243. The Cosplay Killer
Murder With My Husband
Deep Dive
Why did Melissa Turner's story about the murder of Matthew Trussler raise suspicion?
Melissa's story was inconsistent and implausible, including her claim of being asleep through a violent struggle and having injuries that she couldn't explain coherently.
What evidence suggested that Matthew Trussler's death was not a suicide?
The medical examiner found a stab wound in Matthew's back, which they concluded he could not have inflicted on himself, along with multiple lacerations and defensive wounds.
How did the neighbor's security camera footage impact the investigation?
The footage captured sounds of a violent argument and a woman screaming at Matthew to die, which contradicted Melissa's claim of being asleep and provided evidence of her involvement.
What did Matthew's family and friends reveal about Melissa Turner's behavior?
They described Melissa as controlling and aggressive, particularly when Matthew was intoxicated, and suggested she isolated him from his support network.
How did the prosecution attempt to discredit Melissa Turner's self-defense claim?
They presented evidence that Melissa had no head injury despite her claim of being hit, and showed footage of her calmly returning to the scene of the fight after leaving it.
What was the final verdict in the trial of Melissa Turner?
Melissa Turner was found guilty of second-degree murder and sentenced to 20 and a half years in prison.
- Matthew Trussler moved to Florida from Massachusetts.
- He met Melissa Turner on Tinder and they became engaged.
- Melissa found Matthew's lifeless body outside their home and called the police.
Shownotes Transcript