cover of episode 3 Unsolved Disappearances That Defy Explanation

3 Unsolved Disappearances That Defy Explanation

2024/11/11
logo of podcast Malevolent Mischief: True Stories of Horror

Malevolent Mischief: True Stories of Horror

Key Insights

Why did the Sodder family suspect foul play in the disappearance of their children?

The Sodder family found several suspicious details after the fire, including a cut telephone line, a mysterious rubber-like object in the yard, and the disappearance of their ladder, all suggesting a carefully orchestrated plot.

What were the key unsettling details in the disappearance of Bryce LaSpisa?

Bryce's erratic behavior during the drive, his ominous message to his girlfriend, and the discovery of his overturned car with no sign of him, leaving his wallet, phone, and keys untouched.

How did the discovery of Jared Atadero's clothing complicate the investigation?

The clothing was found in pristine condition, despite being exposed to the elements for years, and Jared's pants were inside out, raising questions about whether the items had been moved or tampered with.

What was the most plausible theory for Bryce LaSpisa's disappearance?

Investigators believe Bryce, likely in a disoriented or distressed state, wandered into the rugged wilderness surrounding Castaic Lake after leaving his crashed car, possibly succumbing to the elements or an injury.

What evidence suggested that the Sodder children might have been abducted?

The lack of any remains in the fire, the cut telephone line, and the mysterious disappearance of the family ladder led the Sodders to suspect that their children were taken by someone.

Why did the discovery of Jared Atadero's bones not provide closure?

The bones were scattered and limited, offering no clear cause of death, and the condition of the clothing found with them was inconsistent with typical exposure to the wilderness, leaving many questions unanswered.

Chapters

The Sodder family's home in Fayetteville, West Virginia, was engulfed in flames on Christmas Eve, 1945, leading to the mysterious disappearance of five children. The case is filled with strange details and chilling clues that suggest foul play.
  • The house fire was so intense that it was impossible to reach the children's bedrooms.
  • The family ladder was missing, and George's trucks mysteriously refused to start.
  • The fire chief suggested the blaze was hot enough to incinerate the bodies, but no remains were found.
  • Disturbing details, like the cut telephone line and a strange rubber-like object, hinted at foul play.

Shownotes Transcript

The search for truth never ends. Introducing June's Journey, a hidden object mobile game with a captivating story. Connect with friends, explore the roaring 20s, and enjoy thrilling activities and challenges while supporting environmental causes.

After seven years, the adventure continues with our immersive travels feature. Explore distant cultures and engage in exciting experiences. There's always something new to discover. Are you ready? Download June's Journey now on Android or iOS. Most weight loss plans are one size fits all, not taking into account each person's individual needs.

Noom is here to change that. Noom Weight uses psychology. That's why they say, "Losing weight starts with your brain, but it also takes into account your unique biological factors, which also affect weight loss success." The program helps you understand the science behind your eating choices and why you have cravings. Everyone's journey is different, so your daily lessons are personalized to you and your goals.

One of the great things about Noom is that it's nourishing instead of restrictive. They focus on progress instead of perfection. You don't have to give up carbs or anything for that matter. Have cravings? Food FOMO? Noom can help you lose weight while still enjoying your favorite foods. To date, Noom has helped more than 5.2 million people lose weight.

Stay focused on what's important to you. With Noom's psychology and biology-based approach, sign up for your trial today at Noom.com. That's N-O-O-M dot com. Imagine it's Christmas Eve, 1945. Snow is falling outside and a family of 12 is tucked away in their warm house in the small town of Fayetteville, West Virginia. Ten children have hung their stockings, waiting for morning, while George and Jenny saw her.

Italian immigrants watch over their big family. They've built a good life here in America, far from the turmoil in Europe. But on this night, a nightmare begins that will haunt them for the rest of their lives and leave a mystery that remains unsolved to this day. At around 1 a.m., Jenny Sauter wakes up to the smell of smoke. Frantic, she rushes to her husband, George, and together they realize that their home is engulfed in flames. The blaze has already spread to the stairway,

making it impossible to reach the children's bedrooms upstairs. In the chaos, George and Jenny manage to get four of their children to safety, but five remain inside: Maurice, Martha, Louis, Jenny, and Betty. George's immediate instinct is to rush back inside, but the stairs are impassable. Thinking fast, he runs around the outside of the house to grab his ladder and climb up to the children's windows.

But the ladder, one which always sits by the side of the house, is missing. Desperate, George tries to pull his truck up to the house to climb on it, but inexplicably, neither of his trucks will start, despite having worked perfectly the day before. It's as if the fire, and perhaps something else, has conspired to keep him from saving his children. Neighbors begin to gather, watching in horror as flames consume the house. Calls are made to the fire department.

But it takes them over an hour to arrive, supposedly because of holiday staffing issues. By the time firefighters are on the scene, it's too late. The house has been reduced to ashes. When the fire finally dies down, George and Jenny are left with nothing but the rubble of their once warm home. With heavy hearts, they search for any sign of their missing children's remains. But as the hours pass, something chilling becomes clear. There is no trace of them.

Not a single bone, not a fragment, nothing to indicate that five children perished in the fire. The fire chief suggests that the blaze was hot enough to completely incinerate the bodies, but local experts disagree. Even in fires of extreme temperatures, bones and other remains are usually found. This lack of evidence doesn't sit right with the Sodders, and it isn't long before they begin to suspect something darker. In the days following the fire,

disturbing details begin to surface, transforming the Sauter family's tragedy into a mystery that hinted at foul play. One of the first unsettling discoveries was the cut telephone line. Around midnight on Christmas Eve, Jenny Sauter received a strange phone call from a woman asking for someone she didn't know. Laughter and background noise made it sound like a party, and Jenny dismissed it as a prank. But after the fire, a repairman on the scene confirmed that the line hadn't burned,

it had been intentionally cut. This raised an alarming question: had someone intentionally disconnected their line in order to prevent them from calling for help? George later found a strange rubber-like object in the yard, which experts later suggested could have been an incendiary device. Jenny remembered hearing a thud on the roof and a rolling sound before the fire, which she hadn't thought much of at the time. But with the discovery of this object, she wondered if someone had thrown it to ignite their home.

The mysterious disappearance of the family ladder was another unsettling detail. George always kept the ladder propped up outside the house for emergencies. Yet, when he needed to reach the children's windows, it was gone. They later found it down an embankment, far from the house. George's trucks, both of which had been working the day before, also mysteriously refused to start that night, preventing him from using them to reach the windows. In the days after the fire, locals reported eerie sightings.

A woman claimed to have seen the missing children peering out from a passing car as the solder house burned. In a nearby town, a hotel worker reported serving breakfast to four children matching their descriptions, who were accompanied by two men and two women. When the staff attempted to speak to the children, the adults quickly intervened, speaking in Italian before abruptly leaving. Over the years, similar reports continued, with people claiming to see the solder children in distant parts of the country.

Each time, the Sodders investigated, only to be met with disappointment and dead ends. Finally, in 1968, Jenny received a mysterious envelope from Kentucky. Inside was a photograph of a young man who closely resembled their missing son, Louis, with a message on the back that read, "Louis Sodder. I love brother Frankie. Ill ill boys." The Sodders hired a private investigator to trace the photo's origin, but then the investigator vanished without a trace.

leaving the family with more questions. Each of these details, bizarre in isolation, together formed a haunting picture of a night that seemed far more sinister than just a tragic fire. They suggested a carefully orchestrated plot, a chilling possibility that left the Sodders and the town with questions that remain unanswered to this day. For the rest of their lives, George and Jenny Sodder never stopped searching,

They poured every bit of their energy and savings into finding their missing children, putting up billboards, following every reported sighting, and offering rewards to anyone with information. Even as the years went by, their unwavering hope remained, a silent testament to their enduring love and relentless pursuit of the truth. The haunting image of their five missing children stayed with them, an unsolved question that overshadowed every holiday and every family gathering.

Their case, decades later, remains one of the most unsettling mysteries in American history, filled with strange details, eerie sightings, and chilling clues that point to something more than a tragic accident. What really happened to the Sodder children that Christmas Eve? Could someone out there still hold the answers? Will this mystery ever be solved? Let me know what you think down in the comments.

The disappearance of the Sauter children left us with chilling questions and decades of speculation. And while some mysteries grow cold with time, others unravel in the unlikeliest of moments. This next story takes us to a more recent mystery, one that left both investigators and loved ones searching for answers as the evidence defied logic itself. This is the mysterious disappearance of Bryce LaSpisa. Imagine someone you love is on a road trip home,

A journey meant to bring them back safely, but somewhere along the way, their behavior becomes erratic, their movements inexplicable, and then, without warning, they vanish, leaving only a trail of strange actions and unsettling evidence. This is what happened to Bryce LaSpisa, a college student whose disappearance still defies explanation. In August of 2013, Bryce LaSpisa was starting his second year at Sierra College in Rockland, California.

At 19 years old, Bryce had a warm personality, a creative streak, and a close relationship with his family. He seemed eager to return to campus life, ready to catch up with friends and jump back into his art studies. But within days of the semester beginning, his behavior shifted. Bryce, who was usually even-tempered and easygoing, began acting strangely. Friends noticed he was drinking heavily, much more than they'd ever seen him drink before, and his girlfriend Kim grew increasingly concerned.

Bryce started distancing himself from her, even giving away his personal belongings without any explanation. Kim reached out to Bryce's parents, Karen and Michael Wispisa, who quickly sensed something was wrong. They tried to reassure him, but nothing seemed to change his behavior. Then, on August 28th, Bryce told his mother he was driving back home to Laguna Niguel, several hours away. His parents were relieved, thinking he just needed time with his family. But as Bryce made his way south,

his behavior grew even stranger, leaving a trail of unsettling clues that would leave investigators baffled. Bryce's drive from college back to Laguna Niguel should have taken around seven hours, but it quickly became clear that his trip wasn't going as planned. Instead of driving straight home, Bryce made repeated stops in small towns along the way, his mother worried but still trying to give him space, kept in touch through frequent calls.

At one point, Bryce stopped in Buttonwillow, a small town about halfway to his destination, and he sat there for hours with no clear reason. Growing anxious, his parents eventually called a roadside assistance service, hoping they could check on him. A technician found Bryce still sitting in his car, seeming lost and distant, yet insisting he was fine and would be on his way soon. Bryce then drove a short distance before stopping again.

lingering in the area for nearly 13 hours without explanation. This back and forth behavior left his parents confused and alarmed. Yet, every time they tried to intervene, Bryce reassured them that he was fine. But then, Bryce's behavior took a darker turn. He called his girlfriend Kim and left her an ominous message. Amidst the rambling, he included the sentence, you'll be better off without me. The message hinted at an internal struggle that no one,

not his friends, family, or even Kim fully understood. When his mother Karen offered to come pick him up, Bryce declined, insisting that he'd soon continue the drive. When finally around 3 a.m., he left Buttonwillow for the last time, telling his parents he was on his way home. Bryce's final known actions only added to the mystery. Sometime during the early morning hours, he was spotted by a highway patrol officer near Castaic Lake.

Far off the direct route to Laguna Niguel, the officer conducted a quick check, noting that Bryce appeared fine, if a bit disoriented. After assuring his mother that he would see her soon, Bryce continued along his way, yet he would never make it home. Hours later, Bryce's car was discovered overturned near Castaic Lake. The vehicle had apparently sped down an embankment before crashing, yet when authorities inspected the scene, there was no sign of Bryce himself. It was as if

He had simply vanished. What made the scene even stranger was the evidence left behind. Bryce's wallet, his phone, and laptop were all found in the car untouched. His keys were nearby, yet there was no blood, no clear signs of injury, and no footprints leading away from the wreck. The absence of any sign of Bryce left investigators at a loss. Castaic Lake and the surrounding area were thoroughly searched, but no trace of him was found.

For days, search parties combed through the rough terrain, but Bryce seemed to have disappeared without leaving any clues to follow. The discovery of Bryce's abandoned belongings only deepened the mystery. Leaving his phone, wallet, and keys behind didn't make any sense. If he'd walked away from the crash, why not take anything with him? If he'd suffered an injury, surely there would be some physical evidence. Investigators questioned friends and family,

trying to determine if Bryce's behavior hinted at deeper mental health issues, or if he had been planning to disappear intentionally. Friends noted that his sudden shift in personality had been disturbing. He had started drinking heavily in a short period, and his actions had grown erratic. While some suggested Bryce might have been experiencing a mental health crisis, others couldn't accept that he'd simply walk away without a word. One theory was that Bryce was under intense emotional or psychological pressure.

possibly experiencing a break from reality. But Bryce had no history of such behavior, making it hard to imagine him reaching such an extreme without warning. Others speculated he may have wanted to start over somewhere new, though it seemed unlikely he would abandon his family, especially given their close bond. Theories ranged from Bryce planning his own disappearance to the possibility that he met with foul play. Every clue seemed to add to the confusion rather than lead to an answer. His actions during the drive

The long stops, the repeated refusals for help, and the final phone call seem to hint at an intention, but what that was remains unknown. The most widely accepted theory is that Bryce, likely in a disoriented or distressed state, wandered into the rugged wilderness surrounding Castaic Lake after leaving his crashed car. Investigators believe he may have been confused or impaired, causing him to leave his essentials behind and walk aimlessly into the hills.

The terrain near the lake is rocky and challenging, making it easy to get lost, especially in the dark. Though extensive searches have found no sign of him, the possibility that Bryce succumbed to the elements, or an injury in this isolated area, remains the most plausible theory among experts. Bryce LaSpeece's family continues to search for answers, holding onto hope that he may still be out there somewhere. Every year that passes only deepens the mystery.

leaving loved ones and investigators haunted by the inexplicable details of his final hours. Bryce's sudden shift in behavior, his eerie parting message to his girlfriend, and the deliberate stops on his drive have raised unsettling questions about what was truly going through his mind. To this day, Bryce's disappearance remains one of the most perplexing cases in recent years, a story of a young man whose journey home took a dark and twisted turn.

From the missing hours in Buttonwillow to the overturned car and deserted crash site, every detail of Bryce's story defies easy explanation. The trail that he left behind feels more like fragments of a puzzle that refuses to come together, leaving his family and all who hear his story wondering if the mystery will ever truly be solved. Hey guys, as the days are getting cooler, I've been slowly transforming my wardrobe for fall, and Quince has become my secret weapon.

Honestly, nothing says fall better than a soft, cozy sweater. That's why I'm loving Quince's Mongolian cashmere sweaters. They start at just 50 bucks, which is an incredible deal for cashmere. But Quince doesn't stop there. They've got beautiful leather jackets, cotton cardigans, ultra soft denim, and more. All priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. How? By partnering directly with top factories and skipping the middleman.

Meaning, we get the savings directly. And knowing Quince is committed to safe, ethical, and sustainable manufacturing just makes every piece feel that much better. So whether you're refreshing your fall wardrobe or just grabbing some essentials, Quince makes it easy to stay stylish, warm, and totally guilt-free. I just got one of Quince's ultra cozy cashmere sweaters for myself, and it's every bit as luxurious as it sounds.

The softness and warmth are on par with high-end brands, but at only $50? It's a steal compared to typical prices. Compared to other luxury cashmere I've tried, this sweater holds its own in both style and quality. It's incredibly well-made and perfect for layering as the weather cools down. Affordable cashmere? Yes, please. If you want luxe, cozy essentials without breaking the bank, Quince has totally nailed it.

Get Cozy and Quince's high-quality wardrobe essentials. Go to quince.com slash mischief for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. That's q-u-i-n-c-e dot com slash mischief to get free shipping and 365-day returns. quince.com slash mischief A big thanks to our friends over at Peloton for sponsoring this episode.

I've been using Peloton for a while now, and I've got to tell you, it's not just a workout. It's my workout. Whether I've got 20 minutes for a quick power ride, or an hour to really push myself, there's always a class that fits my day, and with a lineup of instructors who know exactly how to keep me motivated. It's like having a personal coach whenever I need that extra push. And we've got to talk about that leaderboard, because the rivalry is real.

I love seeing my friends up there in real time, pushing me to hit that next climb. The chatter between us is all about who's going to finish on top. And those bragging rights? Priceless. Plus, the instructors make it even better. They're next level. We're talking about professional fitness instructors, college athletes, record breakers. Every time I clip in, I know I'm going to get that support that only they can provide.

And here's the best part. Peloton's got workouts for every mood. Some mornings, I'm all about that sunrise ride. And other days, it's a late night course to unwind. No matter when or how I want to move, they've got me covered. So find your push. Find your power with Peloton at onepeloton.com. From the mysterious disappearance of Bryce LaSpisa, we turn now to a different type of unsolved mystery.

a case of a child who vanished in the wilderness in 1999. Despite the passage of time, the circumstances of his disappearance have only grown stranger. This is the story of Jared Atadero. In October of 1999, three-year-old Jared Atadero joined a group of family friends for a hike in Colorado's Roosevelt National Forest. It was meant to be an exciting day outdoors, filled with exploration and fresh mountain air. But only a few hours into the trip,

Jared would vanish without a trace, disappearing into the dense forest in an instant. Search efforts involving hundreds of volunteers scoured the wilderness, but no trace of Jared was found. For years, his family was left with no answers, until a shocking discovery in 2003 raised disturbing questions about what had happened in the forest that day. However, these new findings would only stoke the flame of mystery.

Jared Atadero's father, Alan, owned a lodge near the Poudre River in Colorado, where he raised Jared and his sister in a close-knit community of friends and nature lovers. On October 2, 1999, a group of family friends planned to hike Big South Trail in Roosevelt National Forest, a trail known for its beautiful but rugged terrain. Alan, trusting the adults, allowed Jared to go along, assuming the group would keep a close eye on him.

It was a decision that would weigh on him heavily in the years that followed. The group set off in the morning, with Jared tagging along, excited to be part of the adventure. As they made their way along the trail, Jared began to run ahead, thrilled by the sights and sounds of the forest. Some hikers reported that he was chasing after a couple walking ahead on the trail, but within minutes, he was out of sight. The adults quickly realized he was gone and began to search frantically, despite combing the area for any sign of the young boy.

Jared seemed to have vanished into thin air. The group notified Allen, and as soon as they could, search and rescue teams arrived to assist. What followed was one of the most extensive searches the area had ever seen. The response to Jared's disappearance was swift and large-scale, with more than 200 volunteers, search and rescue teams, and bloodhounds covering the rugged terrain around Big South Trail. The area was challenging, with steep, rocky cliffs, dense forest,

and fast-flowing rivers cutting through the landscape. Rescuers worked around the clock, braving worsening weather conditions as rain began to fall, making the trails even more treacherous. Temperatures dropped sharply, further complicating the search effort and increasing concerns about Jared's survival. Despite their efforts, searchers found no trace of Jared. The trail he was last seen on yielded nothing. No footprints, no pieces of clothing, no clues to indicate where he might have gone.

Bloodhounds trained to pick up even faint scents were brought in but failed to find any trail, as if Jared had been swallowed up by the forest around him. Experts familiar with search and rescue efforts were baffled. Normally, some sign, however small, would emerge in cases like this. Even nearby rivers and creeks were searched for any sign that Jared might have fallen in, but these searches came up empty. The fact that searches turned up nothing led to speculation running rampant.

Some theorized that Jared might have been taken by a predator, though no claw marks or blood were found on the trail. Others wondered if he had simply wandered far off, but the forest's dense terrain would have made it difficult for him to get far in such a short amount of time. The days stretched into weeks as hope began to wane. Jared's family was left devastated with only haunting questions and a deepening sense of tragedy. Years passed without any word of Jared until 2003,

when two hikers made an unsettling discovery not far from the Big South Trail. As they walked, they stumbled upon pieces of children's clothing scattered in an area dense with underbrush. Among the items found were a pair of small child-sized shoes, a fleece jacket, and a pair of pants. Alan Atadero, Jared's father, later confirmed that these were indeed Jared's clothes, but the condition of the items only served to confuse him as well as investigators.

Jared's shoes, oddly enough, looked almost new, despite four years in the elements. They showed little wear or damage, a puzzling detail given the rough terrain and extreme weather conditions. Even more perplexing was the fleece jacket, which, while faded, was still largely intact. However, Jared's pants were discovered turned inside out, a detail that struck everyone as strange. Why would a child's pants be inside out?

And how had the clothing remained so well-preserved after years in a remote wilderness? This reappearance of Jared's belongings raised more questions than it answered. Had his clothing somehow been moved over time? And if so, by what? Or by whom? Theories quickly circulated, but no one could explain why the clothing looked relatively untouched. Some speculated that the items might not have been exposed to the wilderness the entire time, leading to the unsettling idea

that Jared's clothing may have been placed there more recently. Nearby, searchers eventually uncovered a few small bone fragments, later confirmed through DNA testing, to belong to Jared. The bones were scattered, which experts attributed to possible animal activity. However, there were no major bones found, no skull, no larger bones that might offer insights into what caused his death.

The limited skeletal remains didn't yield many answers, and no cause of death could be determined. The condition of the bones and the state of the clothing led to conflicting theories. Some argued that a mountain lion or another predator might have taken Jared, yet the condition of the clothing didn't match typical animal activity. Normally, an animal attack would leave clear evidence, such as bites, claw marks, torn clothing, or bloodstains, none of which were found.

Additionally, the pristine condition of the shoes made this theory seem even more unlikely. Others believed that Jared might have been abducted and that his remains and clothing were returned to the area at a later time. This disturbing theory gained traction due to the unusual condition of the clothing and the inexplicably preserved shoes, which seemed incompatible with years of exposure in harsh wilderness.

The idea that human involvement was behind Jared's disappearance haunted his family and added an eerie element to the case, though no suspects were ever identified and no evidence of abduction was ever found. For Alan Otterdaro, the discovery of his son's remains brought painful closure, but left him with an overwhelming number of questions. The strange condition of Jared's belongings, the lack of any concrete cause of death,

and the eerie circumstances around the clothing and bones all troubled him deeply. He expressed doubts that his son's disappearance was an accident, and remained vocal about his suspicions, calling for further investigation and attention to the unsolved aspects of the case. The Atadero family's tragic experience became a public story, shining a light on the mystery and dangers of wilderness disappearances. Alan continued to speak out,

hoping to keep Jared's memory alive while advocating for greater safety measures in national parks and forests. But for him and those who have followed the case, Jared's disappearance remains a haunting enigma, one with no clear explanation, only fragments of a story that refuses to be fully told. The case of Jared Atadero is one of the most haunting child disappearances in modern memory, from the suddenness of his vanishing to the reappearance of clues years later

Every detail raises questions that go unanswered. Did Jared fall victim to a tragic accident in the wilderness? Or was there something more sinister afoot? Though many theories abound, the mystery of Jared's fate is one that may never be fully explained. His story remains a chilling reminder of the unknowns that exist, even in places we think we know well, and a symbol of the unfathomable mysteries that sometimes remain locked away in the depths of the wilderness.

Thanks for joining us for today's dive into some of the world's most perplexing mysteries. We appreciate all of you out there, and it's your curiosity and interest that keeps us going. If you'd like to support our work and help us uncover more stories like these, consider checking out our Patreon. You can find us at patreon.com slash malevolentmischief. Every bit of support truly helps, and it allows us to continue putting out more content that you enjoy. Thanks again, and I hope to see you on the next one.

If you have Medicare and Medicaid, then keep listening. You may qualify for a dual special needs plan from UnitedHealthcare. It's time you feel confident you're managing your whole health. With a dual special needs plan from UnitedHealthcare, it's not just health insurance, it's healthy living. You deserve coverage you can count on, so why not see how a dual special needs plan from UnitedHealthcare may help you get extra Medicare benefits. If you live in the D.C. area, see your options today at UHCDualPlans.com.