cover of episode A Tim Walz Face-Off: Radical? Moderate? We Debate!

A Tim Walz Face-Off: Radical? Moderate? We Debate!

2024/8/8
logo of podcast Honestly with Bari Weiss

Honestly with Bari Weiss

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
B
Barry Weiss
一位专注于健康素养和患者-医生沟通的家庭医学教授和研究者。
B
Batya Ungar-Sargon
J
Joe Nocera
P
Peter Savodnik
Topics
Barry Weiss: 本期节目讨论了蒂姆·沃尔兹的政治形象,以及卡玛拉·哈里斯选择他作为竞选伙伴的原因。沃尔兹的形象存在两面性:一方面是亲切友好的中西部人,另一方面则是激进的进步主义者。他的政策在疫情期间和社会议题上引发了争议。 Joe Nocera: 沃尔兹是一位能够吸引工薪阶层白人、农村居民和其他民主党传统上忽视的选民的自由派民主党人。他的部分政策虽然是自由主义或进步主义的,但也很受民众欢迎。例如,他支持工会,这并非激进政策,而是符合美国利益的政策。在新冠疫情期间,他的政策是跟风行为,并非出于个人信念。 Batya Ungar-Sargon: 沃尔兹的公众形象与其政策之间存在巨大差距。他的部分政策,例如跨性别医疗、非法移民政策和新冠疫情期间的政策,引发了争议。美国政治中存在“氛围与政策”之间的脱节现象,这在共和党和民主党候选人身上都有体现。那些经济条件较好的人更倾向于根据“氛围”而非政策来投票。 Peter Savodnik: 选择沃尔兹是为了平衡拜登政府的精英形象。沃尔兹是一个顺应党派和文化潮流的民主党官员。他的沟通方式更具体、更接地气,不像卡玛拉·哈里斯那样含糊不清。他的“奇怪”说法巧妙地表达了对某些政治人物的不信任感。

Deep Dive

Chapters
The episode begins with a discussion on Tim Walz's sudden rise in prominence and the contrasting views of him as either a moderate Midwesterner or a radical leftist, based on his policies and background.

Shownotes Transcript

A few weeks ago, very few people outside of the Beltway and niche media circles had ever heard the name Tim Walz. Almost overnight, the relatively obscure governor from Minnesota started to gain traction thanks to a viral clip where he called J.D. Vance “weird.”

It resonated with a lot of people. He came across as direct, plainspoken, and affable. And on Tuesday, August 6, Vice President Kamala Harris officially announced him as her running mate. 

The conventional wisdom was that Harris would pick a moderate Democrat. But is Walz a true moderate? Because if you go online, there is a split screen reality about who Tim Walz actually is.

On one side: Midwestern nice guy Democrat who grew up in a small town in Nebraska, is a National Guard vet, was a high school teacher, a football coach, a congressman, governor, and to top it all off, a gun owner and a hunter. Policy-wise, he’s worked with Republicans to pass infrastructure investments. He cut taxes for working families. He passed a law to provide paid family and medical leave to Minnesota families.

But on the other side: he’s as radical as radical progressives come. Here are some policies cited to support that argument: during the pandemic, Walz set up a phone line) so Minnesotans could report their neighbors for violating Covid rules. He allowed) Minnesota’s health department to ration lifesaving Covid drugs based on race. Walz made Minnesota a “trans refuge state,” signing a law) that allows the state to take custody of a child whose parents refuse “gender-affirming care.” He also established a council to implement DEI training in statewide agencies. And after George Floyd’s murder, he said): “My administration will use every tool at our disposal to deconstruct generations of systemic racism in Minnesota.” This, as the city was burning.

Then, there is the secondary story of Tim Walz, which is not about Tim Walz at all.

Until Tuesday, Pennsylvania’s Josh Shapiro appeared to be the frontrunner as a charismatic, handsome, and moderate governor from a key battleground state the Democrats need to win. Why didn’t Kamala choose Shapiro? Did anti-semitism play a role?

To explain all of this are three of my favorite writers and thinkers: Free Press contributor Batya Ungar-Sargon, Free Press senior editor Peter Savodnik, and Free Press columnist Joe Nocera (or, as he likes to be called, our in-house-liberal). Suffice it to say, they all have very different opinions on Walz.

Today: Who is Tim Walz? Why did Kamala Harris land on him? What does this choice say about the state of the Democratic Party? And in the race toward the White House, does it even matter?

If you liked what you heard from Honestly, the best way to support us is to go to TheFP.com/subscribe) and become a Free Press subscriber today.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices)