Deep Dive
Shownotes Transcript
It's been a rough week for your retirement account, your friend who imports products from China for the TikTok shop, and also Hooters.
Hooters has now filed for bankruptcy, but they say they are not going anywhere. Last year, Hooters closed dozens of restaurants because of rising food and labor costs. Hooters is shifting away from its iconic skimpy waitress outfits and bikini days, instead opting for a family-friendly vibe. They're vowing to improve the food and ingredients, and staff is now being urged to greet women first when groups arrive. Maybe in April of 2025, you're thinking...
Does the world still really need this chain of restaurants? But then we were surprised to learn of who exactly was mourning the potential loss of Hooters. Straight guys who like chicken, sure. But also a bunch of gay guys who like chicken? Why exactly that is coming up on the show today.
Hey there, it's Noelle with some exciting news for those of you who do not care to listen to the ads on Today Explained. If you become a Vox member, you can now get Today Explained ad-free.
You can also get unlimited articles on the Vox website, vox.com. You can get member-exclusive newsletters and even more special perks to be determined as a thank you. Vox, you should know, is an independent publication. This means we rely on support from listeners such as yourself.
to produce journalism that we believe the world really needs right now. At Vox, we want to help you understand what is going on, not just that, why it is going on. And so we report on big, important issues that shape our world and also essential stories that other people neglect.
If you would like to support our work, let's be honest, if you want to listen ad-free, go to Vox.com slash members today. That's Vox.com slash members. This message comes from Rinse.
These days, you can do a lot from your phone. Book a vacation, trade stocks, but you can also make your dirty laundry disappear and then reappear washed and folded with rinse.
Schedule a pickup with the Rinse app and before you know it, your clothes are back, folded, and ready to wear. They even do dry cleaning. Sign up now and get $20 off your first order at Rinse.com. That's R-I-N-S-E dot com.
Whatever you look for in a getaway, you can find it at Virginia Beach. When you're there, you'll be able to enjoy some of the best cultural attractions, activities, and culinary experiences the world has to offer. You could take a stroll on the world's longest pleasure beach that travels for miles and miles.
Or you could take part in their annual festivals, concerts, and waterfront dining. And if you're in the mood for dinner, make sure to check out their fresh local seafood with farm-to-table ingredients. It's a trip that everyone in the family will remember for a lifetime. Go to visitvirginiabeach.com to learn more.
Today Explained, Sean Ramos from here with Peter Rothpletz. Peter's a writer and recently, for the first time, he became a guy who writes about hooters. Yeah, well, actually, I was nursing a hangover in a small Colorado airport when I was just...
looking through Twitter and saw a report from Bloomberg that they were considering filing for bankruptcy. And it was at that point that while I was hurting, waiting for my plane, I shared a story about a lunch that I had with my grandfather more than a decade ago at a Florida Hooters. It was an annual tradition. I would fly down to Florida before the rest of my family just a few days before Thanksgiving so I would get to hang out with my grandfather a bit.
He would pick me up at the airport and we would then go out to lunch and chat about politics, chat about my soccer season, chat about changes to the Fox News primetime lineup. And this particular trip, I was 14 or 15. This was when I was just beginning to question my sexuality. I was just beginning to realize that I was gay. I don't think I had quite admitted it to myself yet.
but it was certainly top of mind. And then to walk into a Hooters, it was an experience. The Hooters waitress is not your average waitress. They are, objectively speaking, beautiful women, and they tend to be rather scantily clad.
They are extremely friendly, extremely welcoming. And all I can say is eating a meal at Hooters is unlike any dining experience I had ever had previously. And I can't quite compare it to anything I've done since. So we sat down for lunch. The meal was good, as I recall. We had chicken wings. Later on, my grandfather at one point gets up to use the restroom and says,
I remember just sweating and feeling so uncomfortable. And then out of the corner of my eye, I see our waitress who was very tall, was very blonde, a caricature of the caricature of the Hooters waitress. And she slides into the booth across from me. And I wish I remember exactly what she said, but I know it was something along the lines of, you're perfect just the way you are, kid. And it just meant the absolute world to me.
She saw something going on at that table between you and your grandfather. Yeah. I mean, who knows if it was how I held myself or how my voice quivered when I responded to her or how I never quite met her gaze or how I was just sweating my way through the lunch. But she could tell that I was not comfortable. And I don't know if that's because she actually clocked me as gay, but she...
could tell that I was hurting in that moment, and she wanted to help. And you shared this story while you were at the airport, hungover. I did. I really didn't think about it much. And then, of course, I get on the airplane. I don't have access to Wi-Fi. I land at LaGuardia some five hours later, and it had, I think it was already over 100,000 likes. What were people saying to you in response to this story you shared?
Part of the response I anticipated, I thought that folks would be charmed by the story, would find it sweet and sentimental. The part of the response that I did not anticipate was the deluge of direct messages from queer people who described very similar dynamics, very similar experiences,
I describe it in the piece as a baptism into manhood. Time and again, I saw the exact same refrain, conversion therapy with a side of ranch. These young men who didn't know what they were being brought into
being coaxed into the family sedan and driven to Hooters to ogle some breasts. Tell us specifically about stories you heard from people. Was it, like, just a carbon copy of your story, or were there, you know, some variations? A lot of them were similar, but there was a great deal of diversity as well. I note in the piece, Mike Dare said,
grew up in Omaha, Nebraska, and his father would take him to Hooters quite regularly. Mike told me that he was a very flamboyant little boy. It was clear from an early age that he was queer. And this one particular meal was seared into his memory. He recalled his dad asking
two Hooters waitresses to take a photo with him kissing him on the cheeks. And as he recounts it to me, they look at him, can tell he's uncomfortable and say, "We think he'd prefer this instead." They gave him bunny ears. And then as they're walking away, one of them turns around to wink at him.
And as he describes it to me, from that moment forward, he viewed Hooters as his safe space. And I'm quoting him there. He said it was his quote unquote safe space after that dinner. He looked forward to going to Hooters. Wow. Amazing. This one gentleman I spoke with shared how when he was just nine years old, his parents took him to a Hooters in Atlantic City. Wow.
And as he expressed it to me, it was very obvious that he was gay. And his parents kept encouraging him to flirt with their waitress. In fact, they pushed the waitress to flirt with him, again, a nine-year-old child. And later in the meal, he excuses himself to use the restroom again.
The waitress finds him, kneels down and asks him if he's okay. He says yes. She smiles. And as he puts it to me, it was one of the most important moments of his life. And he still lives in Atlantic City. And every time he passes that Hooters, he thinks back on it and reflects on that moment.
I spoke to a number of Hooters waitresses, too, who echoed all of these accounts. Lucy Wilkinson, who's quoted in the piece, who's been a server at Hooters for a number of years, said that she has witnessed this phenomenon many, many times to the extent that she now goes out of her way to comfort the queer kids that she sees being brought in by their family members.
It's kind of funny to be having this conversation as we're hearing that Hooters is in some serious financial trouble. Have you heard from anyone who said like, wow, I really thought Hooters was all about something else. And I wish I had gone as a kid or as a teenager or even as an adult.
Yeah, what I've learned in the past week or so is that there is a hell of a lot of love for Hooters out there, particularly from queer folks. And it's especially funny because I think if you just look at pop culture from Saturday Night Live to American Dad to Joe Rogan, the Hooters waitress is not presented well. She is depicted as a dim person.
I say in the piece, vacant-eyed succubus, a wannabe Stepford wife. And what I heard time and again from all of these queer people in my inbox was that perception is a slander as lazy as it is persistent.
These women genuinely care, earnestly care about the folks who come into their restaurants and go out of their way to make everyone feel as comfortable and as welcome as possible, queer or not.
Peter's opinions about Hooters were published in the New York Times Opinions section. Currently, the piece is titled Why Dads Take Their Gay Sons to Hooters. But at one point, it was titled Failed Conversion Therapy with a Side of Ranch at Hooters. I prefer that OG title. Onward to the origins of this breasturant when we're Brack on Today Explained. ♪
Nowadays, you can do a lot from your phone. Things from booking a vacation, buying and trading stocks, even ordering a car for yourself. But did you know that you can make your dirty laundry disappear and then reappear washed and folded? Yup, and all it takes is rinse. You can schedule a pickup with the Rinse app, and before you know it, your clothes are back, folded, and ready to wear. They even do dry cleaning.
Sign up now and get $20 off your first order at Rinse.com. That's R-I-N-S-E dot com. Fox Creative. This is advertiser content from Mercury.
Thank you.
I've been a Mercury customer since 2022. From the beginning, it was just so clearly built for startups. Like there's all these different features in there, but also they don't overcomplicate it. Here's your balance. Here are your recent transactions. Here you can pay someone or you can receive money. These days, I use Mercury for everything like managing contractors, bill pay, expense tracking, creating credit cards for my employees. It's all in Mercury. Mercury is a great place to start.
Mercury, banking that does more. Mercury is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services provided by Choice Financial Group, Column NA, and Evolve Bank & Trust, members FDIC. Canva presents the killer of productivity. It was an ordinary workday until... Oh no, this meeting could have been an email. Run. Canva had a creative solve.
Get email. I'll just put the info the team needs in a Canva doc, and I'll make it visual with images, charts, and graphics. Bring productivity killers to justice with creativity. Love your work at Canva.com. Hey, kids. You want to do your dad a really big favor? Tell your mom you want to go to Hooters. I'm tired.
And Ty Matioski, a professor of anthropology at the University of Central Florida here in Orlando. And Ty, believe it or not, is putting the finishing touches on a book about Hooters.
and other restaurants like it. The Hooters brand originates in Clearwater, Florida, April 1st, April Fool's Day, 1983. This week? Yes, it's sort of an anniversary. Wow.
So did people think it was a joke? Yeah, and even the original owners behind the brand kind of saw the humor in six guys who really had no experience in terms of running and operating a restaurant, much less one that would go on to have such an iconic status. And so the actual name, Hooters,
surprisingly enough, was inspired by a Steve Martin bit from one of his comedy albums of the early 80s called What I Believe, a Patriotic Statement. And I believe in going to church every Sunday unless there's a game on. And he makes a comment about what he thinks this part of women's anatomy should be called. And you should only refer to them
It got off to a shaky start in October of 1983, but by the following year, it had reaped considerable success locally that then blew up nationally. Tell me how it gets there. How does it go from a potential April Fool's joke to blowing up nationally? The original Hooters 6 basically...
who had kind of blue-collar service sector jobs who wanted to find a place, according to them, where they could hang out, drink, and not get kicked out of the establishment. If you like what you see here on the outside...
You're gonna love what you'll see on the inside. Televised sports, beach shack atmosphere and ambience. The recipe for Hooters chicken wings is so secret, even our cooks aren't allowed to know it. Bar food that you could eat primarily with your hands and attractive, scantily clad servers. Hey kids, you want to do your dad a really big favor? Tell your mom you want to go to Hooters.
The original Hooters 6, when they initially launched the business, were looking for ways to drum up customers to get them to come into the restaurant. So they would do all types of guerrilla-type marketing things, dressing up in a crazy chicken suit. They would go out into traffic and try to direct people into the parking lot.
There was a famous kind of derelict boat that had been kind of half sunk in Tampa Bay. And one of the original Hooters 6 swam out there with a can of orange paint and a six pack and painted the word Hooters on it.
So this boat had a lot of visibility on the nearby roadway. And so people began to see it. So they were like fully committed to the brand and making people know about it. And I don't think you can argue with the results in terms of like the success it had in terms of getting people aware and familiar with the Hooters brand.
One of the things that kind of brought it to national attention was the 1984 Super Bowl was played in Tampa. Super Bowl 18, a matchup between the two best teams. Coach, Tom Flores. Yes, Mr. President. Congratulations. One of the standout players was a running back named John Riggins.
John Riggins kind of had this outsider, edgy, kind of rebel persona. Somehow he found Hooters in nearby Clearwater. Apparently he was spending a lot of time there rather than prepping for the Super Bowl. I'll start off by saying I'm bored, I'm broke, and I'm back. It somehow got national press.
By that point, you have this restaurant entrepreneur who became aware of the brand. He made them an offer that he would take the Hooters idea and concept nationwide. And so you have this kind of beginning of this split in the Hooters brand between two companies.
Hooters Incorporated, which is the original six owners, they would be the ones that oversee the Hooters in and around Tampa, Florida, as well as many in the Chicago area. And then Hooters of America, which became the kind of national brand for Hooters, and then would go on to have an international footprint within Chicago.
dozens of countries around the world. Over time, Hooters has kind of ebbed and flowed in terms of popularity, in terms of success, and was the bellwether brand for this whole genre, what is termed restaurants. And what exactly is the definition? A restaurant where women are... Kind of a variation of a stereotypical sports bar, right?
So it's a type of casual dining venue where beer drinking, where meat eating, where televised sports is foregrounded. But it's probably most known and well associated with the types of servers that are employed there.
The restaurant genre itself did pretty well in the years like immediately following the Great Recession. So you have the emergence of brands like Twin Peaks. Twin Peaks. Eats, drinks, scenic views. Tilted Kilt. Tilted Kilt. Pabunizuri. Colby.
And then multiple other brands that came out at the time. Maybe the peak of the genre itself would be the mid-2010s. Okay. After that, you have like this...
kind of convergence of forces that kind of put restaurants on the ropes, so to speak. You have, of course, Me Too and Time's Up, where these types of venues came under scrutiny in a lot of ways, because, you know, a lot of times the servers have to endure or are subject to unwanted advances, not so nice comments from patrons.
When we get, for example, a customer, it's like a couple, you'll be surprised, like, the minute the lady goes to the bathroom, he'll ask you for your number or something like that. You have, like, this kind of power differential between young wage-earning servers, female servers, who depend on their livelihoods for tips, with these kind of older, primarily male customers. This is just a restaurant to us. We're just waitresses, but to them, it's like...
You're an entertainer. So sometimes they're like, well, you're not getting this tip because you didn't entertain me. You know, it creates kind of this dynamic that has created problems. And this is how we get to Hooters declaring bankruptcy this week. Is Hooters Inc. the one declaring bankruptcy or is it Hooters of America? No, it is the Hooters of America. ♪
So the Hooters of America is the one that it was like had the wider geographic footprint international. It was the one that was more highly capitalized. The restaurants affiliated with Hooters of America were the ones that were experiencing, you know, the closures, the problems, things like this. Hooters Inc., the ones participating
primarily in Tampa area, as well as Chicago, have remained pretty solid. And now they're the ones that are looking to buy out their counterparts under the Hooters of America umbrella.
And so I guess it remains to be seen if they will be successful. It's a brand that now a lot of people have fond, perhaps, memories of. Even though their primary clientele is like a male 18 to 34, perhaps older demographic group,
families do go to Hooters. Parents take their children to Hooters. Grandparents take their grandkids to Hooters. You know, there are high chairs at Hooters. The Hooters gift shop sells onesies. So I think they recognize the reality of kind of the market situation. And, you know,
Really, no brand can be successful by just like focusing specifically on half of the population in order to thrive and be viable. You really have to have a, you know, broad broadening appeal. And do you think the original six owners of Hooters who came up with this concept in the first place and incorporated on April Fool's Day, 1983, did?
Had any idea that one day they'd be trying to, you know, better appeal to women and kids and be selling baby onesies?
Yeah, I mean, I think that would be a stretch to think they had any inkling that this would kind of become the iconic brand that we recognize today. I mean, that's kind of like what is notable and, you know, for some people special about the Hooters brand. You know, it's kind of like these guys decided to, you know, start this brand.
basically where they can hang out and be themselves. And it became this global phenomenon. Problematic phenomenon, of course, but nonetheless one that is an integral part of our corporate foodscape here in the U.S. and elsewhere. I would be sad mainly because of my coworkers. Like, I love them so much. And I love working with girls, all women, all genders.
And we're just like a family. And I feel like if we did close down tomorrow, then I probably wouldn't talk to them. I would, but it wouldn't be the same.
Ty Matioski is the author of the forthcoming Risqué Business Restaurants in American Culture. It drops in August, but you can make your reservation now. Our show today was produced by Victoria Chamberlain with a little help from our senior researcher, Laura Bullard, who visited a Hooters in her neighborhood for the very first time to talk to some servers for us. Yo, Hooters is like, I've never been in a Hooters before and...
Yeah, it's not going to be my last time. Those were the nicest women. Wow. It's such a lovely place. Jolie Myers edited, Patrick Boyd mixed, Avishai Artsy, Gabrielle Burbey, Hadi Mawagdi, Amanda Llewellyn, Carla Javier, Miles Bryan, Peter Balanon-Rosen, Andrea Christen's daughter, Devin Schwartz, Amna Alsadi, Miranda Kennedy, and Noelle King edited.
Make the show two with Breakmaster Cylinder on the ones and twos. Today Explained is distributed by WNYC. The show is a part of Vox. You can support our journalism by joining our membership program today. Go to vox.com slash members to sign up. And I'm pretty sure that's also how to get this show without ads, if you're interested.
You're a problem solver. You've never met a recipe that didn't need a tasty substitution or a room that couldn't use some rearranging. When it comes to keeping your floors clean, the solution is simple. The next generation of Roomba Robots.
The Roomba 205 Combo and Roomba Plus 405 Combo use a four-stage cleaning system for thoroughly clean floors. Roomba robots work so that you can think about more important things, like the perfect spot for that new ottoman. Roomba robots were made for this. Learn more at iRobot.com. That's I-R-O-B-O-T dot com.