Jack Smith Makes FINAL DECISION on Trump Dismissal
The MeidasTouch Podcast
Deep Dive
Why did Special Counsel Jack Smith move to dismiss the federal case against Donald Trump?
The Department of Justice determined that the Constitution prohibits the federal indictment and prosecution of a sitting president, which applies to Trump as he will be inaugurated in 2025.
What is the significance of the dismissal being 'without prejudice'?
It means the case could theoretically be brought again in the future when Trump is no longer president, though in reality, he is likely to pardon himself.
What role did the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) play in the decision to dismiss the case?
OLC provided a binding interpretation of the constitutional prohibition on indicting a sitting president, which the Department of Justice had to follow.
How did Jack Smith's personal integrity influence his handling of the case?
Smith, a career prosecutor with no political agenda, followed the legal mandate despite the difficulty of dismissing a strong case against a former president.
What impact might the dismissal have on the Manhattan DA's case against Trump?
The dismissal could influence the Manhattan DA's office, particularly regarding the supremacy clause and how it applies to state prosecutions, though the specifics remain uncertain.
- The DOJ dismissed the federal case against Trump due to his upcoming inauguration as president.
- The dismissal is without prejudice, meaning the case could be revived in the future.
- The decision was based on the Office of Legal Counsel's opinion, which is binding on the DOJ.
- The DOJ maintains its belief in the strength of the case despite the dismissal.
Shownotes Transcript