Leslie Perloff left the law library at 3 p.m. to go to the hills west of Stanford University to scout a location for a painting she wanted to commission as a gift for her mother.
The police became concerned because Leslie's car was found parked in a remote area at 10 p.m., which was unusual, and she was not at home as expected. Her mother was worried because Leslie was very scheduled and had not called or left a note.
Leslie's body was found partially unclothed, with severe trauma and her pantyhose and underwear stuffed in her mouth. Her rain boots were found 75 feet away, and a scarf was used to strangle her.
The police believed the murders were connected due to the similar methods of attack, the victims' ages and genders, and the fact that both crimes occurred in remote areas with the victims' shoes removed and discarded.
Forensic genealogy and DNA testing were the breakthroughs. DNA from under Leslie's fingernails was matched to John Arthur Getrue using genetic genealogy and CODIS databases.
John Getrue had a history of violence against women, including a 1963 murder and sexual assault in Germany, a 1975 rape conviction in Palo Alto, and accusations of sexual assault while leading a Boy Scout post.
John Getrue denied any involvement in the murders despite the DNA evidence. He claimed it was a mistake and refused to provide an explanation, ultimately requesting a lawyer.
The arrests provided closure and a sense of justice for the families, particularly Leslie's sister Diane, who had been a tireless advocate for solving the case. However, the loss of their loved ones remained deeply painful.
A young woman left the law library and was never seen alive again. It would take years of persistence and advancements in technology to finally get the answers her family had waited decades to hear.
For episode information and photos, please visit: anatomyofmurder.com/similarly-tragic/
Can’t get enough AoM? Find us on social media!