiss: Gad Saad 的经历以及他离开康考迪亚大学的决定,突显了西方社会中逻辑、科学、常识和现实正遭受攻击的现状。许多人对西方社会的消极看法,无论其政治立场如何,都反映了这种普遍的焦虑情绪。

Deep Dive

Chapters
Gad Saad, born into a Jewish family in Lebanon, witnessed the country's descent into civil war. This experience shaped his perspective on identity politics, tribalism, and the importance of Western values.
  • Saad's family was one of the last Jewish families in Lebanon.
  • He witnessed antisemitism from a young age.
  • The Lebanese Civil War was a crash course in identity politics for Saad.
  • He believes immigrants who have lived without Western freedoms uniquely understand their value.

Shownotes Transcript

Gad Saad was born in Beirut in 1964 into one of the last Jewish families to remain in Lebanon. But the country that was once called “the Paris of the Middle East” began to turn.

Saad remembers one day at school when a fellow student told his class that he wanted to be a “Jew-killer” when he grew up. The rest of the kids laughed. By 1975, Lebanon descended into a brutal civil war and Saad said death awaited him at every millisecond of the day.

Even through the danger and turmoil, his family thought, This will pass over. We will be fine. Until someone showed up to their home in Lebanon to kill them, at which point his family fled the country and rebuilt their life in Canada.

In 2024, many of us in Western democracies find ourselves saying the exact same things: This will pass over. We will be fine. Even as Hamas flags and “I love Hezbollah” posters wave in cosmopolitan capitals across the West. How worried should we be? And, is there a way to roll back admiration for anti-civilizational groups? Those are just some of the questions we were eager to put to Saad in today’s conversation.

Saad said that witnessing the Lebanese Civil War gave him a crash course in the extremes of identity politics, tribalism, and illiberalism. He argues that immigrants like himself, who have lived without the virtues of the West—freedom of speech and thought, reason, and true liberalism—uniquely understand what’s at stake right now in Western cultural and political life. It’s no coincidence, Saad said, that the most prominent defenders of Western ideals are immigrants, people like Ayaan Hirsi Ali), Salman Rushdie), and Masih Alinejad).

Saad is a professor of marketing and evolutionary behavioral sciences, and if you’re on X, we suspect you know his name. Unlike most professors, he has a million followers, and a knack for satire—so much so that Elon Musk seems to be one of his biggest fans. 

Outside of his X personality, he’s been teaching at Concordia University in Montreal for the past 30 years. But he’s now having second thoughts. Concordia is today widely regarded as the most antisemitic university in North America. Saad is now a visiting professor and global ambassador at Northwood University in Michigan. He said he can’t bear the possibility of returning to Concordia given the antisemitism on campus.

All of this, he argued, constitutes another war: a campaign against logic, science, common sense, and reality here in the West, which he explains in his book: The Parasitic Mind: How Infectious Ideas Are Killing Common Sense

Today, Bari Weiss asks one of the most insightful and provocative thinkers about the risks of mob rule and extremism on the left, where these “parasitic ideas” came from and why they’re encouraged in the West, if progressive illiberalism is waxing or waning, and if these trends are reversible.

And if you liked what you heard from Honestly, the best way to support us is to go to TheFP.com) and become a Free Press subscriber today.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices)