Home
cover of episode The Authors of “How Democracies Die” on the New Democratic Minority

The Authors of “How Democracies Die” on the New Democratic Minority

2024/11/18
logo of podcast The Political Scene | The New Yorker

The Political Scene | The New Yorker

Key Insights

Why shouldn't voters be expected to defend democracy on their own?

Voters prioritize more immediate concerns over abstract principles or procedures. Democracy requires protection by elites and institutions, not just voters.

What are the key threats to democracy according to Levitsky and Ziblatt?

The transformation of the Republican Party under Trump, efforts to limit access to the ballot, and violent threats against election workers and officials.

How do Levitsky and Ziblatt view the Electoral College's impact on democracy?

The Electoral College distorts the democratic process, leading to outcomes like the 2016 election where the winner of the popular vote did not win the presidency.

What reforms do Levitsky and Ziblatt propose to strengthen democracy?

Reforms include automatic voter registration, eliminating gerrymandering, abolishing the Senate filibuster, term limits on the Supreme Court, and replacing the Electoral College with a direct popular vote.

Why do Levitsky and Ziblatt believe the U.S. is at greater risk than other democracies?

The U.S. has unique institutions like the Electoral College and the Senate that disproportionately favor minority rule, making it more susceptible to democratic backsliding.

What indicators would signal a significant threat to democracy under a Trump administration?

Indicators include the use of government agencies to intimidate or punish political opponents, changes in behavior of key societal actors like media and business, and efforts to weaken the civil service.

How do Levitsky and Ziblatt view the long-term viability of democracy as an idea?

Democracy is constantly challenged but has historically proven to be the best system for protecting civil liberties and allowing peaceful transitions of power.

Chapters

Los autores discuten la condición actual de la democracia en los Estados Unidos y su deterioro desde la publicación de su libro en 2018.
  • La democracia en EE. UU. ha experimentado un declive significativo según las mediciones internacionales.
  • EE. UU. ahora se califica como menos democrático que Argentina según Freedom House.
  • Los autores destacan la necesidad de mejorar las instituciones democráticas.

Shownotes Transcript

American voters have elected a President) with broadly, overtly authoritarian aims. It’s hardly the first time that the democratic process has brought an anti-democratic leader to power. The political scientists Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt, who both teach at Harvard, assert that we shouldn’t be shocked by the Presidential result. “It’s not up to voters to defend a democracy,” Levitsky says. “That’s asking far, far too much of voters, to cast their ballot on the basis of some set of abstract principles or procedures.” He adds, “With the exception of a handful of cases, voters never, ever—in any society, in any culture—prioritize democracy over all else. Individual voters worry about much more mundane things, as is their right. It is up to élites and institutions to protect democracy—not voters.” Levitsky and Ziblatt published “How Democracies Die)” during Donald Trump’s first Administration, but they argue that what’s ailing our democracy runs much deeper—and that it didn’t start with Trump. “We’re the only advanced, old, rich democracy that has faced the level of democratic backsliding that we’ve experienced. . . . So we need to kind of step back and say, ‘What has gone wrong here?’ If we don’t ask those kinds of hard questions, we’re going to continue to be in this roiling crisis,” Ziblatt says.