cover of episode What Democrats Think Went Wrong

What Democrats Think Went Wrong

2024/11/21
logo of podcast The Run-Up

The Run-Up

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
A
Astead Herndon
A
Astead Herndon的家人朋友 (Focus Group成员)
Topics
Astead Herndon:本文探讨了民主党在2024年大选中失利的原因,并通过对普通民众的访谈,深入了解了选民的观点和不满。文章回顾了2013年共和党对大选失利的反思,并指出民主党也需要进行类似的反思,不能仅仅依赖于内部人士的观点。文章还分析了种族多样性对政治格局的影响,以及民主党未能有效应对选民对经济、移民等问题的关切。 Astead Herndon的家人朋友 (Focus Group成员):访谈中,参与者从多个角度分析了卡马拉·哈里斯竞选失利的原因,包括美国社会对女性总统的接受度、竞选时间不足、未能与拜登区分开来、缺乏独特的竞选主张以及未能有效回应选民对经济、移民等问题的关切。他们认为,特朗普的成功在于其抓住了选民对政府不满的情绪,并迎合了选民的个人主义倾向。此外,他们还讨论了不同族裔群体之间的政治分歧,以及民主党在某些政策上的立场过于偏左,导致部分传统支持者流失。他们认为民主党需要进行自我反省,关注民生问题,而不是过度关注文化议题。 Astead Herndon的家人朋友 (Focus Group成员):针对2028年大选,参与者们认为民主党候选人应优先关注经济、教育、医疗和种族平等等问题,并避免过度关注LGBTQ议题。他们还讨论了理想候选人的特质,以及民主党需要如何改进其策略,以更好地回应选民的诉求。部分参与者认为,为了赢得选举,民主党候选人应该选择一位白人男性,因为在当前的政治环境下,白人男性候选人更有可能击败特朗普。他们还强调了候选人应该年轻、有魄力、敢于改革,并展现出自信和果断的领导力。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did Trump win the 2024 election according to the focus group?

The focus group cited several reasons including the country's readiness for a female president, time constraints, lack of a distinct message from Kamala Harris, and Trump's popularity and ability to tap into dissatisfaction with the government.

What did the focus group suggest as key issues for the Democratic Party to address in future elections?

The focus group emphasized the need for the Democratic Party to focus on the economy, particularly for the lower and middle classes, as well as issues like criminal justice, education, health care, and racial inequalities. They also suggested a new approach to discussing immigration.

Why did the focus group feel that the Democratic Party's message didn't resonate in 2024?

The focus group felt that the Democratic Party's message didn't resonate because it failed to address everyday issues like immigration, inflation, and the economy effectively. They also criticized the party for not separating itself from Joe Biden and for not being a change agent.

What demographic shift did the focus group observe that contributed to Trump's victory?

The focus group observed a shift where Hispanic and Latino voters, as well as some immigrant communities, felt that their concerns about immigration and legal status were not being addressed by the Democratic Party, leading them to support Trump.

How did the focus group view the role of racism and sexism in the 2024 election results?

The focus group acknowledged the role of racism and sexism but also emphasized the need for the Democratic Party to hold itself accountable for its messaging and policies. They felt that before addressing external biases, the party needed to look inward.

What did the focus group suggest as the ideal profile for the next Democratic candidate?

The focus group suggested that the next Democratic candidate should be a younger, aggressive, and assertive white man who can address key issues like the economy, criminal justice, and health care. They also emphasized the need for a candidate who can bring substantial reform and rebuild the party's coalition.

Why did the focus group feel that the Democratic Party needed to change its approach to certain issues?

The focus group felt that the Democratic Party needed to change its approach to issues like immigration and LGBTQ rights because their current messaging was polarizing and not resonating with key voter groups. They suggested a more strategic and less woke approach.

How did the focus group view the future of democracy under a Trump administration?

The focus group viewed the future of democracy under a Trump administration as potentially dark, with concerns about the dismantling of democratic institutions and the potential for more radical actions. They felt that the next Democratic candidate should focus on strengthening checks and balances.

What was the focus group's reaction to the lack of mass activism after the 2024 election?

The focus group felt that the lack of mass activism was due to people becoming more self-focused and resigned to the political system's flaws. They observed a shift towards community-focused activism rather than large-scale protests.

Why did the focus group feel that the Democratic Party needed to re-evaluate its approach to black voters?

The focus group felt that the Democratic Party needed to re-evaluate its approach to black voters because it had not fully addressed their concerns or provided tangible benefits. They suggested that the party needed to come to black communities with a genuine understanding of their needs.

Chapters
The chapter examines the political assumptions that led to Donald Trump's first win and how the Democrats are now conducting their own autopsy to understand their defeat in 2024.
  • Demographic destiny was a key assumption in 2013, but it didn't benefit Democrats as expected.
  • Democrats are now in disarray and are conducting their own autopsy to understand their defeat.

Shownotes Transcript

A year ago, Astead took “The Run-Up” listeners home) for Thanksgiving.

Specifically, he convened a focus group of family and friends to talk about the election and the question of Black people’s changing relationship to the Democratic Party.

This year, he got the group back together for a different mission.

The question was: What happened? What can Democrats learn from their defeat in 2024?

On today’s show: an autopsy conducted not by consultants or elected officials but by committed, everyday Democratic voters. And a farewell.

Unlock full access to New York Times podcasts and explore everything from politics to pop culture. Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts) or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.