Yvonne moved to Panama with her boyfriend, Brian Brimager, seeking a fresh start and a break from the corporate lifestyle in California.
Brian was a decorated Marine who served over seven years in the Marine Corps, stationed at Camp Pendleton.
Yvonne's family was initially cautious due to the rapid progression of the relationship and her recent divorce, but they were happy to see her happy.
Michelle became suspicious when Yvonne's communication with the family dwindled significantly, and she received a text from Brian claiming they had broken up.
Michelle discovered that the emails supposedly from Yvonne were being sent from Dana Point, California, where Brian had been living, not from Panama.
The FBI confronted Brian with the evidence of the IP addresses showing that the emails were sent from Dana Point, not Panama.
The FBI found a Yahoo search for 'how to clean bloodstain on mattress' on Yvonne's laptop, suggesting a violent incident had occurred.
The FBI found Yvonne's DNA on the machete Brian had tried to sell, linking him directly to her murder.
Michelle, despite being terminally ill, participated in a deposition against Brian, providing crucial testimony about her sister's disappearance and murder.
Brian was sentenced to 26 years in federal prison for the murder of Yvonne, with a possibility of release when he is 66 years old.
In the fall of 2011, a 41-year-old California woman set out for a new life on a beautiful island in Panama. But what seemed like an adventurous fresh start quickly took a turn for the worse when she suddenly disappeared without a trace. As her family’s concern grew, a horrible story of abuse and manipulation began to surface. As investigators looked for any sign of her, they soon uncovered a trail of lies, fake emails, hidden relationships and shocking evidence that pointed to a murder. This is the story of Yvonne Baldelli.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices)