175. Irene Garza - The Church Murder Cover Up
43:42 Share

All right, you guys, we are jumping into an ad and I wanted to let you know that listening on Audible helps your imagination soar. Whether you listen to stories, motivation, expert advice, any genre you love, you can be inspired to imagine new worlds, new possibilities, and new ways of thinking.

Listening can lead to positive change in your mood, your habits, and ultimately your overall well-being. Audible has the best selection of audiobooks without exception, along with popular podcasts and exclusive Audible Originals. All-in-one, easy app.

app. Enjoy Audible anytime while doing other things, household chores, exercising, on the road, commuting, you name it. Audible makes it easy to be inspired and entertained as part of your everyday routine without needing to set aside extra time. You guys, since becoming an Audible member, I've found it so easy to fit more stories into my day. Recently, I've actually been listening to Twilight on audiobook and it's been a game changer during my daily walks.

So there's more to imagine when you listen. New members can try Audible now for free for 30 days with your first audiobook included. Visit audible.com slash MWMH or text MWMH to 500-500. That's audible.com slash MWMH or text MWMH to 500-500 to try Audible free for 30 days.

All right. Probably not expecting me to start this ad, but I'm going to start this ad. The Skims ad. And let me tell you about something that Peyton's been wearing. The Skims soft loungewear is amazing. Feels great.

- Payne wears it, she looks great, she feels great. - Okay, it has completely transformed my lounge wear game. I love everything I own from Skims, you guys know this, so does my husband, especially my new pieces from the Soft Lounge Collection. And I kid you not, you guys, it is soft. It is the softest fabric.

It makes me feel both confident and comfortable. And it's not just lounge wear. It's actually the first thing I reach for no matter what my plans are for the day. And my favorite piece is the soft lounge tank paired with the fold over pant. You guys, I have tried every ribbed tank on the market. Nothing beats this one. And it looks so adorable.

with the pants set. It is like just the most comfortable go-to outfit and the soft lounge sleep set. I have two of them and it is like sleeping on a cloud. It feels good. You feel put together at the end of the night. You guys, it is lightweight, comfortable, and stylish. I live in it. Also, if you're thinking about getting it for your significant other, just do it. They'll love it.

Shop the Skims Soft Lounge Collection at Skims.com. Now available in sizes extra, extra small to 4X. And if you haven't yet, guys, be sure to let them know that we sent you. So when you go to checkout, please don't skip this step. After you place your order, select Murder With My Husband in the survey and select our show. The drop-down menu that follows, it's a great way to support the show. It lets them know we sent you. Again, you guys, go get Skims.

soft lounge from Skims. The entire collection is so good. And then let them know Murder With My Husband sent you. Okay, we love you. Bye. Hey everybody, welcome back to our podcast. This is Murder With My Husband. I'm Peyton Moreland. And I'm Garrett Moreland. And he's the husband. And I'm the husband.

Okay, I think I'm having like out-of-body experiences every time I say it now. Like you just autopilot? Maybe it's just time to change the intro. How's everyone feel? Did I just give everyone a panic attack? Never do that. Was this like the consistency they needed? Reminder, if you want ad-free content, no ads, and just to hear my voice and Peyton's wonderful voice, then you can subscribe on Apple or on Patreon.

And you will get ad-free and bonus-free content. And that's for all of Oh No Media, so you get access to Binged and Rise and Crime as well. For those on Apple, there was some ads recently on a couple of episodes that is fixed now. We're sorry about that. Sometimes there are some glitches, but we are good to go. We're just a baby. What's up, Furmingan?

It's a meme, right? Or a TikTok? I'm just a baby. I'm just a baby, yeah. I'm just a baby. Okay, before we get into Garrett's 10 seconds, I'd like to say something I was thinking about last night when I was having anxiety and couldn't sleep. I think I would like to start a petition to have my own 10 seconds. Okay.

I think my voice is valuable and I think that I have things I could say. I'll tell you what, babe. We can start. We can give you a 10 seconds when I'm the one telling stories or when I'm the one telling episodes. That'll never happen. I guess there's an answer to your question then, huh? I just, I have stuff I want to talk about that's not murder sometimes. I agree with it. Maybe we need to do another podcast and just, you know, riff the raft with each other.

Okay, whatever. Going to Garrett's 10 seconds. Not sure if anyone would listen to a Rift Raff podcast with Peyton and I, but you never know. All right, my wonderful, extraordinary, perfect, very exciting 10 seconds. I thought you were going to say wife. Oh, is that I'm going to get a haircut after we record this episode? Oh, yeah. My hair's not very long, but, you know, just going to go clean it up a little bit.

Also, Peyton and I may or may not be going to a Taylor Swift concert next week. Yep. Party next week. Isn't that crazy? Yeah. So we will update everyone on that. Also would like to say, sometimes I wonder if the world is trying to kill me. And I know that was kind of abrupt. But what I mean by that is every time, I swear, every time we were driving, something crazy happens to me. Am I right? Yeah.

Well, not something crazy. It's just you almost die. That's pretty crazy. That's pretty insane. I just mean like a car cuts you off or like. And I swear it's not my fault. Like people just merge right into me. People try to hit me. It just happens to me. And maybe at some point I need to internalize a little bit. Maybe it is my fault. But I swear every time we're driving, I'm always on the defensive.

Well, you did get run off the road. Yeah, it's, yeah. Anyways, luckily I'm a good driver. We're still alive. Everything's okay. But I don't know, maybe the CIA, maybe someone's behind it. Why would they want you gone? Maybe someone doesn't like the podcast. Wait, are we just going to like not talk about the UFO thing? Like they literally said they found aliens. Okay, well, we can't make this intro too long, so we'll have to talk about it.

on another episode. I'm telling you, we need to start a riff-raff podcast. Like, that, I just feel like that's right up our alley, but also like, do you believe it? Maybe we'll do a bonus episode for everybody just on all the alien stuff.

I don't know if I got that much to say. Okay. Well, we'll think about it and maybe we'll do an episode on that. Okay. Our case sources are 48 hours, CNN.com, Texas Monthly, McAllen Chamber of Commerce, CBS News, the Sydney Morning Herald, Courthouse News Service, My San Antonio, The Washington Post, My New York City Genealogy, BishopAccountability.org, and Phoenix News Times. So for many people in America, going to church is a major cornerstone of their lives because

It offers them a sense of community, a feeling of belonging, assuredness, and most of all, a feeling of safety. This was especially true in small towns in the South, particularly back in the 1950s and 60s. But what happens when your safe place, your church, is infiltrated by a predator?

Even worse, what happens when the hierarchy of that church works to protect the predator, leading to a cover-up that allows a case to run cold for decades. Today's story begins in the small town of McAllen, Texas, on the southernmost tip of the state, right on the border of Mexico.

Nowadays, it's a busier area as it's the third largest border crossing in Texas. But back in the 1960s, when our story takes place, McAllen was still a small town where the white population and the growing Hispanic population didn't always mix well. For example...

The town's one public swimming pool was off-limits to the Hispanic people living in McAllen, who were instead forced to spend the scorching summers dipping in the town's irrigation canals. This was the world Irene Garza knew and grew up in. It was also the world she'd come to love deeply. Irene herself was part of this growing Hispanic population in McAllen.

But Irene also broke a lot of barriers, particularly at McAllen High School. There, she became the school's first Hispanic twirler and head drum majorette. When Irene was 15, her parents' dry cleaning business had seen so much success that they were actually able to move to a more affluent neighborhood in McAllen.

one north of the train tracks where other Hispanic doctors, lawyers, and businessmen lived with their families. Irene also became the first woman in her family to attend college, where her popularity continued to skyrocket. At Pan American College, Irene was crowned homecoming queen. Then in 1958, the 24-year-old won the Miss All-South Texas Sweetheart Contest, which was practically unheard of at the time for a Mexican-American woman.

After she graduated from school, Irene continued to live with her parents in their new neighborhood in McAllen, Texas. But she decided to return to her old neighborhood below the tracks for work. She taught second grade at the elementary school there and even used her first paycheck to help buy her students school supplies, clothes and books.

Plus, she'd been nominated as the secretary of the Parent Teachers Association, which was about to be a huge challenge for Irene. She wrote to a friend in early April 1960 saying, quote, this might not sound like much, but to me it means a great deal. It means I'm overcoming my terrible shyness and becoming sure of myself.

So while Irene's been doing all of these pageants and campaigning for homecoming queen, it seems she does have some insecurities she's been hiding, like any young woman her age who's still trying to find herself. But in that same letter, Irene also spoke about her old fear of death and told her friend she thought she might be cured. She said she'd been going to communion and mass daily, and it was giving her immense courage and faith. I

Irene wrote she was happier than she'd ever been before. So two weeks after Irene penned that letter, it's Easter weekend. On the Holy Saturday, April 16th, 1960, the church is packed with people from all over McAllen looking to cleanse their souls through confession. At around 6.30 p.m. that night, Irene asks if she can borrow the family car to go do the same. She tells her mother she won't be long and makes the 12-block drive over to the Sacred Heart Church in McAllen.

Now, Irene is not someone people miss. She's strikingly beautiful, elegant even, and catches the eye of nearly everyone as soon as she walks into the church that night. There are rumors that some of the young men in town go to church just to spot a glimpse of Irene. I mean, she's this beauty pageant. She's beautiful. So you know she's something special. Some take notice that night of her making the sign of the cross as she enters the church.

Then she takes some time to herself, kneeling and praying in the fifth row of pews. Next, she gets in line for confession, pulling a white veil down over her face. She even lets one parishioner cut in front of her because they're running late for the next event. While many people noticed Irene inside the church, no one reports seeing Irene exit or go out to the parking lot after her confession.

Now it's starting to get late and back home, Irene's parents wonder why her quick trip to church is taking her so long. At first, they imagine maybe she'd stayed for the Easter vigil mass that's happening later that evening. But when Irene doesn't return home by 3 a.m., her parents know something was wrong and they immediately contact the McAllen Police Department.

The next morning, Easter Sunday, police find Irene's car. It's parked down the street from the church. But for the rest of the day, there's still no sign of Irene. Still, her family is holding out hope. They know Irene has been talking to a few potential suitors and figure, maybe, while it's unlike her, she just ran off with one of them for a day or two. But on Monday, April 18th, new clues change that theory.

On the side of an empty stretch of road in McAllen, a passerby spots a small beige shoe. It's scuffed up and part of the heel seems to be missing.

It doesn't take long for Irene's parents to confirm it was the same one Irene was wearing when she left the house that Saturday night. Just a few hundred yards away, police locate another sign that Irene might be in great danger. It's hard too because you think, oh, I mean, my daughter's going to church, should be safe, nothing bad's going to happen, yada, yada, yada, and then now she's gone.

No one sees her leave the church. Then she goes missing and now her shoe is found. And then they find her black patent leather purse with her driver's license still inside. Okay. And just a little further north and just so. North. And just a little farther north, a piece of white lace crumpled and tossed in the brush similar to the veil Irene was last spotted in a church. Only there's no Irene.

So for the next several days, members of the local police spread out on horseback, combing the area for any sign of the young woman. They scan the 32 block radius surrounding the Sacred Heart Church where Irene was last seen. They even go knocking door to door around the area.

By day three, they've put together one of the most extensive manhunts in the history of the Rio Grande Valley area, complete with 70 members of the Hidalgo County Sheriff's Office, 65 National Guardsmen, two Border Patrol airplanes, and a team of divers combing the canals. Along the way, there are some alarming and strange leads. For example...

One woman calls the Garza home claiming to be Irene. She says she's been kidnapped and brought to a hotel in another town. What the freak? Why would someone do that? And this is the second case we've seen that kind of happening. Yeah. We're the, except the other case, it really probably was. Yeah. Yeah.

And I don't know if it's them this time, but it doesn't sound like it is. Well, detectives quickly do realize the call is a hoax. Then there's a man who tells a local waitress that he killed Irene and threatens to kill her next. After investigators look into the man, they find he's just overly intoxicated and not someone worth considering as an actual suspect. So they have a few leads that amount to absolutely nothing. That is until Thursday, April 21st.

At 7.40 a.m., the McAllen PD receive a call saying a woman's body had been spotted in the 2nd Street Canal, which is several miles away from where the other evidence, like Irene's shoe and purse, were discovered. By the time police arrived, an entire crowd had gathered to watch them remove the body from the water. The woman is still fully clothed, aside from her shoes and her underwear, and her blouse appears to be unbuttoned.

Her face is horribly bruised, including two black eyes. Still, it's clear enough to make out this is the body of Irene Garza. And the autopsy reveals even more about what may have happened to her in those missing hours. By the state of her decomposition, the pathologist believes she'd been dead for a little less than four days before she was discovered.

And since she's been missing for almost six days, this implied she might have been held captive for a day or two before she was killed. They also determined her cause of death was suffocation and that she'd been beaten by a hard object just before. There's also evidence that she was sexually assaulted at some point during her captivity. But the problem is, the autopsy is really the only clue they have to go off of.

Well, that and a partial men's shoe print that was left on the canal bank four blocks south of where Irene's body was discovered. Four blocks. I mean, that could be could be a little kid running around. Right. Well, anybody. It's hardly a smoking gun. Yeah. But police think maybe the culprit dropped her body off at the location of the footprint and she floated downstream. Oh,

However, any other evidence that might have been left behind, like blood or hair, would have been washed away by the time they pulled her from the water. But one thing is 100% clear. Detectives have a homicide on their hands. There's a killer loose in the McAllen area. And the Hidalgo County Sheriff promises they are going to leave no stone unturned. Which, oh, is so hard because there's a killer loose. Yeah.

But the last place she was seen was at church. Yeah. That's pretty disturbing. Could possibly be someone at the church. Hola. ¿Cómo está? Hola, ¿cómo estamos? Want to learn a new language? Well, the best way is to uproot your entire life, move to Spain, and live there for the rest of your...

I made that up. I went off the ad. Let me go back to the ad read. The best way is to uproot your entire life. Drop your... Oh. You literally followed the ad. I didn't read the rest of that. Drop yourself in the middle of a new country and figure it out from there. I just want to let everyone know that's what I did. But... That's what I did. It worked. If you're not ready for that, you can still learn a new language the next best way. And that is with Babbel. See...

Because talking is the key to really knowing any language.

Designed by real people for having real conversation, Babbel gets you talking. You guys, I actually use Babbel to brush up on Spanish when we travel. I love it. It is so easy. And then I can actually kind of keep up with what's going on. And with over 16 million subscriptions sold, Babbel's 14 award-winning language courses are backed by a 20-day money-back guarantee. So there's no pressure. Buy Babbel and travel.

Here's a special limited time deal for our listeners right now. Get up to 60% off your Babbel subscription, but only for our listeners at babbel.com slash husband. Get up to 60% off at babbel.com slash husband spelled B-A-B-B-E-L.com slash husband. Rules and restrictions may apply. Okay, let me guess. Your medicine cabinet is crammed with stuff that does not work. You still aren't sleeping, you still hurt, and you're stressed out. Okay.

That's how it was for me, so I cleared out my cabinet and reset my health with CBD from CB Distillery. CBD Distillery's targeted formulations are made from the highest quality clean ingredients, no fluff, no fillers, just pure effective CBD solutions designed to help support your health.

In two non-clinical surveys, 81% of customers experienced more calm, 80% said CBD helped with pain after physical activity, and an impressive 90% actually said they slept better with CBD. I have personally used CBD before to help me sleep. I used to have a lot of trouble sleeping and I couldn't figure out what to do to help. And honestly, CBD did help. And if that's something you're struggling with, give it a try. Check it out. If

If you struggle with a health concern and haven't found relief, make the change like I did to CBD Distillery. And with over 2 million customers and a solid 100% money back guarantee, CBD Distillery is the source to trust. You guys, we have a 20% discount to get you started. So if you've ever wanted to do CBD, now is the time. Visit CBDistillery.com and use code husband for 20% off. That's CBDistillery.com.

Now, this is practically unheard of nowadays, but the mayor of McAllen seems so committing to finding Irene's killer that he offers the police a blank check for the investigation. This way they have, quote, Oh, wow.

Even the locals lend resources to solve Irene's crime. Small businesses around town offer reward money to anyone who might have any valuable information. And over the next few weeks, detectives interview about 500 people from Irene's family and friends to anyone who saw her at church that final evening. They even map out the entire confession line, who was standing in front of who and so forth. So they're basically putting together her last night at church.

On top of that, they interrogate a variety of sex offenders in the area, spanning as far as 700 miles west to El Paso, Texas. So needless to say, the investigation seems incredibly thorough at the beginning.

But rumors about the culprit are spreading like wildfire throughout the town. Some wonder if Irene's murderer might have been a heartbroken suitor, seeing as many men around town were very interested in her. Others suspect that it was this prominent McAllen citizen who had died just a few days after Irene's disappearance of a heart attack. But the one theory many people are thinking, but no one is saying out in the open, is what if Irene's killer was a holy man? Yep.

So several days after Irene's body is found, investigators drain the canal along 2nd Street looking for any further clues.

Lying only a few feet away from where they discovered the man's shoe print, they find a light green Kodaslide viewer with a long cord. This is basically one of those old-fashioned projector systems that you could put two-by-two photos in and display bigger on a wall for people to see your family vacation or wedding photos or whatever. Got it. It's so hard because I think nowadays nothing surprises us. Right. Like anybody can kill someone. Right.

But I feel like it didn't used to be like that. Especially in the 60s. Yeah, it was like, oh, they are a priest or they go to church or they are a cop or they are someone in a respectable, whatever you want to consider respectable position. You're like, oh, they would never do that. And nowadays it's like.

Nothing surprises us. It could be anybody. We looked at them first, you know? It could be the President of the United States. Like, nothing surprises us these days. So police believe the murderer might have used the cord from this machine to bind Irene's hands or to keep her body submerged. So this becomes a critical clue. Problem is, they don't have any idea who this thing belongs to. So they ask the public for their help in finding the owner. And shockingly, one man comes forward saying,

Yeah, that's mine. He's a 27-year-old priest named John Feit. Now, Father Feit was new to the McAllen area. He had just finished his seminary school in San Antonio, Texas, and he was only supposed to be in McAllen for a year of pastor training. Many of the locals liked him because he gave his sermons in Spanish and

and did it well. But others said the dark-haired priest with horn-rimmed glasses was also kind of a bit aloof. Even worse, he almost seemed unsure about his commitment to his faith. When one parishioner asked him why he wanted to become a priest, Fite said, "'I just wanted to give it a try.'"

Ironically enough, Father Fight also happened to be one of the priests hearing confessions at the Sacred Heart the night Irene disappeared. It seems interesting that he came forward. It doesn't make me very suspicious of him because he came forward. I agree. And several parishioners who waited in his line that evening claimed the queue moved slowly and that Fight seemed to disappear from the church several times that night. Well,

Well, in May 1960, police call Father Fite in for questioning, and his story changes a few times. At first, he says Irene approached him in the rectory that evening, which is like the private housing section of the church meant only for the clergy. He claims there Irene wanted to discuss a question of conscience.

After this, he sent her to the sanctuary to make her confession, which is the more appropriate place for these matters. But later, he changes his story. He says he did hear Irene's confession in the rectory, which would have been considered a really inappropriate thing for him to do. And that's why he kept it to himself originally. Still, he claims after he heard her confession, Irene left around 7.15 or 7.20 p.m.,

Then, Fite returned to the sanctuary of the church and continued hearing other parishioners' confessions for the next several hours with a few cigarette breaks. At some time during the confessions, Father Fite said he broke his glasses while he was playing around with them, which...

Now he broke his glasses the same night she disappeared. It's just. Yeah, I know. It's suspicious. I was watching something yesterday and it was like, is there really coincidences? Yeah. You know, it's true. Like how many things can actually be a coincidence?

So at about 10 p.m., he drove to where he was staying to grab another pair of glasses about five miles away in San Juan at the pastoral house. But when he got there, he found that he had forgotten his keys and the doors were locked. So he had to scale the building to the second floor balcony to let himself in. So now he's a rock climber?

And during this process, he says he scraped the back of his hands. That's why there's scrapes on them. Getting creative. Now, this detail is actually later corroborated by another priest at the Sacred Heart, Father O'Brien.

He claims that when the clergymen gathered after their midnight mass, he noticed Father Fite had these strange markings on the back of his hands. But if he got them from climbing a brick wall, then why were there scrapes on the back of his hands and not the palms? Well, police also clocked this as suspicious, but they let Fite continue with his account.

He says on Easter Sunday, he gave two morning masses and an afternoon mass. But later in the day, he was approached by Irene's parents who heard he was one of the last people to see her. They asked whether he might have said something to Irene that could have upset her, and he told them there wasn't anything he could think of. He also tells police that this conversation with her parents was so upsetting that he drove aimlessly around town after and couldn't return immediately back to the pastoral house.

Now, the police are obviously considering Fite as a potential suspect at this point. But they are also keeping this pretty hush-hush. Because in a town like McAllen, you don't just talk about the church or priests in this way, especially in the 60s. It's blasphemy to infer that a man of God would have done something as sinful and unholy as murdering one of his parishioners. So until they have more information, the fact that Fite is a suspect is not made public.

However, it's around this time they learn of a similar attack, one that happened just a few weeks before Irene Garza went missing. So back on March 23, 1960, a woman named Maria America Guerra visited another Sacred Heart church just 12 miles away in Edinburgh, Texas. When she entered the church, she noticed a young priest with dark hair and horn-rimmed glasses sitting in one of the back pews all by himself.

Maria was at the altar praying when a man snuck up behind her, grabbed her, and tried to smother her with a rag. She bit down on the man's fingers, drawing blood, which ultimately helped her escape. She bolted out of the church, screaming and yelling for help. She never got a look at the man's face, but she did see he was wearing black pants, just like a clergyman. Okay.

Maria felt certain the person who attacked her was the same priest who'd been sitting in the back pew when she arrived. The father in the horn-rimmed glasses. After police learn about Maria's attack, they call Father Fite back in for questioning. I mean, things are just not looking good for him. It's interesting because, I don't know, why did he say that cord was his? Right. Like, why would you do that?

They get him to admit that he was in fact at the Sacred Heart in Edinburgh on March 23rd for a meeting with another priest. So now he's admitting that he was at the same Sacred Heart where the girl before was attacked. However, he claims he left before the time of the attack and was back at his house in San Juan by that point.

When his fellow priests are questioned, they admit they saw the bite mark on his finger right after the attack. But Feit says he got it stuck in a mimeograph machine just a few days before March 23rd. Oh, okay. Now I'm done with these coincidences. This was despite the fact that the rest of the clergymen said they didn't see the injury until the night of the attack.

His fellow priests also insist fight wasn't back at the house before the time of the attack, like he had claimed. So they don't hold up his alibi. Got it. But ultimately father fight denies having anything to do with Maria or Irene's attacks. Still things don't go exactly fights way. In August, 1960, he's indicted for assault with attempted rape against Maria, though it takes another two years for John fight to have his day in court. And he's not going to be able to do that.

And inevitably, Fight finds himself facing a hung jury. Instead of going on to a second trial, he pleads no contest, which means he's not admitting he's guilty, but he accepts whatever the conviction is. This helped him reduce his charges, and Fight is only slapped with a $500 fine for that attempted attack. Wow. It doesn't surprise me, though. One, because of his position. Two... It was just an attempt. Yeah.

Which is so messed up because would he have killed her? Right. The attempts are so hard to me with the justice system because... They just got unlucky. Yeah. Like, he probably would have killed her. Yeah.

It's insane. Keep in mind, this is just for Maria's case, the attempted attack. She got away. She bit him and got away. There's still no movement, nor are police getting any closer to charging fight in Irene's death, though they think he's responsible. And over time, Irene's case stalls out. Detectives move on to other cases and newspapers on to other stories. Men

Many begin to wonder, was there some sort of backdoor deal that's been made between the church and the state? Like, how have they not charged him? Or are detectives just afraid to harshly prosecute a man of God? Either way, it seems like fight is getting off easy, and he kind of is. The Catholic Church ships Fidoff to a monastery in Iowa, then Missouri, as part of a rehabilitation program.

Rehabilitation? Now, you killed someone, so let's just move you around a little bit. Yeah. He's later moved to a treatment center for troubled priests in New Mexico. For Christmastime,

For context, this is the same treatment center where the infamous father James Porter was sent after he abused as many as 100 children during his time with the church. Holy crap. However, in 1972, Fite leaves the priesthood altogether. He moves to Phoenix, Arizona, gets married, and has three children. For the next 30 years, John Fite gets to live an ordinary, quiet life as an insurance salesman. Okay.

But in April 2002, the San Antonio Police Department receives a call that changes everything.

The caller claims to be a former priest who's now living in Oklahoma City, and they have information about a murder that occurred in the Texas area in the 1960s. The man says in 1963, he was living at a monastery in Missouri where he counseled a young priest from San Antonio. The priest confessed to this man that he had attacked and killed a woman over Easter weekend.

Now, the timing of this call is interesting because 2002 was the same year the Boston Globe exposed several Roman Catholic priests for sexually abusing minors. It became a huge national scandal that proved there were cover-ups happening in Catholic churches across the country and inevitably led to 249 criminal cases. I think it's interesting that

They would confess that probably because of their beliefs. But at the same time, it's like you killed someone. I don't know. You know what I'm saying? So the San Antonio police are cautious about this phone call because maybe this person just has something against the Catholic church and thinks now's the time to come out because so many people are, or maybe this person has been harboring this secret for some time. And with the current climate, they feel, okay, it's time. I can finally come forward.

What they don't realize is that over in the Texas Rangers new cold case unit, one detective named Rudy Jaramillo has also just reopened Irene Garza's case.

Problem is, Jaramillo doesn't have a lot to work with since there wasn't any DNA collected during the initial investigation. And many of the detectives who originally investigated the case are now either deceased or retired. Still, Jaramillo's suspicions are firmly locked on the original suspect, John Fite. But he is also looking to answer some of the other lingering questions, like where was Irene killed?

And how long before her body was dumped in that canal? For months, Jaramillo has no idea that some of those answers are hiding in a file owned by the San Antonio Police Department. Then in November 2002, word finally reaches him. The San Antonio PD is working on the same case. They need to now compare notes.

Wow.

So Jaramillo and his team begin building a new case against Fite, and their first stop is tracking down the Oklahoma priest who called in, a man named Del Tacony, who is now their star witness. Tacony makes the drive to San Antonio to meet with Jaramillo to tell him the entire story, and it goes something like this.

In the summer of 1963, a superior of his at the Our Lady of Assumption Abbey in Avva, Missouri, told him a new troubled priest was joining their ranks. Takeney began counseling John Fite, and over the next six months, Fite opened up to him slowly about the crimes he'd committed. Fite told Takeney that a young woman had come to him on Easter weekend to give her confession.

Instead of hearing her confession in the booth, however, Feit convinced her to come to the rectory instead. After hearing her confession there, he moved Irene to the rectory basement because he knew it had thick walls and no one would hear her scream from down there. There, he restrained her, removed her blouse, and fondled her. Then he took a break to return to the church to hear more confessions to try to establish an alibi, leaving Irene in the basement tied up and unbuckled

Yeah. Just hurt. It's that time of the year. Your vacation is coming up. You can already hear the beach waves, feel the warm breeze, relax, and think about work. You really, really want it all to work out while you're away. Monday.com gives you and the team that peace of mind. When all work is on one platform and everyone's in sync, things just flow wherever you are. Tap the banner to go to Monday.com.

Shopify is the global commerce platform that helps you sell at every stage of your business. From the launch online shop stage, the first real life store stage, all the way to the did we just hit a million orders stage. Shopify is there to help you grow. Shopify helps you turn browsers into buyers with the internet's best converting checkout up to 36% better compared to other leading commerce platforms.

and sell more with less effort thanks to Shopify Magic, your AI-powered all-star. Peyton and I love Shopify. We have been using it for, I mean, I've been using it for six years now, so many years, and it's amazing. It just keeps getting better and better with more updates. It's easy to use. It's user-friendly. Shopify powers 10% of all e-commerce in the US, and Shopify is the global force behind Allbirds, Rothy's, and Brooklyn, and millions of other entrepreneurs of every size across 175 countries.

Sign up for a $1 per month trial period at shopify.com slash husband, all lowercase. Go to shopify.com slash husband now to grow your business no matter what stage you're in. Shopify.com slash husband.

Later that evening, after all of the parishioners had left, he moved Irene to the pastoral house where he was staying just a few miles away. Then, Fights told Takeney, on Easter Sunday, he placed her in a bathtub and put a bag over her head before leaving for church to give Mass. He claimed to hear Irene crying out as he left, I can't breathe, I can't breathe.

By the time Fight returned from church that afternoon, Irene was dead. Later that night, on Easter Sunday, Fight placed Irene's body in his car and moved her to the canals where he left her. Takeney said that when Fight described the crime to him, he showed no remorse, sorrow, or grief over the act. That is insane. Also, it was planned. And also, like, he's literally leaving a girl behind.

In a basement tied up with her blouse open to go hear confessions. Which is so like the most hypocritical thing I've ever heard of. And then leaving her in a bathtub, walking out, hearing her say, I can't breathe. I can't breathe for her to die while he goes and gives mass. Also, who knows how many other people he's done this to. Right. Maybe not killed them, but sexually assaulted.

No way. Yeah.

He was approached by a writer who wanted to pen a book about his life, and Takene realized that this information shouldn't be exposed through his memoir. It needed to be told to the police. Wow. Dale Takene wasn't the only valuable witness Camarillo tracked down, though. Would he get in trouble because he's kept it a secret so long?

Or I assume he said, look, I'll tell you everything if we come to a deal that. I'm sure. I mean, he could probably get charged with obstructing of justice, getting, you know, involved with a case. Yeah, yeah.

I don't think he did. So the detective locates another priest who'd worked with Fyte at the Sacred Heart Church the weekend Irene went missing. His name was Father O'Brien. He was the same priest who had noticed the suspicious scratch marks on Fyte's hands, the ones he claimed he got by scaling the walls. Well, it turns out that Father O'Brien was so suspicious of Fyte that weekend that he and another priest actually searched the rectory for Irene once they heard she was missing, only they found no sign of her.

How did he get out of there with not one other person seeing him? It's kind of crazy. Yeah, that seems impossible. But like Del Takeney, O'Brien didn't go to the cops because of this unspoken protection that he was seemingly granted to anyone inside the church. O'Brien did, however, say that back in 1960, he confronted Fite to ask him what had happened to Irene. And Fite confessed to Father O'Brien he had, in fact, killed Irene. Wow.

And that's when they sent fight off to the monastery. That's insane. They knew. That's not okay. Right? That is not okay. So with O'Brien's account confirming a lot of what Takeney had said, Jamarillo thinks he's got a strong case on his hands. I think it's even...

Pretty crazy as well that instead of releasing him completely, they sent him somewhere to continue to practice. Yeah. Like, oh, we can quote unquote fix you, whatever you want to call it. Yes. Like, did you just... He killed one of the prisoners. He just SA'd someone and killed them. Yeah.

After attacking another girl. It's like the worst thing you can do. So at the very least, they feel like they have enough to arrest John Fight, who is now 70 years old, mind you. Only the Hidalgo County District Attorney, a man named Rene Guerra, thinks the case doesn't stand a chance in court. What? Yeah.

Yes, Guerra doubts Takene's account, saying it's possible he made the whole thing up since Takene himself was excommunicated from the church for getting married before he'd formally left the priesthood. Oh, so we'll excommunicate someone for getting married, but if you kill someone, nah, you're good. Guerra also claims that O'Brien's case won't be admissible in court because the conversations he had with Fite during his priesthood was privileged.

Okay. And I want to clarify here, Garrett and I aren't dissing the Catholic church by any means or dissing these specific people who covered up a

a crime and made these choices. The truth is, it seems like not much has changed in Hidalgo County over the last four decades because they're still kind of like, eh, that was clear information. We're not going to use it against him. People like Guerra are still hesitant to prosecute a man of God, especially without any physical evidence and especially with a case this old. Inevitably, Guerra says he won't be presenting the case to the grand jury, which means Irene Garza's case goes cold again.

At least until Guerra leaves his post as DA and is replaced by a man named Rick Rodriguez in 2015. That year, Rodriguez takes his seat as the new county DA. One of his first orders of business is to finally get justice for the Garza family. But time hasn't made that easy. Father O'Brien, one of their last remaining witnesses, dies.

back in 2005, just three years after the case had been reopened originally. And Del Takney is now 87 years old. John Fite is also still alive at 83 years old, living in the Scottsdale, Arizona area. He's now a grandfather. They've lived their life. Yes. Right.

Or he's lived his life. Still, this doesn't stop Rodriguez from moving forward with the case. He brings it before a grand jury, and this time, Fight is indicted for his crimes. In February 2016, he's finally arrested in Arizona and extradited back to Texas for a trial. In March, the 83-year-old Fight enters the courtroom using a walker and pleads not guilty to the murder of Irene Garza.

By this point, Fite is also riddled with stage three kidney and bladder cancer. Wow. So there's questions as to whether he'll even go on to see the verdict. Yeah.

Aside from Del Takney, one of the witnesses called to the stand is Irene's childhood friend, Anna Marie Hollingsworth. She recalls a conversation she had with Irene just before she disappeared that Easter weekend. Allegedly, Irene had told Anna Marie that she didn't like going to confession anymore because fight always pulled her out of the booth, saying the space wasn't good enough for her.

Apparently, he had taken her to the rectory a few times before that day to hear her confession, which was something that made Irene uncomfortable. While Irene was confused about Fite's insistence on the matter, she always went, though...

Because it was his instruction. After all, this was a priest. She had no reason to feel unsafe or threatened by a man of God. During the trial, the prosecution also offers up evidence that proves a deal was struck between law enforcement, local officials, and the church to keep Fite's crime a secret. Insane. That's not okay. The evidence comes in the form of a letter from October 1960, one that was sent between clergy officials.

It expresses concerns, particularly over John F. Kennedy's presidential election that year. It basically says if the church is found to be tied up in a murder, it could jeopardize Kennedy, a Catholic man, and his chances of becoming president. Wow, this is deep. I just thought so ironic that at the beginning you said...

Yeah, it could even be our own president. And now this is literally part of the reason they covered it up. So in order to protect Kennedy, as well as another local Catholic sheriff that was also up for reelection that year, the DA made a deal. If Fite pled guilty to assaulting Maria America Guerra, they would look the other way when it came to Irene Garza's death, which is exactly what happened. The church agreed, and as part of it, sent Fite away to Monastery for Rehabilitation.

That letter seemed to be all the evidence the jury needed because in December 2017, they found John Fite, now 85, guilty of murder. He was sentenced to life in prison. Fite was eligible for parole in 2024, but in February 2020, he was found unresponsive in his cell. John Fite's cause of death was said to be cardiac arrest.

The most heartbreaking part is Irene Garza went to church on that Holy Saturday with her whole life still ahead of her. Her journey was cut off too soon by a man she should have been able to trust in a place she should have felt safe. Instead, Irene Garza and the entire community of McAllen were betrayed, but her story was not in vain. Her

Her case has helped to expose a dark corner of the Catholic Church, one that is often riddled in cover-ups, corruption, and its own personal agenda. Thanks to Irene, organizations like bishopsaccountability.org are continuing to fight for justice for those that have been wronged by the Catholic clergy abuse crisis. And that is the case of Irene Garza. It's sad that you think you're sending, you know,

You think your kids are going to somewhere safe and they aren't. Whether, you know, it's a church, whether it's a daycare school. Summer camp. You know, all these places where...

Kids are supposed to be safe. Yeah. And they just. It's part of the reason we see people pretend to be cops and pull people over. And then that's how they attack them or pretend to be doctors. I mean, there's just should be this level of trust. Or teachers getting in trouble. You know, it's just there's this level of authority and trust that's so abused. And I also find it interesting that.

He got married, had kids, and, like, lived a life without doing... I mean, who knows if he was sexually assaulting anyone. But you know what I'm saying? He just went on. Yeah, just went on. Which I tend to not believe. I think there was probably other stuff going on. Even if it wasn't, like, full...

Killing somebody. Yeah. Or sexual assault. He was most likely making women feel uncomfortable. Yeah, he's not a good person. It's a common thing we see. Yeah. And because he was making Irene feel uncomfortable before he even murdered her. She obviously confided in a friend saying, I'm really uncomfortable when I go in for confession because he always pulls me out. Yeah. So it's just heartbreaking and it's also completely unfair that he got to go on, live his life, get married, have kids, have grandchildren, and she didn't. Yeah, okay.

Agreed. All right, you guys, that is our case for this week and we will see you next time with another one. I love it. And I hate it. Goodbye.